Letter to the Editor: Commentary on Why Laryngeal Stroboscopy Really Works: Clarifying Misconceptions Surrounding Talbot's Law and the Persistence of Vision

Mehta, Daryush D.; Deliyski, Dimitar D.; Hillman, Robert E.
October 2010
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Oct2010, Vol. 53 Issue 5, p1263
Academic Journal
Purpose: The purpose of this article is to clear up misconceptions that have propagated in the clinical voice literature that inappropriately cite Talbot's law (1834) and the theory of persistence of vision as the scientific principles that underlie laryngeal stroboscopy. Method: After initial research into Talbot's (1834) original studies, it became clear that his experiments were not designed to explain why stroboscopy works. Subsequently, a comprehensive literature search was conducted for the purpose of investigating the general principles of stroboscopic imaging from primary sources. Results: Talbot made no reference to stroboscopy in designing his experiments, and the notion of persistence of vision is not applicable to stroboscopic motion. Instead, two visual phenomena play critical roles: (a) the flicker-free perception of light and (b) the perception of apparent motion. In addition, the integration of stroboscopy with video-based technology in today's voice clinic requires additional complexities to include synchronization with camera frame rates. Conclusions: References to Talbot's law and the persistence of vision are not relevant to the generation of stroboscopic images. The critical visual phenomena are the flicker-free perception of light intensity and the perception of apparent motion from sampled images. A complete understanding of how laryngeal stroboscopy works will aid in better interpreting clinical findings during voice assessment.


Related Articles

  • Timeless Advice from The Etude. Austin, Stephen F. // Journal of Singing;Sep/Oct2013, Vol. 70 Issue 1, p93 

    The article presents a reprint of the article "The Larynx, Its Position and Movements in Singing" by Herbert Saunders, which originally appeared in the January 1912 issue of "The Etude" Magazine. In the article the author discusses the importance of having opera singers perform with an open...

  • The Very First Cry: A Multidisciplinary Approach Toward a Model. Nicollas, Richard; Vicente, Jérome; Brutin, David; Giordano, Jerome; Medale, Marc; Giovanni, Antoine; Ouaknine, Maurice; Triglia, Jean-Michel // Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology;Dec2012, Vol. 121 Issue 12, p821 

    Objectives: In previous work, we showed that a rigid larynx-like geometry can generate a sound by itself. However, very little is known about the exact mechanisms and control of the larynx during the first cry of life. The goal of this work was to understand how the very first cry is generated....

  • Formantology. McCoy, Scott // Journal of Singing;Sep/Oct2013, Vol. 70 Issue 1, p43 

    The article discusses voice acoustics and harmonics found in singing, including the function and exploitation of formants, which are resonances of the vocal tract, which together could be referred to as the science of formantology. A discussion of the benefits that voice teachers and students...

  • Timely Orders: A New Viewpoint of the Vocal Onset and Release. Indik, Lawrence // Journal of Singing;Jan/Feb2015, Vol. 71 Issue 3, p297 

    The article presents a new perspective on vocal onset and release in January 2015. Topics covered include how the prevalent method for the analysis of vocal onset or vocal release uses the terms "too hard," "too soft," or "balanced," which is inherently subjective and inconsistent and how the...

  • Ventricular-Fold Dynamics in Human Phonation. Bailly, Lucie; Henrich Bernardoni, Nathalie; Müller, Frank; Rohlfs, Anna-Katharina; Hess, Markus // Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Aug2014, Vol. 57 Issue 4, p1219 

    Purpose: In this study, the authors aimed (a) to provide a classification of the ventricular-fold dynamics during voicing, (b) to study the aerodynamic impact of these motions on vocal-fold vibrations, and (c) to assess whether ventricular-fold oscillations could be sustained by aerodynamic...

  • The Female Primo Passaggio: A Survey of Its Physiology, Psychology, and Pedagogy. Blyskal, Elena // Journal of Singing;Sep/Oct2012, Vol. 69 Issue 1, p11 

    The article presents an overview of the physiology, pedagogy and psychology of the female primo passaggio in adolescent voice students and discusses the challenges that it poses for female voice students and for voice teachers who teach them. The opinions that several voice professionals,...

  • Glottal Reconstruction With a Tissue Engineering Technique Using Polypropylene Mesh: A Canine Experiment.  // Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology;Feb2010, Vol. 119 Issue 2, p110 

    Objectives: The larynx must be resected in some cases of cancer or stenosis, and various techniques are generally employed to fill the resulting defect. No ideal way, however, has been established to restore vocal function after this form of insult. The aim of this preliminary feasibility study...

  • Neuromuscular Basis for Ventricular Fold Function. Young, Nwanmegha; Wadie, Mikhail; Sasaki, Clarence T. // Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology;May2012, Vol. 121 Issue 5, p317 

    Objectives: We sought to examine the neuromuscular basis for ventricular fold function. The primary function of the ventricular folds is to assist in the regulation of intra-abdominal and intrathoracic pressure. They also influence phonation in the setting of vocal fold paralysis or ventricular...

  • Assessment of Phonation Threshold Pressure: A Critical Review and Clinical Implications. Plexico, Laura W.; Sandage, Mary J.; Faver, Katherine Y. // American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology;Nov2011, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p348 

    Purpose: To describe the origins of the task elicitation procedure for determining phonation threshold pressure and, through a literature review and online survey, describe published procedural, environmental, and participant variable departures from the original methodology. Method: Literature...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics