TITLE

A STUDY OF THE LEARNING CURVE FOR A COLONOSCOPY SIMULATOR WITHOUT ANY FEEDBACK: NO FEEDBACK, NO LEARNING OF THE MACHINE ITSELF

AUTHOR(S)
Mahmood, T.; Darzi, A.; Bann, S.; Datta, V.
PUB. DATE
April 2003
SOURCE
Gut;Apr2003 Supplement 1, Vol. 52, pA71
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Objectives: To investigate the learning curve for colonoscopic procedures performed on the HT Immersion Medical Colonoscopy Simulator without any feedback. The hypothesis is that no learning curve exists without a feedback. In other words, the student does not learn the simulation machine itself, instead of the colonoscopy technique that it is primarily meant to teach. Method: 22 postgraduate doctors were recruited, including 5 research fellows, 4 PRHOs, 6 SpRs and 7 consultants. Candidates were asked to perform colonoscopy on the HT Immersion Medical Colonoscopy Simulator. Modules 3 and 4 were used at random. In total, each candidate was asked to perform five consecutive virtual colonoscopies on the same module. These five episodes were collectively referred to as one trial. A time result of 3600 seconds (1 h) was used to denote perforation. No guidance or feedback was given to candidates before, during or after each procedure. Results: 23 candidates recorded five attempts or episodes each, meaning one trial each, on only one module of the colonoscopy simulator, (Total 115 episodes over 23 trials). Another 15 people recorded five attempts, meaning one trial each, on two modules of the colonoscopy simulator (Total 150 episodes over 30 trials). Therefore the total episodes recorded were 265, over 53 trials. There was no improvement in performance on the simulator from first attempt to the fifth in absence of feedback. The outcomes measured included time taken to complete the test, percentage of the mucosa visualised, depth of the instrument inserted, and the path length used. The results were statistically very significant p < 0.000 for all outcomes. Conclusions: This study has demonstrated that in absence of feedback, it is not possible to improve performance on the HT Immersion Colonoscopy Simulator. Thus there is no learning curve for the machine itself. The information from this study is vital for using the simulators in training and assessment because any...
ACCESSION #
9747763

 

Related Articles

  • The importance of proper preparation for colonoscopy.  // Medical Update;Sep99, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p2 

    Discusses the importance of proper preparation for colonoscopy, a medical examination of colon for precancerous polyps or any suspicious abnormality.

  • COLON CANCER: MOVING CLOSER TO A CURE.  // Medical Update;Jun2001, Vol. 24 Issue 12, p1 

    Provides information on virtual colonoscopy to diagnose and treat colon cancer.

  • Colonoscopy in Management of Colonic Strictures. Hunt, Richard H.; Teague, Robin H.; Swarbrick, Edwin T.; Williams, Christopher B. // British Medical Journal;8/9/1975, Vol. 3 Issue 5979, p360 

    Assesses the use of colonoscopy in the management of colonic strictures. Fallacy of the possibility of making a pre-examination diagnosis; Safety of colonoscopy in elucidating the differential diagnosis of strictures of the large bowel; Inability of colonoscopy in distinguishing between...

  • Importance of Adenomas 5 mm or Less in Diameter That Are Detected by Sigmoidoscopy. Read, Thomas E.; Read, Julie D.; Butterly, Lynn F. // New England Journal of Medicine;1/2/97, Vol. 336 Issue 1, p8 

    Background: The need for colonoscopy in patients with adenomas 5 mm or less in diameter that are detected by sigmoidoscopy is controversial. Methods: We prospectively determined the prevalence of proximal colonic neoplasms in asymptomatic patients at average risk for colorectal cancer, each of...

  • Colonoscopy: The Truth About the Test. Raymond, Joan // Town & Country;Oct2007, Vol. 161 Issue 5329, p134 

    The article offers information on colonoscopy.

  • Bruce's Choice. Goldberg, Charlie // Annals of Internal Medicine;5/21/2002, Vol. 136 Issue 10, p777 

    Focuses on the issues related to development of metastatic colon cancer. Importance of colonoscopy in determining the disease; Symptoms of the disorder; Factors contributing to the development of cancer.

  • Critical Decisions in the Management of Endoscopic Perforations of the Colon. Clements, Ronald H.; Jordan, Linda M. // American Surgeon;Jan2000, Vol. 66 Issue 1, p91 

    The ideal management of suspected colon perforation following colonoscopy remains elusive because the incidence is only 0.1 to 2.0 per cent. The patient with obvious perforation deserves immediate exploration, but the patient with equivocal findings poses a diagnostic dilemma. We propose an...

  • Increase in Colonoscopies Associated With Decrease in Colorectal Cancer Deaths.  // Mayo Clinic Women's Health Source;Sep2010, Vol. 14 Issue 9, p3 

    The article discusses a study published in the online edition of "American Journal of Gastroenterology" on March 2, 2010, in which researchers found that the increase of colonoscopies since the early 1990s associates with the decrease in colorectal cancer related deaths among 2.4 million men and...

  • Volume and yield of screening colonoscopy at a tertiary medical center after change in medicare reimbursement. Prajapati, Devang N.; Saeian, Kia; Binion, David G.; Staff, David M.; Kim, Joseph P.; Massey, Benson T.; Hogan, Walter J. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Jan2003, Vol. 98 Issue 1, p194 

    : ObjectiveStarting July 1, 2001, Medicare began to reimburse for screening colonoscopy in asymptomatic adults older than 50 yr with no risk factors for colorectal cancer. We sought to determine the short-term impact of the change in Medicare reimbursement on the demand for and yield of...

  • CT colonography to detect colorectal polyps: a virtual success?: Yee J, Akerkar GA, Hung RK, et al., Colorectal Neoplasia: Performance Characteristics of CT Colonography for Detection in 300 Patients, Radiology 2001;219(3):685—92. Pineau, Benoit C.; Ott, David J. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Jan2003, Vol. 98 Issue 1, p210 

    The purpose of this study was to determine the sensitivity and specificity of CT colonography (CTC) to detect colorectal polyps and cancer compared with conventional colonoscopy. In this investigation, 300 patients (97% male; mean age 62.6 yr) at a university-affiliated Veterans Affair hospital...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sign out of this library

Other Topics