TITLE

Capacity as Philosophy: A Review of Richard Lippke's, The Ethics of Plea Bargaining

AUTHOR(S)
Armstrong, Sarah
PUB. DATE
January 2014
SOURCE
Criminal Law & Philosophy;Jan2014, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p265
SOURCE TYPE
Review
DOC. TYPE
Book Review
ABSTRACT
Plea bargaining is a response to capacity overload in the criminal justice system. It both preserves and belies the right to trial, making possible its glorious display but only by denying it in most cases. While plea bargaining has been documented and analysed copiously in historical, sociological and legal terms, its ethical status as an institutional practice are hazy. Richard Lippke offers an account of plea bargaining that draws on the normative debates over responsibility, culpability and desert, in aid of a holistic proposal for a morally defensible system of pre-trial adjudication. In proposing an ethical system of plea bargaining, and working through the normative challenges to this, two bigger questions become visible. These are: what are the implications of developing, in essence, an ethics of efficiency, and, how should the criminal justice system be held to account for the inequalities (and iniquities) that exist before and outside it? In this review essay, I show how these questions are constructed in the book and make some attempt at analysing them, thus engaging with the more urgent and general issue of the complicated relationship of the ideal to the real when it comes to penal practice.
ACCESSION #
93447643

 

Related Articles

  • The competence of investigator to ensure the legitimate interests of the person in pre-trial proceedings. Gladysheva, O. V. // Russian Juridical Journal / Rossijskij Juridiceskij Zurnal;Nov2012, Vol. 86 Issue 6, p122 

    The powers of investigator in the sphere of legitimate interests of the person in pre-trial proceedings ensuring are analyzed. It is proposed to consolidate the legal status of the applicant who has been called for questioning and the lawyer by adding art. 56¹, 56² and 56³ to ch. 8 of...

  • LAFLER AND FRYE: A NEW CONSTITUTIONAL STANDARD FOR NEGOTIATION. Batra, Rishi // Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution;Winter2013, Vol. 14 Issue 2, p309 

    The article offers information loopholes of plea-bargaining process in the U.S. prevalent in the criminal justice system. It informs that reasons like defense attorneys overburdened with many plea-bargains cases and lack of motivation in lawyers to bargain effectively cause ineffective...

  • Fair and Expeditious Pre-trial Proceedings. Higgins, Gillian // Journal of International Criminal Justice;May2007, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p394 

    In recent times it has been argued that international criminal proceedings are too costly, too long and no longer politically or financially viable. This article proposes several ways in which pre-trial proceedings in international criminal trials may be fairly expedited. The author argues that...

  • BECAUSE DEATH IS DIFFERENT: LEGAL AND MORAL ARGUMENTS FOR BROADENING DEFENDANTS' RIGHTS TO DISCOVERY IN FEDERAL CAPITAL CASES. Lindenman, Stefanie // St. John's Law Review;Spring99, Vol. 73 Issue 2, p541 

    Argues the expansion of the defendant's rights to discovery in the early stages of a potential federal capital case in the U.S. Details of the procedures to obtain permission to seek death penalty; Reasons behind the need for special care in the administration of death penalty cases;...

  • The International Duty of a Reliable Criminal Investigation: A Comparison to Recent U.S. Supreme Court Jurisprudence. Wallace, Don; Scroggs, Amber; Ilett, Melanie // Journal of the Institute of Justice & International Studies;2012, Vol. 12, p61 

    The article offers information on the criminal investigation carried out by the U.S. Supreme Court. It informs about U.S. Supreme Court which takes decision that seemingly send contradictory signals for the investigatory powers of law enforcement and prosecution in the pretrial process of the...

  • Using Research to Improve Pretrial Justice and Public Safety: Results from PSA's Risk Assessment Validation Project. Kennedy, Spurgeon; House, Laura; Williams, Michael // Federal Probation;Jun2013, Vol. 77 Issue 1, p1 

    The article provides a descriptive overview of a new pretrial assessment instrument developed by the Pretrial Services Agency (PSA) for Washington D.C. The authors plan to present more detailed information on the implementation process and data analysis, as the implementation process moves...

  • Former and Current Concepts of the Pre-Trial Investigation Organization. Navickienė, Žaneta // Internal Security;Jan-Jun2013, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p173 

    The article analyzes the concept and content of the pre-trial investigation organization. Based on the various approaches to the subject, the author compares former and current concepts of the pre-trial investigation organization. Despite the fact that an agreed approach to the elements of the...

  • Participation of Victims in Pre-Trial Proceedings of the ICC. Stahn, Carsten; Olásolo, Héctor; Gibson, Kate // Journal of International Criminal Justice;May2006, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p219 

    Victims' participation is usually celebrated as one of the major innovations of the International Criminal Court (ICC) system. It has been regulated in great detail by the drafters of the Rome Statute and the Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the ICC in relation to trial proceedings. However,...

  • ICC Pre-Trial Chamber Allows Victims to Participate in the Investigation Phase of Proceedings. de Hemptinne, Jérôme; Rindi, Francesco // Journal of International Criminal Justice;May2006, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p342 

    The decision rendered by the International Criminal Court (ICC) Pre-Trial Chamber I on 17 January 2006 allows victims to be involved in ICC proceedings at an early stage of the investigation. The Prosecutor, who has filed an appeal against this decision, has consistently argued that the right of...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics