No Lagrangian? No quantization!

Hojman, Sergio A.; Shepley, L. C.
January 1991
Journal of Mathematical Physics;Jan1991, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p142
Academic Journal
This work starts with classical equations of motion and sets very general quantization conditions (commutation relations). It is proved that these conditions imply that the equations of motion are equivalent to the Euler–Lagrange equations of a Lagrangian L. The result is a generalization of work by Feynman, recently reported by Dyson [Am. J. Phys. 58, 209–211 (1990)]. The Lagrangian L need not be unique. Examples are given, including classical equations that do not come from a Lagrangian and therefore cannot be quantized consistently.


Related Articles

  • On the Discretization of the Continuity Equation in Semi-Lagrangian Models with a Pressure-Type Vertical Coordinate. Benard, P.; Yessad, K. // Monthly Weather Review;Jul2001, Vol. 129 Issue 7, p1746 

    Presents an alternative way to perform discretization of the column-integrated continuity equation in pressure-type vertical coordinate semi-Langrangian models. Comments on the properties of the alternative form; Links with the global mass conservation.

  • Lie symmetries and conserved quantities of constrained mechanical systems. Mei, F.X. // Acta Mechanica;2000, Vol. 141 Issue 3/4, p135 

    Examines the Lie symmetries and conserved quantities of constrained mechanical systems. Establishment of restriction equations of the Lie symmetries; Illustration of Lagrange equations; Determination of equations of motion.

  • On the Tetrad Formulation of the Equations of Motion in General Relativity. Krikorian, R. A. // Astrophysics;Oct/Dec2003, Vol. 46 Issue 4, p496 

    It is shown that the equation of motion Duj/Ds = (e/mc2)Fjiui , a natural generalization to the curved spacetime of the Heaviside-Lorentz law of ponderomotive force, is equivalent to the metric independent and covariant Van Dantzig's equations of motion dxj ∂_{[_j} p_i] = 0 or...

  • Attitude dynamics and control of satellites orbiting rotating asteroids. Kumar, K. D. // Acta Mechanica;Jun2008, Vol. 198 Issue 1/2, p99 

    The paper focuses on the attitude dynamics and control of satellites orbiting a rotating asteroid. The general formulation of the satellite equations of motion in an equatorial eccentric orbit is obtained through the Lagrangian method. The linearized system model is derived and the stability...

  • On the constant of motion of dissipative systems. Patiño, A.; Rago, H. // Canadian Journal of Physics;Jan2002, Vol. 80 Issue 1, p1 

    We apply results on symmetries of equations of motion and equivalent Lagrangians to obtain a constant of motion for a particle travelling through a viscous medium and for the damped harmonic oscillator.

  • Spinorial Field and Lyra Geometry. Casana, R.; Melo, C. A. M.; Pimentel, B. M. // Astrophysics & Space Science;Oct2006, Vol. 305 Issue 2, p125 

    The Dirac field is studied in a Lyra space-time background by means of the classical Schwinger Variational Principle. We obtain the equations of motion, establish the conservation laws, and get a scale relation relating the energy-momentum and spin tensors. Such scale relation is an intrinsic...

  • Nonlinear Evolution of Electron Density Under High-Energy-Density Conditions. Shi Chen; Chen, Zi Y.; Dan, Jian K.; Li, Jian F. // World Academy of Science, Engineering & Technology;Apr2011, Issue 52, p559 

    Evolution of one-dimensional electron system under high-energy-density (HED) conditions is investigated, using the principle of least-action and variational method. In a single-mode modulation model, the amplitude and spatial wavelength of the modulation are chosen to be general coordinates....

  • Ballooning stability of anisotropic, rotating plasmas. Wang, X.-H.; Bhattacharjee, A. // Physics of Fluids B: Plasma Physics;Oct90, Vol. 2 Issue 10, p2346 

    The linearized equation of motion is given in a Lagrangian representation for a rotating plasma with anisotropic pressure. A WKB theory is developed for large-n ballooning modes in an axisymmetric configuration with field-aligned and rigid toroidal flows. In the presence of field-aligned flows,...

  • Finslerian Lie Variations for Dust-Like Matter. Stavrinos, P. C.; Ikeda, S. // International Journal of Theoretical Physics;Feb2004, Vol. 43 Issue 2, p437 

    We use the Finslerian Lie variations and obtain the equations of motion of dust-like matter.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics