More than Just Eye-Catching: Evaluating Graphic Quality in Middle School English Language Learners' Science Textbooks

Wright, Katherine Landau; McTigue, Erin M.; Eslami, Zohreh R.; University, Texas A&M; Reynolds, Dudley
December 2014
Journal of Curriculum & Instruction;Dec2014, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p89
Academic Journal
Second language (L2) instructors frequently use visual stimuli to support learning, particularly content-specific learning; however, not all visuals are effective in supporting curriculum. Previous research has demonstrated that while graphics may make texts visually appealing, middle grade students, even native English speakers, are not consistently skilled in interpreting science diagrams and integrating textual and visual information simultaneously. This study used the Graphics Analysis Protocol (GAP; Slough & McTigue, 2013), which has been used to assess U.S. science textbooks to evaluate how well graphics in scientific readings support both content knowledge and second language acquisition. Our sample included 118 graphics from 54 readings used to teach science in English to 7th and 8th grade English language learners (ELL) in Qatar. Our findings indicate that not only does poor integration of text and graphics fail to support student learning, but it also may hinder overall reading comprehension. Results suggest that individuals selecting instructional materials for ELL need to evaluate visuals as part of the selection process, particularly with technical classes such as science. Recommendations for practitioners are provided.


Related Articles

  • Seeing how to ask first: Photo elicitation motivates English language learners to write. Zenkov, Kristien; Ewaida, Marriam; Bell, Athene; Lynch, Megan // Middle School Journal;Nov2012, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p6 

    The article focuses on the use of photo elicitation techniques to teach English language learners (ELL) in middle schools in the U.S. The authors claim that image-based tools are proven methods in engaging at-risk youth and can get information about teenagers' perspectives. They report on using...

  • English Language Learning and Leadership: Putting It All Together. Lundquist, Anne M.; Hill, Jane D. // Phi Delta Kappan;Nov2009, Vol. 91 Issue 3, p38 

    The article discusses how language teachers can blend higher-order thinking skills with the stages of language acquisition to improve classroom instruction for English-language learners. Teachers will be required to adopt different teaching strategies that encourage learning at higher levels and...

  • A Research of the 3Bs Teaching Method in Second Language Acquisition. Dongmei LI; Xiaoxiao MAO // Advanced Materials Research;2014, Issue 912-914, p1505 

    The 3Bs Teaching Method has turned out to be successful in the English teaching in Junior Middle Schools in China. To testify its efficacy on the foreign language acquisition for the university English majors in China, an empirical study was made. The experiment reveals that the 3Bs Teaching...

  • New Pedagogical Approaches for Teaching Elementary Science to Limited English Proficient Students. Vang, Christopher T. // Multicultural Education;Spring2006, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p37 

    The article focuses on pedagogical approaches for teaching elementary science to limited English proficient (LEP) students. According to research, second-language learners perform better in math and science classes than language arts and social studies courses. It was said that the key to making...

  • The Effect of Scaffolding Technique in Journal Writing among the Second Language Learners. Veerappan, Veeramuthu A/L; Wei Hui Suan; Sulaiman, Tajularipin // Journal of Language Teaching & Research;Jul2011, Vol. 2 Issue 4, p934 

    It was noted that one of the most distressing challenges faced by the L2 college students was the poor presentation of their journal writing skills. The researcher noticed a prevailing pattern in their journal writing, where most of them were unable to construct proper sentences, making too many...

  • WThe Roles of Meaningful Social Interaction in Second Language Semantic and Lexical Development. Sidek, Harison Mohd; Abdullah, Hazlina // World Applied Sciences Journal;2014, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p449 

    The social cultural theory posits that meaningful social interaction may assist second language (L2) development. This case study attempted to examine the role of meaningful social interaction via informal interaction in L2 semantic and lexical development of a female preschool L2 learner. A set...

  • Sensitivity to the Learning Needs of Newcomers in Foreign Language Settings. Klein, Ana Maria // Multicultural Education;Winter2008, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p41 

    The author discusses the needs of English language learners (ELLs) entering American classrooms and teaching strategies to aid their adjustment. The author suggests cultural experiences of ELLs can benefit classrooms and recommends teachers utilize body language, gestures and sign language to...

  • Successful strategies for teaching reading to middle grades English language learners. Bolos, Nicole // Middle School Journal;Nov2012, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p14 

    The article discusses strategies for successfully teaching reading to middle school English language learners in the U.S. According to the author, reading out loud to middle level students is a way of modeling the use of reading strategies, fluent reading and careful comprehension. He states...

  • Discrepancies between L2 Teacher and L2 Learner Beliefs. Gabillon, Zehra // English Language Teaching;Dec2012, Vol. 5 Issue 12, p94 

    This state of the art article overviews the literature on discrepancies between foreign language teacher and learner beliefs. In the first section, the author draws the reader's attention to the significance of discrepancies between the L2 teacher and L2 learner perceptions and provides a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics