Officials and Subjects in Gardner's Law as a Leap of Faith

Smith, Matthew
November 2014
Law & Philosophy;Nov2014, Vol. 33 Issue 6, p795
Academic Journal
In his collection of essays, Law as a Leap of Faith, John Gardner lucidly develops a powerful account of legal positivism, primarily via a careful interrogation of H. L. A. Hart's work, with a particular focus on Hart's most important text, The Concept of Law. In this essay, I raise a question regarding the significance of legal subjects' understanding of themselves as legal subjects. I claim that as Gardner fills out the picture of what it takes to have an ideal legal system, we will find that there is no requirement that subjects have any understanding of themselves as legal subjects, much less an understanding either of what the law requires of them or of the legal status with respect to officials that the law gives them. In particular, I argue that Gardner's account of the law is too focused on the perspective of officials, and leaves out the perspective of legal subjects. This manifests what I call a unidirectional legal optic: the view of the law is the view from a single perspective, namely the perspective of the official. This is not an accurate picture of the law and so should not be presented as the paradigmatic account of law.


Related Articles

  • Some Remarks on the Connection Between Law and Morality. Redondo, María // Law & Philosophy;Nov2014, Vol. 33 Issue 6, p773 

    This article is primarily focused on two interconnected discussions presented by John Gardner in Law as a Leap of Faith. The first one is related to the thesis which, according to Gardner, all positivists agree on; the second one is referred to the positivist's position regarding the connection...

  • Socio-Legal Positivism and a General Jurisprudence. TAMANAHA, BRIAN Z. // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies;Spring2001, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p1 

    H.L.A. Hart described his classic book, The Concept of Law, as a work in 'descriptive sociology', and his aspiration was to produce a general jurisprudence. He was less than successful in achieving both of these aims. This article attempts a comprehensive reconstruction of legal positivism in a...

  • Four Neglected Prescriptions of Hartian Legal Philosophy. Toh, Kevin // Law & Philosophy;Nov2014, Vol. 33 Issue 6, p689 

    This paper seeks to uncover and rationally reconstruct four theoretical prescriptions that H. L. A. Hart urged philosophers to observe and follow when investigating and theorizing about the nature of law. The four prescriptions may appear meager and insignificant when each is seen in isolation,...

  • Positivismo e Obediência em Herbert Hart. Santos Neto, Arnaldo Bastos; Heinen, Luana Renostro // Revista Seqüência;2010, Vol. 31 Issue 61, p127 

    The issue of respect for legality has always served as a point of complaint to the opponents of legal positivism. This article aims to investigate the theme of obedience to the laws in the thinking of Herbert Hart, one of the most important jurists of the twentieth century, affiliated to the...

  • Analytical Jurisprudence Versus Descriptive Sociology Revisited. Lacey, Nicola // Texas Law Review;Mar2006, Vol. 84 Issue 4, p945 

    Discusses the claims made by H.L.A. Hart that his book "The Concept of Law" might be regarded as a contribution not only to analytical jurisprudence but also to descriptive sociology. Interpretation and limit of Hart's claims; Relationship between Hart's idea on the connection of legal theory...

  • A Few Words on AuDority. Hauksson, Hafsteinn Dór // Nordicum-Mediterraneum;Dec2011, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p2 

    The article reviews the book "The Concept of Law," by HLA Hart.

  • THE CONCEPT OF LAW. DECOSTE, F. C. // Alberta Law Review;Jul2013, Vol. 50 Issue 4, p910 

    No abstract available.

  • Strategy and Ultimate Legal Rules. Green, Leslie; Benditt, Theodore // APA Newsletters;Spring2004, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p69 

    Determines whether law can be understood in terms of coordination games. Context of legal validity and the rule of recognition in the book "The Concept of Law," by H. L. A. Hart; Comparison between superior and ultimate legal rules; Significance of the application of coordination games to...

  • Asking Why in the Study of Human Affairs. Webber, Grégoire // American Journal of Jurisprudence;2015, Vol. 60 Issue 1, p51 

    For the study of human affairs, there is a strategic question that directs inquiry: why? Why did persons act the way they did? What were their reasons for so acting? When one seeks to study human affairs of a time and place, one puts the question "why?" to the persons of that time and place and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics