Peace and Justice: A Limited Reconciliation

Biggar, Nigel
June 2002
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jun2002, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p167
Academic Journal
This paper aims to relax the tension between the political requirements of making peace and the moral demands of doing justice, in light of the 'peace processes' in South Africa and Northern Ireland. It begins by arguing that criminal justice should be reconceived as consisting primarily in the vindication of victims, both direct and indirect. This is not to deny the retributive punishment of perpetrators any role at all, only to insist that it be largely subservient to the goal of vindication. Why should we take such an account of justice to be true? The paper offers two reasons. First, Christians -- and even secularist liberals -- have a prima facie reason in the consonance of this account with the Bible's eudaimonistic conception of justice as ordered to the restoration of healthy community. Second, since all concepts of criminal justice share the basic notion of putting right what is wrong, it would be odd if the repair of damage done to victims (i.e., their 'vindication') were not prominent among its concerns; and there are reasons to suppose that this vindication should actually predominate in relation to the other principles of justice (the retributive `balancing' of crime and punishment, and the reform of the criminal for his own sake). In its final sections, the paper applies the proposed conception of criminal justice to the 'peace processes' in South Africa and Northern Ireland, and concludes that in both cases, notwithstanding concessions to the politics of peace-making, considerable justice has been done.


Related Articles

  • An Ethic of Political Reconciliation. Philpott, Daniel // Ethics & International Affairs;2009, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p389 

    The core proposition of this article is that reconciliation, both as a process and an end state, is a concept of justice. Its animating virtue is mercy and its goal is peace. These concepts are expressed most deeply in religious traditions, including Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. The idea of...

  • Camilo Torres Lives On. Culhane, Eugene K. // America;2/17/1968, Vol. 118 Issue 7, p214 

    The article focuses on the social and political life of Camilo Torres in the U.S. It narrates how Torres became totally disappointed with normal political methods and decided to join the guerilla bands in Colombia wherein he was shot to death by a government patrol. It notes that Torres was the...

  • Taking aim. Gibeaut, John // ABA Journal;Nov96, Vol. 82 Issue 11, p50 

    Focuses on the increasingly confrontational and personal tone of the current disenchantment with the judiciary and its implications for the very concept of judicial independence. Political attacks on judges and on isolated decisions; Spirit of robust political debate encouraged by the First...

  • INSTRUCTIONS AS A SAFEGUARD AGAINST PROSECUTORIAL MISCONDUCT IN CAPITAL SENTENCING. Platania, Judith; Small, Rachel // Applied Psychology in Criminal Justice;2010, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p62 

    Prosecutorial misconduct in the form of improper closing argument has been identified as a leading cause of unfairness in capital trials. the U.S. Supreme Court has indicated that arguments with the potential to unduly influence the jury should be clarified by a specific judicial instruction....

  • SADDAM STANDS TRIAL.  // People;10/24/2005, Vol. 64 Issue 17, p79 

    Reports on the upcoming trial of former Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein. Details of Saddam's jail, its conditions, and his visitors; The location of his family; Criminal charges against Saddam and seven others; Why one criminal incident was chosen; Identity of the judges and Saddam's lawyers;...

  • Justice spending in Canada.  // Infomat: A Weekly Review;11/8/2002, p3 

    Reveals the average cost of operating the five major sectors of the justice system in Canada in the fiscal year 2000-2001.

  • JUSTICIA, JUSTICIA ELECTORAL Y DEMOCRACIA. Ezquiaga Ganuzas, Francisco Javier // Vniversitas;jul-dic2006, Issue 112, p9 

    This article shows a series of thoughts about justice, electoral justice, and democracy, based on questions such as: Is the judiciary a relevant issue in order to strengthen democracy? What common characteristics and differences does the electoral justice have related to the judiciary in...

  • Living Proof of Change. Tebo, Margaret Graham // ABA Journal;Dec2000, Vol. 86 Issue 12, p94 

    Offers a look at the American Bar Association Forum on Justice Improvements in Scottsdale, Arizona, that discusses how justice initiatives directly affect people. Details on changes that occurred in the life of Jeremy Estrada due to a compassionate judge and judicial system; Relationship...

  • Of men, magic, and the law: Popular justice and the political imagination in South Africa. Crais, Clifton // Journal of Social History;Fall98, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p49 

    Examines the increase of the anti-stocktheft Makhulu Span movement in South Africa's rural region during the 1950s and the informal structures of justice and politics in the country. Formation and establishment of the Makhulu Span movement; Political conflict and challenges the people of South...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics