Joint crisis plans for people with psychosis: economic evaluation of a randomized controlled trial

Flood, Chris; Byford, Sarah; Henderson, Claire; Leese, Morven; Thornicroft, Graham; Sutherby, Kim; Szmukler, George
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Conference Paper
Background To investigate cost-effectiveness of joint crisis plans, a form of advance agreement for people with severe mental illness. Methods Design: Single blind randomized controlled trial, with randomisation of individuals to Joint Crisis Plan or a standardized service information control. Setting: Eight community mental health teams in southern England. Participants: 160 people with a diagnosis of psychotic illness or non-psychotic bipolar disorder, with a hospital admission within the previous two years. Intervention: The Joint Crisis Plan was formulated by the patient, care co-ordinator, psychiatrist, and project worker, containing contact information, details of illnesses, treatments, relapse indicators, and advance statements of preferences for care for future relapses. Main outcome measures: Admission to hospital, and service use over 15 months. Results Joint Crisis Plan use was associated with relatively lower service use and costs on average than the control group, but differences were not statistically significant. Total costs during follow-up were £7,264 for each Joint Crisis Plan participant and £8,359 for the control group (mean difference £1095; 95% confidence interval -- £2,814 to £5,004). Cost-effectiveness acceptability curves, used to explore uncertainty in estimates of costs and effects, suggest there is a greater than 78% probability that Joint Crisis Plans are more cost-effective than the standardized service information in reducing the proportion of patients admitted to hospital. Conclusion Joint Crisis Plans produced a non-significant decrease in admissions and total costs. Whilst acknowledging the wide confidence intervals for the cost estimates, exploration of the associated uncertainty suggests there is a relatively high probability of Joint Crisis Plans being more cost-effective than standardized service information for people with psychotic disorders.


Related Articles

  • Crisis Plans Facilitated by Patient Advocates are Better than those Drawn up by Clinicians: Results from an RCT. Ruchlewska, A.; Mulder, C.; Waal, R.; Kamperman, A.; Gaag, M. // Administration & Policy in Mental Health & Mental Health Service;Mar2014, Vol. 41 Issue 2, p220 

    This study compared quality aspects of crisis plans made with the help of a patient advocate (PACP) with those of plans made with the patient's clinician (clinician crisis plan, CCP). Patients were randomized into PACP and CCP conditions. The quality of crisis plan checklist was used to compare...

  • Joint crisis plans for people with borderline personality disorder: feasibility and outcomes in a randomised controlled trial. Borschmann, Rohan; Barrett, Barbara; Hellier, Jennifer M.; Byford, Sarah; Henderson, Claire; Rose, Diana; Slade, Mike; Sutherby, Kim; Szmukler, George; Thornicroft, Graham; Hogg, Joanna; Moran, Paul // British Journal of Psychiatry;May2013, Vol. 202 Issue 5, p357 

    Background: People with borderline personality disorder frequently experience crises. To date, no randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of crisis interventions for this population have been published.Aims: To examine the feasibility of recruiting and retaining adults with...

  • Hone your skills in intervention. MINTZ, JANE EIGNER // Addiction Professional;May/Jun2010, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p20 

    The article discusses crisis intervention strategies for individuals who work with substance abusers. Many intervention clients are dual diagnosed with both substance abuse and mental health issues. Intervention strategies typically involve phone triage, collecting collateral information,...

  • SAMHSA News - "Crisis Response": An Alternative.  // SAMHSA News;Fall2014, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p1 

    The article focuses on crises services available for stabilizing people with psychological distress instead of inpatient-based care. Topics discussed include services designed for providing appropriate treatment by reaching in communities, involvement of several services like telephone hotlines,...

  • New Research in Treating Child and Adolescent Trauma. Cohen, Judith A. // PTSD Research Quarterly;2015, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p1 

    The author discusses several research studies for effective treatment for child post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) based on ptsd randomized controlled trials (RCT) published from January 2012 and June 2015. Topics include the use of intervention models to prevent PTSD development attempt by...

  • Lifestyle intervention: from cost savings to value for money. Rappange, David R.; Brouwer, Werner B. F.; Rutten, Frans F.H.; van Baal, Pieter H. M. // Journal of Public Health;Sep2010, Vol. 32 Issue 3, p440 

    Prevention of unhealthy lifestyles has sometimes been promoted as simultaneously reducing costs and improving public health but this will unlikely prove to be true. Additional medical costs in life years gained due to treatment of unrelated diseases may offset possible savings in related...

  • Development of family interventions: a 9-month pilot study. Murphy, Neil // British Journal of Nursing;8/9/2007, Vol. 16 Issue 15, p948 

    This article outlines the introduction and development of a team of like-minded people utilizing family interventions (FIs) in a NHS Trust. FIs can be described as therapy sessions for families of people experiencing psychosis, which involve the family, client and therapist. The sessions focus...

  • Parents' tough beat and the school counselor. Downing, Jerry; Harrison, Tom // School Counselor;Nov91, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p91 

    Describes a counseling intervention system specific to managing crisis in a student's life. Factors leading to tough beat situations in a student's life; Impact of students' misbehavior on parents; School counselors' role.

  • Preparing for a crisis. Perea, Rosalie D.; Morrison, Shirley // Educational Leadership;Oct97, Vol. 55 Issue 2, p42 

    Features the Critical Incident Response Team which helps an Albuquerque, New Mexico district meet crisis expeditiously and with compassion. Orchestration of appropriate responses; Coordination of plans and people; Fine-tuning crisis counseling; Assessment of the services.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics