Practical Reasons and the Redundancy of Motives

Norman, Richard
March 2001
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar2001, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p3
Academic Journal
Jonathan Dancy, in his 1994 Aristotelian Society Presidential Address, set out to show 'why there is really no such thing as the theory of motivation'. In this paper I want to agree that there is no such thing, and to offer reasons of a different kind for that conclusion. I shall suggest that the so-called 'theory of motivation' misconstrues the question which it purports to answer, and that when we properly analyse the question and distinguish it clearly from other questions with which it should not be confused, we do not need a theory of motivation at all.


Related Articles

  • PRESENTER QUICK TIPS.  // American Speaker;Jun2009, p2 

    The article presents several adaptations about tips on making presentations, including answering questions from "Communicate With Confidence," by Dianna Booher, at www.mhprofessional.com, making a speech personalized from "The Talisman of Leadership: Authenticity," by Bruna Martinuzzi, at "Mind...

  • Vigilantism, the Stanley Cup, Wedding Toasts & Animal Glue.  // Esquire;Oct2004, Vol. 142 Issue 4, p100 

    Answers questions on various issues. Information on specialty glues made from animals; Legality of a citizen's arrest; Guidelines on making a best-man speech.

  • How Can You Reactivate Lapsed Donors?  // Nonprofit World;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 23 Issue 6, p5 

    This article answers a query as how to motivate lapsed donors to give again. One should treat lapses as what they are probing for an indication that they really do want to continue supporting one. In this vein, it's a good idea to include a short questionnaire, fishing for donors' reasons for...

  • A DILEMMA FOR PARTICULARIST VIRTUE ETHICS. Stangl, Rebecca // Philosophical Quarterly;Oct2008, Vol. 58 Issue 233, p665 

    There is an obvious affinity between virtue ethics and particularism. Both stress the complexity of the moral life, the inadequacy of rule-following as a guide to moral deliberation, and the importance of judgement in discerning the morally relevant features of particular situations. Yet it...

  • Pure Cognitivism and Beyond. Tanyi, Attila // Acta Analytica;Autumn2014, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p331 

    The article begins with Jonathan Dancy's attempt to refute the Humean Theory of Motivation. It first spells out Dancy's argument for his alternative position, the view he labels 'Pure Cognitivism', according to which what motivate are always beliefs, never desires. The article next argues that...

  • ON THE CAMPAIGN COUCH… WITH JB.  // Campaign;6/17/2011, Issue 24, p31 

    The article presents questions and answers related to media and advertising industry in Great Britain including giving a speech at dinner parties and at schools.

  • The Power of the Pause. BLANCK, JENNIFER L. // Toastmaster;Jan2014, Vol. 80 Issue 1, p28 

    The article discusses the use of silence in speeches, negotiations, and conversations. Pauses reportedly give time for the audience to reflect on what the speaker just said, and enables speakers to focus on the audience, their presentation or their own presence. The article notes that the...

  • Advice From Istanbul. Senelt, Deniz // Toastmaster;Nov2008, Vol. 74 Issue 11, p5 

    The author provides the different means of conducting effective speech. According to the author, a speaker must know what is it that he wants to convey to his audience. Setting a goal, knowing the time limit to talk, and adjusting to the audience will reportedly make his speech more...

  • Great Oratory is in the Ear of the Beholder. Mayer, Christopher // Legacy (National Association for Interpretation);May/Jun2008, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p30 

    The author discusses the things that he look for to distinguish a great oratorical speech. He says that some speeches require time for the significance of their content to ripen and that open acknowledgement of one's motives, in the orator's part, is what urges listeners to listen and become...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics