TITLE

SHOULD DIGITAL RECTAL EXAMINATION STILL BE PART OF THE PHYSICAL EXAMINATION OF PATIENTS WITH COLONIC SYMPTOMS?

AUTHOR(S)
Langmead, L.; Jones, D.B.; Katelaris, P.H.
PUB. DATE
April 2003
SOURCE
Gut;Apr2003 Supplement 1, Vol. 52, pA27
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Background: It is an unchallenged axiom that digital rectal examination (DRE) is an essential part of the physical examination of patients with colonic symptoms. However, there is no evidence demonstrating that routine unsedated, unprepared DRE at the initial consultation is useful in patients in whom colonoscopy is indicated. Aims: To assess the value of DRE in patients presenting to gastroenterologists with colonic symptoms. Methods: Consecutive patients presenting to gastroenterologists with colonic symptoms, in whom a colonoscopy was later performed, were studied. Patients with perianal pain or tenesmus and those in whom DRE was done for indications other than routine were excluded. Endoscopic findings were evaluated. Rectal cancers were recorded as distal (within 7 cm of the anal verge and potentially palpable on unsedated DRE) or proximal (beyond 7 cm). Results: In 4834 patients undergoing colonoscopy, 166 cancers were diagnosed, of which 68 (41%) were rectal cancer (23 distal, 45 proximal). Anaemia was a more frequent indication in those with colonic cancers (p < 0.001). A qualitative questionnaire revealed unanimous patient and doctor preference for DRE at the time of colonoscopy rather than unsedated, unprepared DRE. In a presumptive analysis of usefulness, a 75% sensitivity of DRE for distal cancers was assumed. 280 DREs, therefore, wouldbe required to detect one distal cancer in this cohort, with the outcome of this being a possibly reduced waiting time to colonoscopy. Conclusion: Routine DRE was not sensitive for the diagnosis of colorectal cancer. It was unpopular with patients and doctors and would not alter management in more than 0.4% of patients. In those with a positive DRE, the maximum benefit would be to shorten the interval to colonoscopy. In practice, valuable time spent performing DRE may be better spent in the endoscopy suite reducing colonoscopy waiting times.
ACCESSION #
9747438

 

Related Articles

  • Computed Tomographic Colonography and Conventional Colonoscopy for Colon Diseases: A Prospective, Blinded Study. Spinzi, Giancarlo; Belloni, Gianmarco; Martegani, Alberto; Sangiovanni, Angelo; Del Favero, Carlo; Minoli, Giorgio // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Feb2001, Vol. 96 Issue 2, p394 

    OBJECTIVES: Computed tomographic (CT) colonography or virtual colonoscopy is a new diagnostic method for the colon and rectum, developed on the basis of spiral computed axial tomography and employing virtual reality technology. The aim of this study was to determine the sensitivity, specificity,...

  • Colonoscopy in Management of Colonic Strictures. Hunt, Richard H.; Teague, Robin H.; Swarbrick, Edwin T.; Williams, Christopher B. // British Medical Journal;8/9/1975, Vol. 3 Issue 5979, p360 

    Assesses the use of colonoscopy in the management of colonic strictures. Fallacy of the possibility of making a pre-examination diagnosis; Safety of colonoscopy in elucidating the differential diagnosis of strictures of the large bowel; Inability of colonoscopy in distinguishing between...

  • DIVERTICULAR DISEASE: RACIAL DIFFERENCES IN PREVALENCE. Dhar, A.; Leicester, R.J.; Benson, M.J.; Kumar, D.; Melville, D.; Neild, P.; Tibbs, C.J.; Maxwell, J.D.; Kang, J.Y. // Gut;Apr2003 Supplement 1, Vol. 52, pA95 

    Introduction: Diverticular disease (DD) is said to be uncommon in Africans and in Asians. Aim: To determine if patients of Indian subcontinent racial origin (ISC Asians) have a lower prevalence of DD compared to other patients (non-Asians). Method: All colonoscopies performed at St George's...

  • Should colonoscopy be the first investigation for colonic disease? Lindsay, D.C.; Freeman, J.G.; Cobden, I.; Record, C.O. // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);1/16/1988, Vol. 296 Issue 6616, p167 

    Evaluates colonoscopy for the investigation of colonic disease. Conduction of barium enema examination as an alternative investigation; Acceptance of fiberoptic gastroduodenoscopy to determine patients with upper gastrointestinal symptoms; Diagnosis of the disease process.

  • Investigating constipation.  // British Medical Journal;3/8/1980, Vol. 280 Issue 6215, p669 

    Investigates the causes and effects constipation. Possibility of carcinomatous stricture of the colon; Implications of presence of flesh in the faeces; Effectiveness of colonoscopy on abdominal examinations.

  • Methods of Reducing Discomfort During Colonoscopy.  // Digestive Diseases & Sciences;Jun2008, Vol. 53 Issue 6, p1462 

    Abstract  In the United States sedation for colonoscopy is usual practice. Unsedated colonoscopy is limited to a small proportion of unescorted patients and those with a personal preference for no sedation. Over 80% of patients who accept the option of as-needed sedation can complete...

  • Gangrenous caecal volvulus after colonoscopy.  // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);2/5/1983, Vol. 286 Issue 6363, p439 

    Presents a case of caecal volvulus after colonoscopy in Great Britain. Complications of colonoscopy; Development of abdominal distension; Confirmation of the diverticular disease of the colon.

  • Colonoscopy patients in Ireland waiting too long.  // Gastrointestinal Nursing;May2010, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p12 

    The article reports that colonscopy patients were waiting more than 6 months in Ireland for expected changes in technology.

  • Collagenous colitis in adult Sri Lankans: experience from the Indian subcontinent. Satarasinghe, R. L.; Fernando, H. R. R.; Jayamaha, D. H.; Samarasinghe, I.; De Silva, A. P. // Gut;Mar2006, Vol. 55 Issue 3, p436 

    The article examines the clinical features and demographics of collagenous colitic patients in Sri Lanka. Patients who underwent colonoscopy at Base Hospital-Panadura were included in the study. Those with chronic colonic symptoms had mucosal biopsies taken from all major segments of the colon....

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sign out of this library

Other Topics