Temporal relationships between physical symptoms and psychiatric disorder. Results from a national birth cohort

Hotopf, Matthew; Mayou, Richard; Wadsworth, Michael; Wessely, Simon; Hotopf, M; Mayou, R; Wadsworth, M; Wessely, S
September 1998
British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep98, Vol. 173, p255
Academic Journal
journal article
Background: Physical symptoms and psychiatric disorder are associated. We aimed to investigate which comes first. Methods: Data from the Medical Research Council National Survey of Health and Development, a population-based birth cohort study were used at two time points: 36 and 43 years. Six physical symptoms were reported at both time points. The Present State Examination and Psychiatric Symptom Frequency interviews were administered at 36 and 43 years respectively. Odds ratios corrected for a variety of confounders were used to describe the associations between physical symptoms and psychiatric disorder across these two time points. Results: Psychiatric disorder increased the odds of reporting symptoms 3-7-fold. The relationship strengthened when the outcome was defined as suffering from multiple symptoms. Population attributable risk of psychiatric disorder and subsyndromal disorder in causing multiple somatic symptoms was 40.3%. Prospectively, psychiatric disorder at 36 years was a predictor for five of the six physical symptoms. Three physical symptoms at 36 years predicted new onset of psychiatric symptoms at 43 years. Conclusions: Psychiatric disorder is strongly related to physical symptoms. The direction of causality may operate in both directions. Assuming a causal relationship, psychiatric disorder (including sub-threshold disorders) could account for at most 40% of cases of multiple physical symptoms.


Related Articles

  • Limitations of the symptom-oriented approach to psychiatric research. Mojtabai, Ramin; Rieder, Ronald O. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep98, Vol. 173, p198 

    Background We critically reviewed the arguments of the symptom-oriented researchers who propose to replace syndromes and diagnostic categories with symptoms as units of analysis in psychiatric research. Method Three central arguments were examined: (a) current diagnostic categories lack...

  • A Follow-Up and Family Study of Briquet's Syndrome. Guze, S. B.; Cloninger, C. R.; Martin, R. L.; Clayton, P. J. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul86, Vol. 149, p17 

    The article presents a study on the validity of specific diagnostic criteria and the pattern of illness observed in first-degree relatives of index cases of Briquet's syndrome. The study began with the systematic clinical evaluation of a cross-section of 500 of the clinic's patients. This was...

  • Somatoform disorders: severe psychiatric illnesses neglected by psychiatrists. Bass, Christopher; Peveler, Robert; House, Allan // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul2001, Vol. 179, p11 

    Background Somatoform disorders have few peers in terms of personal morbidity and cost to the health service, yet many psychiatrists train without any experience of them. Aims To review the prevalence, disability and economic burden of somatoform disorders, and to explore the reasons why they...

  • Specific fears and phobias. Curtis, G. C.; Magee, W. J.; Eaton, W. W.; Wittchen, H.-U.; Kessler, R. C. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep98, Vol. 173, p212 

    Background Data on eight specific fears representing DSM—III—R simple phobia were analysed to evaluate: (a) their prevalence and (b) the validity of subtypes of specific phobia defined by DSM—IV Method A modified version of the Composite International Diagnostic Interview...

  • Long-term course of acute brief psychosis in a developing country setting. Susser, E.; Varma, V. K.; Mattoo, S. K.; Finnerty, M.; Mojtabai, R.; Tripathi, B. M.; Misra, A. K.; Wig, N. N. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep98, Vol. 173, p226 

    Background This study in North India compared acute brief psychosis—defined by acute onset, brief duration and no early relapse—with other remitting psychoses, over a 12-year course and outcome. Method In a cohort of incident psychoses, we identified 20 cases of acute brief...

  • Two psychological treatments for hypochondriasis. Clark, D. M.; Salkovskis, P. M.; Hackmann, A.; Wells, A.; Fennell, M.; Ludgate, J.; Ahmad, S.; Richards, H. C.; Gelder, M. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep98, Vol. 173, p218 

    Background Hypochondriasis is generally considered difficult to manage. This study aimed to assess the effectiveness of cognitive therapy and to compare it with an equally credible, alternative treatment. Method Forty-eight patients with hypochondriasis were initially randomly assigned to either...

  • Somatization in Latin America: a review on the classification of somatoform disorders, functional syndromes, and medically unexplained symptoms. Tofoli, Luís Fernando; Andrade, Laura Helena; Fortes, Sandra // Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria;mai2011 Supplemento 1, Vol. 33, pS70 

    Objective: medically unexplained symptoms are common and associated with mental illness in various contexts. Previous studies show that Latin American populations are prone to somatization. Given the reformulation of the International Classification of Diseases towards its 11th edition the...

  • Somatisation disorder in primary care. Escobar, J. I.; Gara, M.; Silver, R. Cohen; Waitzkin, H.; Holman, A.; Compton, W. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep98, Vol. 173, p262 

    Background Somatisation is a common and frustrating clinical problem in primary care. Method Using structural diagnoses and functional measures, we examined the prevalence and associated features of somatisation disorder defined by three current nosologies and an abridged construct in subjects...

  • Social Transmission in Acute Somatoform Epidemics. Eaton, William W. // Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health;1999, p417 

    This chapter considers the social origins of acute somatoform illnesses, such as so-called hysterical epidemics and mass psychogenic illnesses. Somatoform illnesses are clusters of one or more complaints from individuals and typically accompany bodily, or somatic, illness--that is, in the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics