College Athletes'Rights in the Age of the Super Conference: The Case of the All Players United Campaign

Staurowsky, Ellen
June 2014
Journal of Intercollegiate Sport;Jun2014, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p11
Academic Journal
Case Study
Among the most central ethical obligations that higher education in the United States owes to students is the protection of their right to freely disagree, form judgments on their own. and evaluate evidence (AAC&U Board of Directors, 2006). This commentary argues that the ethical obligation to ensure that the academic freedom that should be available to all students is not met when it comes to the treatment of college athletes, most particularly those college athletes participating in the big-time, revenue-generating sports of football and men's basketball. Using the case example of the All Players United ( APU) Campaign, a protest staged by less than two dozen college football players in the fall of 2013. issues associated with athletes right to freedom of speech and freedom of association are examined. The All Players United (APU) campaign is first described followed by an exploration of the group think evidenced in the reaction by college sport officials and football coaches to the APU. To provide context, the APU action is considered within a broader historical overview of college athlete protests and attempts to affect change in the areas of compensation, health and well-being, and educational access. Using a conceptual frame that recognizes that college athletes are recognized as neither workers nor students, difficulties associated with the location of college athletes' rights are explored. This commentary concludes with final thoughts regarding the implications of limiting avenues for athlete self-advocacy within higher education in light of efforts by the Northwestern football team to be recognized as employees with the right to unionize and collectively bargain.


Related Articles

  • WHERE'S THE LINE? Staples, Andy // Sports Illustrated;3/7/2011, Vol. 114 Issue 10, p35 

    The article considers how college football coaches deal with college football players or with high school players who are potential recruits who are arrested for criminal offenses or who have previous criminal records. A lack of a set policy for dealing with such players within college football...

  • Jock Police. Gregory, Sean // Time;10/22/2012, Vol. 180 Issue 17, p56 

    The article discusses the legal and moral aspects of colleges and universities monitoring the online social media of scholarship athletes to prevent misconduct. The example of football player Marvin Austin posting his activities on the social media website Twitter is presented, which led to the...

  • NCAA to Accept More Nontraditional Core High School Courses. Manzo, Kathleen Kennedy // Education Week;02/09/2000, Vol. 19 Issue 22, p7 

    Highlights the agreement of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) to expand its view of which courses meet standards for participation in college sports in the United States (US). Overview of academic requirements for prospective college athletes in the US; Comments from NCAA...

  • Regulating Sports. Marcotte, Paul // ABA Journal;Dec90, Vol. 76 Issue 12, p40 

    Reports on the legislative bills being introduced in the United States Congress which aim to protect athletes of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). Incidents that influenced legislators' decision to propose the bills; Cities involved in the campaign for tougher laws concerning...

  • Letters. Ambrosio, Joseph; Danstrom, Doug; Brandenburg, Myra; Anastasi, Michael A.; Pica, Paul; Shakely, Jack; Geldhof, Adam R.; Windmiller, Bob; Hamilton, Bill; Gilbert, Paul // Sports Illustrated;3/28/2011, Vol. 114 Issue 13, p12 

    Letters to the editor are presented in response to articles published in the March 7, 2011 issue including "Rap Sheets, Recruits & Repercussions," "Scorecard" and "Point After."

  • California Passes the Nation's First Ever "Student-Athlete Bill of Rights". Kleinman, Benjamin M. // Journal of NCAA Compliance;Sep/Oct2012, p2 

    A summary is presented of the Student-Athlete Bill of Rights, sponsored by California Senator Alex Padilla, effective from January 1, 2013.

  • Return to Play. Taylor, Kelley R. // Principal Leadership;Dec2010, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p8 

    The article focuses on a new state law on how to deal with student-athlete concussions which will be implemented in Virginia in July 2011. It notes that under the new law, students with a suspected concussion will be asked to leave the playing field. It adds that they will be required to obtain...

  • Women's hockey gang is not all here. R.A. // Christian Science Monitor;2/26/98, Vol. 90 Issue 63, p14 

    Comments on the five members of the US women's Olympic hockey team who will not be pictured on the Wheaties box with the rest of the team because they are still playing hockey for their respective colleges in 1998. Rules which prohibit college athletes from endorsing commercial products; Why it...

  • Defense of the Week.  // Sports Illustrated;4/16/2007, Vol. 106 Issue 16, following p15 

    This article discusses former University of Oklahoma football player J. D. Quinn. Quinn was kicked off the Oklahoma football team in 2006 for accepting money for work he didn't complete, and is quoted stating that his crime was minor compared to illegal actions taken by his former teammates that...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics