Wasting energy on an illusion: Six months later

McWhorter, John H.
June 1997
Black Scholar;Summer97, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p2
Academic Journal
Opinion. Examines the question of teaching standard English to African American children as a foreign language. Reasons children should not be taught English; Reference to the Oakland controversy on English translation for students; Information on a study by Nolen (1972).


Related Articles

  • The hidden meanings of black English. Williams, Patricia J. // Black Scholar;Spring97, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p7 

    Questions a decision made by the school board in Oakland,b California to reclassify ebonics or black venacular as a distinct language. Circumstances surrounding black vernacular as English; Indepth look at society and black English; Discussion over the reported plan to teach city teachers ebonics.

  • U.S. won't classify Ebonics as a language.  // Curriculum Review;Mar1997, Vol. 36 Issue 7, p3 

    Looks at why officials of the President Bill Clinton's administration will not provide funds to teach `black English' or Ebonics as a second language in American schools. Characterization of Ebonics; Creation of a program to instruct teachers in Ebonics; Comments from Reverend Jesse Jackson.

  • A case for Ebonics.  // Curriculum Review;Mar1997, Vol. 36 Issue 7, p5 

    Presents an interview with Noma LeMoine, program director of the Los Angeles school district's `Language Development Program for African-American Students,' focusing on its relation to `black English' or Ebonics. Definition of Ebonics; Misconceptions about Ebonics; Problems the language program...

  • Johnny be good. Menand, Louis // New Yorker;01/13/97, Vol. 72 Issue 42, p4 

    Opinion. Argues that the ideology behind Ebonics is wrong. Announcement by the Oakland, California, school board that Ebonics is the primary language of African Americans; Association of language with skin color; Linguistics as ideology as much as it is science; Theory about the origin of Ebonics.

  • Those who try to challenge `ebonics' will either be called Uncle Toms, racists or some other... Sowell, Thomas // Enterprise/Salt Lake City;2/10/97, Vol. 26 Issue 33, p19 

    Comments on the revival of support for the ebonics program proposed by the school board of Oakland, California. Question on the definition of black English and ebonics; Concerns about federal funding; Assertion that the program's real intent is only to get federal funding.

  • `Ebonics' not mentioned in Oakland's final report.  // Black Issues in Higher Education;5/29/1997, Vol. 14 Issue 7, p8 

    Reveals that the final report issued by a task force charged with improving the performance of black students in Oakland, California, did not deal with the issue of eEbonics. Reason the topic was not dealt with; Details on the report; Intended focus of the report; Recommendations for language...

  • Indoctrination isn't teaching. Steele, Shelby // Education Week;1/29/97, Vol. 16 Issue 18, p48 

    Opinion. Examines the implications of the use of Ebonics or Black English in teaching African-American students. Basis of the education of minority students on identity enhancement rather than on academic expectations; Link between self-esteem and identity; Ebonics' emphasizing of self-esteem...

  • Ebonics, unique colorful language, different from English. Barton, Paul Alfred // New York Amsterdam News;01/18/97, Vol. 88 Issue 3, p11 

    Opinion. Discusses whether Ebonics or Black English should be taught in America's public school systems. Examination of linguistics and African language patterns; Whether Ebonics should be seen as a distinct language; Reference to the decision to recognize Black English or Ebonics by the...

  • Black English.  // Christian Science Monitor;1/3/97, Vol. 89 Issue 27, p20 

    Reports that `black English' or `ebonics' is receiving the thoughtful discussion it deserves. Comments from Afro-American, Jesse Jackson.


Read the Article

Other Topics