Ethics, organ donation and tax: a reply to Quigley and Taylor

Lippert-Rasmussen, Kasper; Petersen, Thomas Søbirk
August 2012
Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug2012, Vol. 38 Issue 8, p463
Academic Journal
A national opt-out system of post-mortem donation of scarce organs is preferable to an opt-in system. Unfortunately, the former system is not always feasible, and so in a recent JME article we canvassed the possibility of offering people a tax break for opting-in as a way of increasing the number of organs available for donation under an opt-in regime. Muireann Quigley and James Stacey Taylor criticize our proposal. Roughly, Quigley argues that our proposal is costly and, hence, is unlikely to be implemented, while Taylor contests our response to a Titmuss-style objection to our scheme. In response to Quigley, we note that our proposal's main attraction lies in gains not reflected in the figures presented by Quigley and that the mere fact that it is costly does not imply that it is unfeasible. In response to Taylor, we offer some textual evidence in support of our interpretation of Taylor and responds to his favoured interpretation of the Titmuss-style objection that many people seem to want to donate to charities even if they can deduct their donations from their income tax. Finally, we show why our views do not commit us to endorsing a free organ-market.


Related Articles

  • The Brain-Dead Organ Donor: A Missed Opportunity for Early Intervention. Danobeitia, Juan S. // Journal of Transplantation Techniques & Research;2012, Vol. 2 Issue 3, Special section p1 

    The author discusses the lack of attention given to the appropriate management of the heartbeating brain-dead organ donor. He criticizes the lack of clinical application of findings from therapy in animal models of brain death. He asserts that being brain-dead substantially impacts organ quality...

  • Elective ventilation for organ donation: law, policy and public ethics. Coggon, John // Journal of Medical Ethics;Mar2013, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p130 

    This paper examines questions concerning elective ventilation, contextualised within English law and policy. It presents the general debate with reference both to the Exeter Protocol on elective ventilation, and the considerable developments in legal principle since the time that that protocol...

  • Is providing elective ventilation in the best interests of potential donors? McGee, Andrew John; White, Benjamin Peter // Journal of Medical Ethics;Mar2013, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p135 

    In this paper, we examine the lawfulness of a proposal to provide elective ventilation to incompetent patients who are potential organ donors. Under the current legal framework, this depends on whether the best interests test could be satisfied. It might be argued that, because the Mental...

  • Sisters Share Special Bond After Rare Living-Donor Transplant.  // Ascribe Newswire: Medicine;4/23/2004, p44 

    Jessica Eveleth will celebrate her 21st birthday on April 20, but she's already received the gift of a lifetime. Her sister Jamie, 18, donated a segment of her small intestine to Jessica in a rare living-donor transplant at the University of Illinois Medical Center at Chicago on March 23.

  • Liver transplantation using 'donation after circulatory death' donors: the ethics of managing the end-of-life care of potential donors to achieve organs suitable for transplantation. Moorlock, Greg; Draper, Heather; Bramhall, Simon R. // Clinical Ethics;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p134 

    The decline in organs donated after brain death has been countered by an increase in organs donated after circulatory death. Organs donated after circulatory death present an increased risk of complications for their eventual recipients when compared with organs donated after brain death, so the...

  • Yes, Let's Pay for Organs. Krauthammer, Charles // Time;5/17/1999, Vol. 153 Issue 19, p100 

    Comments on organ donation in the United States. How Pennsylvania plans to reward organ donation; A federal law declaring organs as a national resource not subject to compensation; The shortage of organs for transplantation; The ethical issues regarding human beings and their parts; Free...

  • Is presumed consent the answer to organ shortages? NO. Wright, Linda // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);5/26/2007, Vol. 334 Issue 7603, p1089 

    The article presents the author's opinions on whether presumed consent, which assumes that deceased people want to donate their organs unless there is evidence to the contrary, will solve a shortage of organs which exists in Great Britain. Arguments are presented which suggest that presumed...

  • Xenotransplantation: Social, ethical, religious, and political issues. First, M. Roy // Kidney International Supplement;Mar1997, Issue 58, pS-46 

    Focuses on the consideration for alternative approaches to overcome shortage of donor organs available for transplantation. Feasibility and acceptability of xenotransplantation; Issues surrounding the use of animal species as donors in organ transplantation; Regulations of organs and tissues by...

  • Wanted, dead or alive... Parker, Shafer // Report / Newsmagazine (Alberta Edition);08/14/2000, Vol. 27 Issue 7, p16 

    Discusses government policy for organ and tissue donation in Ontario. Plan to increase spending to cover hospital costs for transplant operations; Ontario's need for increased donors; Number of Ontario residents waiting for organs as of August 2000; Why families are reluctant to donate the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics