Patient preferences for care by general internists and specialists in the ambulatory setting

Lewis, Carmen L.; Wickstrom, Glenda C.; Kolar, Maria M.; Keyserling, Thomas C.; Bognar, Bryan A.; DuPre, Connie T.; Hayden, Juliana; Lewis, C L; Wickstrom, G C; Kolar, M M; Keyserling, T C; Bognar, B A; Dupre, C T; Hayden, J
February 2000
JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Feb2000, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p75
Academic Journal
journal article
Objective: To investigate patients' preferences for care by general internists and specialists for common medical conditions.Design: Telephone interview.Setting: A convenience sample of general internal medicine practices at 10 eastern academic medical centers.Patient/participants: A probability sample of 314 participants who had at least one visit with their primary care physician during the preceding 2 years.Measurements and Main Results: Items addressed patients' attitudes concerning continuity of care, preferences for care by general internists or specialists for common medical problems, and perceptions about the competency of general internists and specialists to manage these problems. Continuity was important to participants, with 63% reporting they preferred having one doctor. Respondents were willing to wait 3 or 4 days to see their regular doctor (85%) and wanted their doctor to see them in the emergency department (77%) and monitor their care while in the hospital (94%). A majority (>60%) preferred care from their regular doctor for a variety of new conditions. Though respondents valued continuity, 84% felt it was important to be able to seek medical care from any type of physician without a referral, and 74% responded that if they needed to see a specialist, they were willing to pay out-of-pocket to do so. Although most participants (98%) thought their regular doctor was able to take care of usual medical problems, the majority thought that specialists were better able to care for allergies (79%) and better able to prescribe medications for depression (65%) and low-back pain (72%).Conclusions: Participants preferred to see their general internist despite their perceptions that specialists were more competent in caring for the conditions we examined. However, they wanted unrestricted access to specialists to supplement care provided by general internists.


Related Articles

  • THE DYSPHAGIA HOTLINE.  // Gut;Apr2004 Supplement 3, Vol. 53, pA108 

    To determine the incidence of true dysphagia in patients referred with dysphagia under the 2 week rule and to assess the improvement in service a "dysphagia hotline" was piloted for 6 months. 92 patients were referred with dysphagia under the existing 2 week cancer guidelines. A telephone...

  • PERSPECTIVES: Principles to Consider in Defining New Directions in Internal Medicine Training and Certification. Turner, Barbara J.; Centor, Robert M.; Rosenthal, Gary E. // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Mar2006, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p276 

    SGIM endoreses seven principles related to current thinking about internal medicine training: 1) internal medicine requires a full three years of residency training before subspecialization; 2) internal medicine residency programs must dramatically increase support for training in the ambulatory...

  • Morbidity, Mortality, and Charges for Hospital Care of the Elderly: A Comparison of Internists' and Family Physicians' Admissions. McGann, K. Patricia; Bowman, Marjorie A.; Davis, Stephen W. // Journal of Family Practice;May95, Vol. 40 Issue 5, p443 

    Background. In an atmosphere of cost containment, an important question is whether there are differences in quality or cost of medical care provided by physicians with different specialty training. Methods. This study is an analysis of Pennsylvania hospital admissions from the 1989 MedisGroups...

  • Performance of a Web-Based Clinical Diagnosis Support System for Internists. Graber, Mark L.; Mathew, Ashlei // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jan2008 Supplement 1, Vol. 23 Issue S1, p37 

    Clinical decision support systems can improve medical diagnosis and reduce diagnostic errors. Older systems, however, were cumbersome to use and had limited success in identifying the correct diagnosis in complicated cases. To measure the sensitivity and speed of “Isabel” (Isabel...

  • The Effects of Physicians' Training and Personality on Test Ordering for Ambulatory Patients. Epstein, Arnold M.; Begg, Colin B.; McNeil, Barbara J. // American Journal of Public Health;Nov84, Vol. 74 Issue 11, p1271 

    We studied records of 351 hypertensive patients cared for by 30 internists in private office practice. We correlated the use of outpatient diagnostic tests with personal characteristics of the prescribing physicians. Doctors trained in medical schools with academic orientations used more tests...

  • Ethical Dilemmas in Providing Health Care to Workers. Rosenstock, Linda; Hagopian, Amy // Annals of Internal Medicine;Oct87, Vol. 107 Issue 4, p575 

    Deals with a study which discussed the ethical dilemmas in the delivery of health care to workers. Role of internist in occupational medicine; Integration of occupational health services with health services by internists; Relationship of physician and patients.

  • A shower in the desert of a patient's emotions. Livingston, Wiley // Cortlandt Forum;9/25/2003, Vol. 16 Issue 9, p13 

    Relates experience of the author as an internist with a special internist in infectious disease in the U.S. Comments on the duties of physicians; Remarks on the degree of freedom for various nursing units; Accounts on the importance of medical service.

  • Primary care physicians' attitudes regarding race-based therapies. Frank, Danielle; Gallagher, Thomas H.; Sellers, Sherrill L.; Cooper, Lisa A.; Price, Eboni G.; Odunlami, Adebola O.; Bonham, Vence L. // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;May2010, Vol. 25 Issue 5, p384 

    Background: There is little to no information on whether race should be considered in the exam room by those who care for and treat patients. How primary care physicians understand the relationship between genes, race and drugs has the potential to influence both individual care and...

  • Physician productivity: How FPs, IMs compare.  // Family Practice Management;Feb2000, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p22 

    Presents statistics on the productivity of family physicians and internists as of February 2000. Relative value units to determine Medicare reimbursement rates; Mean number of ambulatory encounters per year.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics