Estimating the magnitude and direction of bias in tuberculosis drug resistance surveys conducted only in the public sector: a simulation study

Cohen, Ted; Hedt, Bethany L.; Pagano, Marcello
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p355
Academic Journal
journal article
Background: Accurate assessment of the burden of drug-resistant TB requires systematic efforts to quantify its magnitude and trend. In approximately half the countries where resistance has been reported, estimates are based on surveys conducted in public sector facilities. However, in locations where a substantial fraction of TB cases seek care with private providers, these surveys may not accurately measure resistance in the entire population.Methods: We describe a mathematical model to investigate biases associated with sampling only from public sector cases in India, where TB treatment is offered in both public and private sectors. We then propose and demonstrate a weighted estimator as an efficient method for including small numbers of cases from the private sector as a way to recover valid estimates of resistance in the population under study.Results: We find that public sector surveys rarely provide valid estimates of drug-resistance among new and retreatment cases. Further, the magnitude and direction of the bias are sensitive to many parameters describing the health-seeking behaviours and treatment outcomes of tuberculosis patients, disallowing simple adjustments to recover accurate estimates.Conclusions: In locations where large numbers of tuberculosis patients are diagnosed and treated by private sector practitioners who are not typically included in drug resistance surveys, targeted surveys for assessing drug resistance are required to validly estimate resistance.


Related Articles

  • What Needs to be Done to Eradicate Tuberculosis. Rosen, George; Kimmey, James A. // American Journal of Public Health;Feb1972, Vol. 62 Issue 2, p127 

    The author reflects on the issue regarding the accomplishments in the control of tuberculosis in the U.S. 4.9% of the cattle tested reacted to tuberculin were sent to the rendering tanks because of tuberculosis in 1918. On the other hand, among people in 1920 almost no tuberculin testing was...

  • Plenary Lectures.  // Annals of Clinical Biochemistry;Jan2006 Supplement, Vol. 43, p1 

    Biosensors in medicine. C Lowe, Cambridge. 1 Molecular therapy for diabetes. L Chan, Houston, USA. 1 C-reactive protein and cardiovascular risk. N Rifai, Boston, USA. 1 The role of gut hormones in obesity and appetite regulation. C le Roux, London. 2 Good and bad for the bone. W D Fraser,...

  • Poor adherence not enough to cause development of MDR-TB. Carter, Michael // CME: Continuing Medical Education;Nov/Dec2011, Vol. 29 Issue 11/12, p482 

    The article details a laboratory study published in the online edition of the "Journal of Infectious Diseases" which suggests that poor adherence is not enough to cause multidrug-resistent tuberculosis (MDR-TB). According to the study, failure of management of tuberculosis results from extremely...

  • TUBERCULOUS PAROTITIS: CLINICAL EVALUATION OF TWO CASES. Akdag, Mehmet; Canbay, Ercan; Muderris, Suphi; Egilmez, Reyhan // Journal of International Dental & Medical Research;Dec2011, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p160 

    Although parotid gland involvement with tuberculosis is the most common among salivary glands tuberculosis, tuberculous parotitis is rare. Parotis tuberculous is clinically indistinguishable from a parotid tumour and also diagnostic techniques may fail to reveal the diagnosis. We have been...

  • Tuberculous tenosynovitis. Sanders, Clayton J.; Schucany, William G. // Baylor University Medical Center Proceedings;Jan2008, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p71 

    The article provides information related to Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Mycobacterium tuberculosis remain the top-10 cause of death worldwide. Tuberculosis is spread primarily by inhalation of infected droplets, resulting in pulmonary disease. Tuberculous tenosynovitis is a rare complication of...

  • Study of Psychiatric Morbidity among Pulmonary Tuberculosis Patients. Jagpal Singh Klair // International Online Medical Conference (IOMC) Conference Procee;2010, Vol. 1 Issue 1, p322 

    The article presents a research study which examines the onset of psychiatric morbidity among patients with pulmonary tuberculosis (PT) and assesses the impact of the disease on the quality of life. The study has utilized patients with PT who were diagnosed for lung cancer and screened at the...

  • Tuberculous encephalopathy: a reappraisal. Lammie, G. Alistair; Hewlett, Richard H.; Schoeman, Johan F.; Donald, Peter R. // Acta Neuropathologica;Mar2007, Vol. 113 Issue 3, p227 

    Forty years ago Dastur and Udani described a form of diffuse cerebral damage in tuberculosis, which they called tuberculous encephalopathy. Their pathological and clinical observations led them to propose an immune pathogenesis. Although there have been no convincing independently reported...

  • MDCT abnormalities of small- and medium-sized bronchus in active tuberculosis: a new angle on an old disease. Jin Kyoung Oh; Myeong Im Ahn; Jung Im Jung; Young Kyoon Kim; Eun-Jee Oh; Yeon-Joon Park; Dae Hee Han // Acta Radiologica;Mar2011, Vol. 52 Issue 2, p167 

    Background: The incidence and findings of tuberculous invasion of the peripheral bronchus have not been fully investigated with MDCT. Purpose: To evaluate the prevalence and findings of MDCT abnormalities of small- and medium-sized bronchus (SMB) in active pulmonary tuberculosis (TB). Material...

  • Comparative analysis for the detection of tuberculosis by conventional and flurosence microscopy. Ahmed, O.; Ahmed, Z. // Bangladesh Journal of Medical Science;Jul2013, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p315 

    Total of 300 TB patients sample were collected from NIDCH (Indoor and Outdoor) for six months period where three different specimens (sputum, pus, BAL) were collected among different age group (male and female). In sputum sample, percentage of identified samples in Auramine-O stain was 41%...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics