Group sequential testing in dental clinical trials with longitudinal data on multiple outcome variables

Leroux, Brian G.; Mancl, Lloyd A.; DeRouen, Timothy A.
December 2005
Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Dec2005, Vol. 14 Issue 6, p591
Academic Journal
journal article
In this article, methods are proposed for design and analysis of clinical trials that gather longitudinal data on multiple outcome variables. A valid test of the null hypothesis of no treatment group differences can be obtained for any choice of a working alternative hypothesis and a working covariance matrix for the outcome variables. Increased power can be achieved by accurate modeling of the true treatment effect and covariance structure. Implementation of the procedure is simple using existing software for generalized estimating equations. The procedure is an extension of the 'derived variable' technique (univariate analysis applied to a linear combination of the outcome variables) and also of O'Brien's generalized least squares test. The procedure is extended to allow sequential testing using an arbitrary division of the total type I error rate among repeated hypothesis tests. The methods are illustrated by the design of a study on the safety of dental amalgam fillings, which served as the motivation for the research.


Related Articles

  • Methodology and Application of Adaptive and Sequential Approaches in Contemporary Clinical Trials. Chen, Zhengjia; Zhao, Yichuan; Cui, Ye; Kowalski, Jeanne // Journal of Probability & Statistics;2012, p1 

    The clinical trial, a prospective study to evaluate the effect of interventions in humans under prespecified conditions, is a standard and integral part of modern medicine. Many adaptive and sequential approaches have been proposed for use in clinical trials to allow adaptations or modifications...

  • The Integrity of Bonded Amalgam Restorations: A Clinical Evaluation after Five Years. Mach, Z.; Regent, J.; Staninec, M.; Mrklas, L.; Setcos, J.C. // Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA);Apr2002, Vol. 133 Issue 4, p1 

    Examines the clinical performance of bonded amalgam dental restorations and compares it with that of nonbonded amalgam dental restoration. Placement of bonded and nonbonded amalgams in patients needing dental restoration; Statistical analysis of the two restoration techniques; Similarities in...

  • Sequential analysis applied to clinical trials in dentistry: a systematic review. Bogowicz, P.; Flores-Mir, C.; Major, PW; Heo, Giseon // Evidence-Based Dentistry;Jun2008, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p55 

    Clinical trials employ sequential analysis for the ethical and economic benefits it brings. In dentistry, as in other fields, resources are scarce and efforts are made to ensure that patients are treated ethically. The objective of this systematic review was to characterise the use of sequential...

  • Long-Term Survival of Extensive Amalgam Restorations. Plasmans, P. J. J. M.; Creugers, N. H. J.; Mulder, J. // Journal of Dental Research;Mar1998, Vol. 77 Issue 3, p453 

    In cost-effectiveness analysis and contemporary treatment planning strategies, the postponement of placement of cast crowns plays an important role. Extensive amalgam restorations that involve the rebuilding of cusps and the provision of auxiliary retention are thought to make this postponement...

  • PERFORMANCES OF DENTAL MATERIALS (AMALGAM VERSUS COMPOSITE). V�rlan, Virginia; Stanciu, Radu Patru; V�rlan, Constantin; Bodnar, Traian; Marcov, Narcis; Popa, Mariana Br�ndusa // Metalurgia International;Special Issue, Vol. 16, p35 

    Silver amalgam which is a type of restoration material in dental practice for over 150 years, seriously criticized and defended equally by experts because of its physical qualities, clinical performances and unaesthetic appearance, but also because its alleged impact on general health of...

  • Marginal Fracture of Amalgam: Effect of Type of Tooth and Restoration Class and Size. MAHLER, DAVID B.; MARANTZ, RICHARD L. // Journal of Dental Research;Sep1980, Vol. 59 Issue 9, p1497 

    In this study of the marginal fracture of clinical amalgam restorations, it was found that restoration class or size did not influence fracture behavior, and a contralateral pair design was not found to be necessary. However, a slight effect was found for tooth type.

  • A Two-body Frictional Wear Test. Wassell, R. W.; McCabe, J. E.; Walls, A. W. G. // Journal of Dental Research;Sep1994, Vol. 73 Issue 9, p1546 

    Enamel abraders used in two-body wear tests suffer the disadvantage that standardization is difficult or impossible to obtain. The aim of this study was to test whether steatite (a ceramic material with a Vickers Hardness similar to that of enamel) could be used as a satisfactory human enamel...

  • Repair or replacement of restorations: do we accept built in obsolescence or do we improve the evidence? Sharif, M. O.; Fedorowicz, Z.; Tickle, M.; Brunton, P. A. // British Dental Journal;8/28/2010, Vol. 209 Issue 4, p171 

    Introduction Controversy surrounds decisions on whether to repair or replace defective dental restorations. The concept of built-in obsolescence, ie periodic replacement of dental restorations, is largely accepted as the modus operandi if not the default mode in restorative care. In this article...

  • Dental mercury hygiene recommendations.  // Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA);Jul99, Vol. 130 Issue 7, p1125 

    Presents guidelines for updating mercury hygiene recommendations published by the former American Dental Association (ADA) Council on Dental Materials, Instruments and Equipment. Dental offices' adoption of an appropriate mercury hygiene program; Training of personnel regarding the handling of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics