Energy sources for laparoscopic colectomy: a prospective randomized comparison of conventional electrosurgery, bipolar computer-controlled electrosurgery and ultrasonic dissection. Operative outcome and costs analysis

Targarona, Eduardo Ma; Balague, Carmen; Marin, Juan; Neto, Rene Berindoague; Martinez, Carmen; Garriga, Jordi; Trias, Manuel
December 2005
Surgical Innovation;Dec2005, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p339
Academic Journal
journal article
The development of operative laparoscopic surgery is linked to advances in ancillary surgical instrumentation. Ultrasonic energy devices avoid the use of electricity and provide effective control of small- to medium-sized vessels. Bipolar computer-controlled electrosurgical technology eliminates the disadvantages of electrical energy, and a mechanical blade adds a cutting action. This instrument can provide effective hemostasis of large vessels up to 7 mm. Such devices significantly increase the cost of laparoscopic procedures, however, and the amount of evidence-based information on this topic is surprisingly scarce. This study compared the effectiveness of three different energy sources on the laparoscopic performance of a left colectomy. The trial included 38 nonselected patients with a disease of the colon requiring an elective segmental left-sided colon resection. Patients were preoperatively randomized into three groups. Group I had electrosurgery; vascular dissection was performed entirely with an electrosurgery generator, and vessels were controlled with clips. Group II underwent computer-controlled bipolar electrosurgery; vascular and mesocolon section was completed by using the 10-mm Ligasure device aione. In group III, 5-mm ultrasonic shears (Harmonic Scalpel) were used for bowel dissection, vascular pedicle dissection, and mesocolon transection. The mesenteric vessel pedicle was controlled with an endostapler. Demographics (age, sex, body mass index, comorbidity, previous surgery and diagnoses requiring surgery) were recorded, as were surgical details (operative time, conversion, blood loss), additional disposable instruments (number of trocars, EndoGIA charges, and clip appliers), and clinical outcome. Intraoperative economic costs were also evaluated. End points of the trial were operative time and intraoperative blood loss, and an intention-to-treat principle was followed. The three groups were well matched for demographic and pathologic features. Surgical time was significantly longer in patients operated on with conventional electrosurgery vs the Harmonic Scalpel or computed-based bipolar energy devices. This finding correlated with a significant reduction in intraoperative blood loss. Conversion to other endoscopic techniques was more frequent in Group I; however, conversion to open surgery was similar in ail three groups. No intraoperative accident related to the use of the specific device was observed in any group. Immediate outcome was similar in the three groups, without differences in morbidity, mortality, or hospital stay. Analysis of operative costs showed no significant differences between the three groups. High-energy power sources specifically adapted for endoscopic surgery reduce operative time and blood loss and may be considered cost-effective when left colectomy is used as a model.


Related Articles

  • Thermal spread and heat absorbance differences between open and laparoscopic surgeries during energized dissections by electrosurgical instruments. Song, C.; Tang, B.; Campbell, P. A.; Cuschieri, A. // Surgical Endoscopy;Nov2009, Vol. 23 Issue 11, p2480 

    The reported literature suggests a higher incidence of collateral damage during energized dissections in laparoscopic surgery than in open surgery, probably because the ambient environment of the two approaches causes different heat absorbance and thermal spread during energized dissection. The...

  • Alternate Methods for Laparoscopic Management of Adnexal Masses Greater than 10 cm in Diameter. Ou, Chau-Su; Liu, Yung-Hsien; Zabriskie, Vinette; Rowbotham, Ron // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Jun2001, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p125 

    Purpose: We describe alternate laparoscopic methods for inspection and removal of large adnexal masses, and report our experience with 18 cases in which these methods were used. Patients and Methods: Between April 1994 and January 2000, the first author performed operative laparoscopy on 18...

  • News and Notices.  // Surgical Endoscopy;Apr2009, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p924 

    The article announces several courses related to endoscopic surgery including surgical skills and advanced laparoscopic suturing, research fellowships, and live operative demonstrations.

  • Minimally invasive surgery gains ground. Scott, Lisa // Modern Healthcare;3/11/96, Vol. 26 Issue 11, p56 

    Discusses various aspects of minimally invasive surgical procedures in the United States. Applications; Increasing sale of minimally invasive surgical instruments; Predictions for future applications.

  • Transanal endoscopic resection with peritoneal entry: a word of reason. Burke, J.; Atallah, S.; Albert, M. // Techniques in Coloproctology;Oct2015, Vol. 19 Issue 10, p663 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Transanal endoscopic resection with peritoneal entry: a word of caution" by G. Molina and colleagues in a 2015 issue.

  • Literature Watch.  // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Feb2002, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p85 

    Presents a list of articles related to laparoendoscopic and advanced surgical techniques.

  • A comparison of NOTES transvaginal and laparoscopic cholecystectomy procedures based upon task analysis. Nemani, Arun; Sankaranarayanan, Ganesh; Olasky, Jaisa; Adra, Souheil; Roberts, Kurt; Panait, Lucian; Schwaitzberg, Steven; Jones, Daniel; De, Suvranu // Surgical Endoscopy;Aug2014, Vol. 28 Issue 8, p2443 

    Background: A virtual reality-based simulator for natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) procedures may be used for training and discovery of new tools and procedures. Our previous study (Sankaranarayanan et al. in Surg Endosc 27:1607-1616, ) shows that developing such a...

  • Biomedical nanostructured coating for minimally invasive surgery devices applications: characterization, cell cytotoxicity evaluation and an animal study in rat. Ou, Keng-Liang; Chu, Jan-Show; Hosseinkhani, Hossein; Chiou, Jeng-Fong; Yu, Chih-Hua // Surgical Endoscopy;Jul2014, Vol. 28 Issue 7, p2174 

    Background: Thermal injury and tissue sticking, which influence wound remodeling, are major concerns in electrosurgery. In this study, the effect of lateral thermal injury caused by different electrosurgical electrodes on hepatic remodeling was investigated. Methods: A monopolar electrosurgical...

  • Gallbladder Duplication and Laparoscopic Management. Horattas, Mark C. // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Aug98, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p231 

    Presents a case study of a successful laparoscopic management of symptomatic gallbladder duplication in a middle-aged woman. Review of previous reports of staged laparoscopic procedures for missed duplicated gallbladders; Vital signs of the patient; Manifestations of the disease; Advantages of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics