Minimally invasive: minimally reimbursed? An examination of six laparoscopic surgical procedures

Roumm, Adam R.; Pizzi, Laura; Goldfarb, Neil I.; Cohn, Herbert
September 2005
Surgical Innovation;Sep2005, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p261
Academic Journal
journal article
It is generally believed that minimally invasive surgery (MIS) results in less postoperative pain, fewer complications, and shorter recovery periods compared with open procedures. Yet despite these benefits, the level of reimbursement assigned to the surgeon by United States health-care payers is often lower than that for open procedures. Furthermore, the cost of performing a MIS may be higher vs an open procedure because specialized equipment, increased surgical time, or both may be required. In this report, we examine the issue by comparing reimbursements for MIS with open procedures, summarizing the medical literature on MIS vs open surgical procedures, and offering recommendations for payers who establish reimbursement policies. The review is focused on six MIS procedures where outcomes data exist: laparoscopic cholecystectomy (lap chole), laparoscopic colectomy (LC), laparoscopic fundoplication (LF), laparoscopic hysterectomy (LH), laparoscopic ventral hernia repair (LVHR), and laparoscopic appendectomy (LA). Outcomes summarized were length of hospital stay (LOS), operating room time, operating room costs, complications, and return to work or normal activities. The level of scientific evidence was assigned to each study using predetermined criteria. A total of 112 articles were reviewed: 14 for lap chole, 26 for LC, 7 for LF, 19 for LH, 9 for LVHR, and 37 for LA. The data demonstrate that these procedures result in reduced hospital stay, reduced hospital costs, and faster return to work or normal activities. Yet, the operating room time and costs are frequently higher for MIS. These findings suggest that as both the outcomes value and level of operating room resources are greater, MIS warrants reimbursement that meets or exceeds that of open procedures.


Related Articles

  • Prevention of recurrence by reinforcement of hiatal closure using ligamentum teres in laparoscopic repair of large hiatal hernias. Varga, G.; Cseke, L.; Kalmár, K.; Ö. P. Horváth; Kalmár, K; Horváth, O P // Surgical Endoscopy;Jul2004, Vol. 18 Issue 7, p1051 

    Unlabelled: BACKGROUND. Several attempts were made to develop an effective technique to reduce the high recurrence rate associated with the repair of large hiatal hernias.Methods: A new laparoscopic technique was introduced to reinforce hiatal closure with the...

  • The use of self-gripping (Progripâ„¢) mesh during laparoscopic total extraperitoneal (TEP) inguinal hernia repair: a prospective feasibility and long-term outcomes study. Bresnahan, Erin; Bates, Andrew; Wu, Andrew; Reiner, Mark; Jacob, Brian // Surgical Endoscopy;Sep2015, Vol. 29 Issue 9, p2690 

    Background: The use of self-gripping mesh during laparoscopic TEP inguinal hernia repairs may eliminate the need for any additional fixation, and thus reduce post-operative pain without the added concern for mesh migration. Long-term outcomes are not yet prospectively studied in a controlled...

  • Prospective, randomized clinical trial comparing the use of a single-port device with that of a flexible endoscope with no other device for transumbilical cholecystectomy: LLATZER-FSIS pilot study. Noguera, José; Tejada, Silvia; Tortajada, Carmen; Sánchez, Anna; Muñoz, José // Surgical Endoscopy;Nov2013, Vol. 27 Issue 11, p4284 

    Background: Natural orifice transumbilical endoscopic surgery (NOTES) is a technique still in experimental development that requires clinical trials to assess its safety and efficacy. We present a pilot prospective, randomized, three-arm clinical trial of 1-year duration that was conducted as a...

  • Preperitoneal bupivacaine attenuates pain following laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair. Bar-dayan, A.; Natour, M.; Bar-Zakai, B.; Zmora, O.; Shabtai, M.; Ayalon, A.; Kuriansky, J. // Surgical Endoscopy;Jul2004, Vol. 18 Issue 7, p1079 

    Background: Laparoscopic preperitoneal inguinal hernia repair is associated with a short hospital stay and an early return to normal activity. Therefore, early postoperative pain control is important. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of preperitoneal Bupivacaine...

  • Incisional Hernia Rate May Increase After Single-Port Cholecystectomy. Alptekin, Husnu; Yilmaz, Huseyin; Acar, Fahrettin; Kafali, M. Ertugrul; Sahin, Mustafa // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Oct2012, Vol. 22 Issue 8, p731 

    Background: The major concerns of single-port cholecystectomy are port-site hernia and cost. Essentially, a larger transumbilical incision is more likely to increase the incidence of incisional hernia. The effect of single-port cholecystectomy on hospital cost is controversial. This study...

  • A cost–utility analysis of treatment options for inguinal hernia in 1,513,008 adult patients. Stylopoulos, N.; Gazelle, G.S.; Rattner, D.W. // Surgical Endoscopy;Feb2003, Vol. 17 Issue 2, p180 

    Background: The controversial issue of the cost-effectiveness of laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair is examined, employing a decision analytic method. Materials and methods: The NSAS, NHDS (National Center for Health Statistics), HCUP-NIS (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality) databases...

  • Recurrence after laparoscopic ventral hernia repair. Rosen, M.; Brody, F.; Ponsky, J.; Walsh, R.M.; Rosenblatt, S.; Duperier, F.; Fanning, A.; Siperstein, A. // Surgical Endoscopy;Jan2003, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p123 

    Background: Although the early results of laparoscopic ventral hernia repair have shown a low recurrence rate, there is a paucity of long-term data. This study reviews a single institution's experience with laparoscopic ventral hernia repair (LVHR). Methods: We carried out a retrospective...

  • Primary inguinal hernia repair. Meffinger, J. D.; Felix, K L. // Surgical Endoscopy;Jul2004, Vol. 18 Issue 7, p1144 

    Discusses primary inguinal hernia repair. Advantag of open hernia repair; Difficulty of performing laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair; Way in which primary unilateral hernias can be repaired.

  • Laparoscopic Treatment of Morgagni-Larrey Hernia: Technical Details and Report of a Series. Percivale, Andrea; Stella, Mattia; Durante, Valentino; Dogliotti, Luca; Serafini, Giovanni; Saccomani, Giovanni; Pellicci, Riccardo // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Jun2005, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p303 

    Three patients with Morgagni-Larrey hernia were admitted to the surgical department between August 2000 and September 2003 with slight chest pain and dyspnea. Laparoscopic repair of the diaphragmatic hernia was performed using a tension-free closure of the defects with either Vicryl-Prolene or...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics