Is old-fashioned electroconvulsive therapy more efficacious? A randomised comparative study of bilateral brief-pulse and bilateral sine-wave treatments

Scott, Allan I.F.; Rodger, Colin R.; Stocks, Ruth H.; Shering, Anne P.; Scott, A I; Rodger, C R; Stocks, R H; Shering, A P
March 1992
British Journal of Psychiatry;Mar92, Vol. 160, p360
Academic Journal
journal article
In-patients suffering from major depressive disorder (endogenous subtype) were randomly allocated to treatment by either traditional ECT with constant-voltage modified sine-wave stimuli (n = 17) or modern, constant-current brief-pulse ECT (n = 14). All treatments were bilateral and monitored by simultaneous recording by EEG. The severity of depressive illness was assessed the day before treatment, after three treatments, and seven days after the last treatment. The improvement and final depression rating scores, the likelihood of recovery, and the average number of treatments received were virtually identical in the two groups. We concluded that the policy of bilateral suprathreshold modern ECT monitored by EEG is as efficacious as traditional ECT.


Related Articles

  • Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Proven and Contemporary Treatment. Loo, Colleen // Issues;Sep2007, Issue 80, p38 

    The article discusses the use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), a treatment approach for depression which uses a controlled seizure in the patient who is under anaesthetic. It cites several improvements made to these approach to achieve safer and more effective use of ECT. It is argued that...

  • The effects of pulse ECT in neurotic and endogenous depression. Carney, M. W. P.; Sheffield, B. F.; Carney, M W // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul74, Vol. 125, p91 

    The article presents the study that examines the response to pulse electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in the two varieties of depression. The results obtained from the pulse-treated patients was compared to 100 depressives consecutively treated with sinusoidal ECT immediately before this study. An...

  • The onset and rate of the antidepressant effect of electroconvulsive therapy. A neglected topic of research. Scott, Allan I.F.; Whalley, Lawrence J.; Scott, A I; Whalley, L J // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jun93, Vol. 162, p725 

    The article discusses the lack of research about the onset and rate of the antidepressant effect of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in Great Britain. The selection of depressed patients who will receive ECT and the recommended ECT practice have significantly changed. All depressed patients who...

  • Prediction of clinical response to ECT. Abrams, Richard; Fink, Max; Feldstein, Stanley; Abrams, R; Fink, M; Feldstein, S // British Journal of Psychiatry;Apr73, Vol. 122 Issue 569, p457 

    The article discusses the methods for calculating an index for prediction response to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) as shown by three different studies and a new study. One of the studies, assesses the relation of each index to the immediate clinical response of depressed in-patients who...

  • Inducing seizures among seniors. Hoag, Hannah // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;5/6/2008, Vol. 178 Issue 10, p1264 

    The article reports on the use of electroconvulsive therapy in the brain for the treatment of depression among elderly in Canada. It relates that Canadian physicians anecdotally suggest that electroconvulsive therapy, like inducting seizures in the brain is becoming the norm in the treatment of...

  • The study protocol of the Norwegian randomized controlled trial of electroconvulsive therapy in treatment resistant depression in bipolar disorder. Kessler, Ute; Vaaler, Arne E.; Schøyen, Helle; Oedegaard, Ketil J.; Bergsholm, Per; Andreassen, Ole A.; Malt, Ulrik F.; Morken, Gunnar // BMC Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 10, p16 

    Background: The treatment of depressive phases of bipolar disorder is challenging. The effects of the commonly used antidepressants in bipolar depression are questionable. Electroconvulsive therapy is generally considered to be the most effective treatment even if there are no randomized...

  • Who benefits from electroconvulsive therapy? Combined results of the Leicester and Northwick Park trials. Buchan, Heather; Johnstone, Eve; McPherson, K.; Palmer, R.L.; Crow, T.J.; Brandon, S.; Buchan, H; Johnstone, E // British Journal of Psychiatry;Mar92, Vol. 160, p355 

    This paper describes the results obtained by combining data from the Northwick Park and Leicester randomised controlled trials of ECT. Patients who suffered from depression in which retardation and delusions were features and who received real ECT had a significantly improved outcome at the end...

  • Electroconvulsive therapy in Denmark. Heshe, J.; Roeder, E. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Mar76, Vol. 128, p241 

    During the fiscal year 1 April 1972 to 31 March 1973, 22,210 ECT treatments in 3,438 series were given in Denmark (6-46 treatments per series). Indications for treatment were: endogenous depression, acute delirium, mania, hysterical psychosis, reactive depression and schizophrenia. Unilateral...

  • The role of electroconvulsive therapy in the treatment of depressive illness in old age. Benbow, S.M. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Aug89, Vol. 155, p147 

    Electroconvulsive therapy is an important treatment in the depressive states of late life, and there is general agreement about the indications for its use in old age psychiatry. Indeed, old age may be associated with a better response to ECT than that in younger age groups. The additional risk...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics