Legislation on Ethical Issues: Towards an Interactive Paradigm

Van der Burg, Wibren; Brom, Frans W. A.
March 2000
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar2000, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p57
Academic Journal
In this article, we sketch a new approach to law and ethics. The traditional paradigm, exemplified in the debate on liberal moralism, becomes increasingly inadequate. Its basic assumptions are that there are clear moral norms of positive or critical morality, and that making statutory norms is an effective method to have citizens conform to those norms. However, for many ethical issues that are on the legislative agenda, e.g. with respect to bioethics and anti-discrimination law, the moral norms are controversial, vague or still evolving. Moreover, law proves not to be a very effective instrument. Therefore, we need a new paradigm, both for descriptive and for normative analysis. This interactive paradigm, as a normative position, can be summarised in two theses. The process of legislation on ethical issues should be structured as a process of interaction between the legislature and society or relevant sectors of society, so that the development of new moral norms and the development of new legal norms may reinforce each other. And legislation on ethical issues should be designed in such a way that it is an effective form of communication which, moreover, facilitates an ongoing moral debate and an ongoing reflection on such issues, because this is the best method to ensure that the practice remains oriented to the ideals and values the law tries to realise.


Related Articles

  • Self-restraint and the Principle of Consent: Some considerations of the Liberal Conception of Political Legitmacy. Stefan Grotefeld // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar2000, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p77 

    This article discusses the legitimacy argument on which many liberals ground their demand for restraining the use of religious convictions in processes of political deliberation and decision making. According to this argument the exercise of political power can only be justified by 'neutral'...

  • Ethics, Law and Legislation: The Institutionalisation of Moral Reflection. Bondolfi, Alberto // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar2000, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p27 

    This paper describes the different dimensions of the relation between moral reflection and legislative processes. It discusses some examples of the institutionalisation of moral reflection. It is argued that the relation between ethics and law is still an actual and relevant question. Ethics...

  • Civil Ethics and the Validity of Law. Cortina, Adela // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar2000, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p39 

    This paper aims to clarify the nature and contents of 'civil ethics' and the source of the binding force of its obligations. This ethics should provide the criteria for evaluating the moral validity of social, legal and morally valid law. The article starts with observing that in morally...

  • Common Law Approaches to the Relationship Between Law and Morality. Roger Cotterrell // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar2000, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p9 

    How are general relations of law and morality typically conceived in an environment of Anglo-saxon common law? This paper considers some classical common law methods and traditions as these have confronted and been overlaid with modern ideas of legal positivism. While classical common law...

  • HART, Herbert Lionel Adolphus (1907-92). Brooks, Thom // Continuum Encyclopedia of British Philosophy;2006, Vol. 2, p1387 

    This article presents an encyclopedia entry for philosopher Herbert Lionel Adolphus Hart. He was born on July 8, 1907 in Harrogate, England. He studied classical Greats at New College in Oxford, England. A background on a debate that Hart had with Lon L. Fuller regarding the topic of "Positivism...

  • Legislation shows ties between politics, morality. Cook, Bradford E. // New Hampshire Business Review;02/13/98, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p9 

    Ponders on the connection between legislation and morality as practiced in New Hampshire. Morality issues brought about in legislative hearings on bills concerning capital punishment and assisted suicide; Testimonies at the hearings.

  • Law, Morality and Common Ground. Kaveny, M. Cathleen // America;12/09/2000, Vol. 183 Issue 19, p7 

    Deals with the moral issues that bound the laws and legislation in the United States (U.S.). Argument on the promotion of common good and enforcement of law; Limitations of law; Types of law; Holistic approach on the U.S. legal system.

  • Ethics and Halakhah in Levinas. Fagenblat, Michael // Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies;Summer2008, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p97 

    An essay is presented regarding Emmanuel Levinas's conception of ethics which has the structure of Jewish law (halakhah). It outlines the conception of ethics as revealed command, which links it closely with the phenomenology of halakhah, and his refusal of a rational and philosophical account...

  • Tennessee. Schlesinger, Robert // Politics (Campaigns & Elections);Mar2008, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p47 

    This article deals with the proposed overhauling of Tennessee's ethics law. The current ethics law, passed in the wake of a bribery scandal, more or less bans lobbyists and their employers from buying food and drink for state legislators. Some lawmakers now favor altering the law to allow the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics