Controlling the familywise error rate in functional neuroimaging: a comparative review

Nichols, Thomas; Hayasaka, Satoru
October 2003
Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Oct2003, Vol. 12 Issue 5, p419
Academic Journal
journal article
Functional neuroimaging data embodies a massive multiple testing problem, where 100,000 correlated test statistics must be assessed. The familywise error rate, the chance of any false positives is the standard measure of Type I errors in multiple testing. In this paper we review and evaluate three approaches to thresholding images of test statistics: Bonferroni, random field and the permutation test. Owing to recent developments, improved Bonferroni procedures, such as Hochberg's methods, are now applicable to dependent data. Continuous random field methods use the smoothness of the image to adapt to the severity of the multiple testing problem. Also, increased computing power has made both permutation and bootstrap methods applicable to functional neuroimaging. We evaluate these approaches on t images using simulations and a collection of real datasets. We find that Bonferroni-related tests offer little improvement over Bonferroni, while the permutation method offers substantial improvement over the random field method for low smoothness and low degrees of freedom. We also show the limitations of trying to find an equivalent number of independent tests for an image of correlated test statistics.


Related Articles

  • Evaluations of diffusion tensor image registration based on fiber tractography. Yi Wang; Yu Shen; Dongyang Liu; Guoqin Li; Zhe Guo; Yangyu Fan; Yilong Niu; Wang, Yi; Shen, Yu; Liu, Dongyang; Li, Guoqin; Guo, Zhe; Fan, Yangyu; Niu, Yilong // BioMedical Engineering OnLine;1/10/2017, Vol. 16, p1 

    Background: Diffusion Tensor Magnetic Resonance Imaging (DT-MRI, also known as DTI) measures the diffusion properties of water molecules in tissues and to date is one of the main techniques that can effectively study the microstructures of the brain in vivo. Presently, evaluation of...

  • Classifying radiographic progression status in early rheumatoid arthritis patients using propensity scores to adjust for baseline differences. Park, Grace S.; Weng Kee Wong; MyungShin Oh; Khanna, Dinesh; Gold, Richard H.; Sharp, John T.; Paulus, Harold E.; Wong, Weng Kee; Oh, MyungShin // Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Feb2007, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p13 

    Various methods are used to measure radiographic joint damage in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), but determining proportions of responsive patients is difficult. A key problem in observational studies when assessing damage outcomes is incorporating time to treatment initialization and...

  • Role of contrast-enhanced ultrasound in early diagnosis of psoriatic arthritis. Solivetti; Elia; Teoli; De Mutiis; Chimenti; Berardesca; Di Carlo; Solivetti, F M; Elia, F; Teoli, M; De Mutiis, C; Chimenti, S; Berardesca, E; Di Carlo, A // Dermatology (10188665);Jan2010, Vol. 220 Issue 1, p25 

    Background: Radiographic examination (Rx) is still the best method to obtain an accurate diagnosis of psoriatic arthritis (PsA). Nevertheless, ultrasound (US) examination of the potentially involved joints has started to play a leading role. The sensitivity and specificity of a scan...

  • Combined reading of Contrast Enhanced and Diffusion Weighted Magnetic Resonance Imaging by using a simple sum score. Baltzer, Anja; Dietzel, Matthias; Kaiser, Clemens; Baltzer, Pascal; Kaiser, Clemens G; Baltzer, Pascal A // European Radiology;Mar2016, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p884 

    Objective: To improve specificity of breast MRI by integrating Apparent Diffusion Coefficient (ADC) values with contrast enhanced MRI (CE-MRI) using a simple sum score.Methods: Retrospective analysis of a consecutive series of patients referred to breast MRI at 1.5 T...

  • Subcortical volume changes in dementia with Lewy bodies and Alzheimer's disease. A comparison with healthy aging. Watson, Rosie; Colloby, Sean J.; Blamire, Andrew M.; O’Brien, John T.; O'Brien, John T // International Psychogeriatrics;Apr2016, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p529 

    Background: Differentiating Alzheimer's disease (AD) and dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), two of the commonest forms of dementia in older age, remains a diagnostic challenge. To assist with better understanding of the differences between the conditions during life, we assessed limbic and...

  • A Comparison of Hyperelastic Warping of PET Images with Tagged MRI for the Analysis of Cardiac Deformation. Veress, Alexander I.; Klein, Gregory; Gullberg, Grant T. // International Journal of Biomedical Imaging;2013, p1 

    The objectives of the following research were to evaluate the utility of a deformable image registration technique known as hyperelastic warping for the measurement of local strains in the left ventricle through the analysis of clinical, gated PET image datasets. Two normal human male subjects...

  • Parotid tumors: MR imaging with pathological correlation. Okahara, Mika; Kiyosue, Hiro; Hori, Yuko; Matsumoto, Akira; Mori, Hiromu; Yokoyama, Shigeo // European Radiology;Dec2003 Supplement 4, Vol. 13, pL25 

    Most parotid tumors grow slowly, whether benign or malignant; thus, it is difficult to predict the malignant or benign nature of a tumor clinically. Magnetic resonance imaging may have a place in the diagnostic work-up of parotid tumors. The purpose of this article is to illustrate the MR...

  • Multilevel analysis with messy data. Longford, N.; Longford, N T // Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Dec2001, Vol. 10 Issue 6, p429 

    This paper reviews applications of the method of multiple imputation to dealing with multilevel data that have several kinds of imperfections. These are classified into two broad categories: missing values and imprecise measurement (corrupted recording). The role of the model describing the data...

  • Analysis of uncertainty in health care cost-effectiveness studies: an introduction to statistical issues and methods. O'Brien, B. J.; Briggs, A. H. // Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Dec2002, Vol. 11 Issue 6, p455 

    Cost-effectiveness analysis is now an integral part of health technology assessment and addresses the question of whether a new treatment or other health care program offers good value for money. In this paper we introduce the basic framework for decision making with cost-effectiveness data and...

  • Motion Detection in Diffusion MRI via Online ODF Estimation. Caruyer, Emmanuel; Aganj, Iman; Lenglet, Christophe; Sapiro, Guillermo; Deriche, Rachid // International Journal of Biomedical Imaging;2013, p1 

    The acquisition of high angular resolution diffusion MRI is particularly long and subject motion can become an issue. The orientation distribution function (ODF) can be reconstructed online incrementally from diffusion-weighted MRI with a Kalman filtering framework. This online reconstruction...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics