van Roermund, Bert
June 2014
Diametros: An Online Journal of Philosophy;2014, Issue 40, p149
Academic Journal
The French Code civil, including the tradition of legal practice and scholarship it stands for, is the child of two parents: Enlightenment and Restoration. They came together in the person of Jean Etienne Marie Portalis (1746-1807), who was the main drafter of the code under Napoleon. I want to investigate which line of philosophical argument he followed in uniting the two and critically assess the value of this argumentation. In section 1 I briefly sketch the codification of civil law in the (post-)revolutionary setting of the time, as well as Portalis' philosophical background. Section 2 turns to the principled and wide-ranging discourse he delivered at the occasion of the formal presentation of the draft civil code to the legislature. This discourse, in turn, found its deeper roots in an extensive treatise that he wrote prior to the former, on the use and abuse of reason in times of Enlightenment (Section 3). I will focus, in particular, on the twin concepts of knowledge (section 4) and nature (section 5) in this treatise. From this vantage point, section 6 analyzes the eclectic way in which Portalis uses his philosophical godfathers Montesquieu and Rousseau, while section 7 shows why his preoccupation with the protection of established property rights can explain such eclecticism. Section 8 takes stock and submits that at least one of Portalis' arguments presents a real challenge to Enlightenment philosophy up until the present day.


Related Articles

  • Napoleon and the Jews At the Start of the Jewish Enlightenment. Abidor, Mitchell // Jewish Currents;Autumn2012, Vol. 67 Issue 1, p24 

    The article focuses on the interest of French Emperor, Napoleon Bonaparte in the Jews. It says that Bonaparte issued a proclamation in April 1799 which offers the Jews with the right to political existence as a nation and the right for religious and political freedom. Jean-Étienne-Marie...

  • LETTERS. Ball, David; Appiah, Kwame Anthony; Powell, Eric; Saval, Nikil; Berg, Charles A.; Lass, Egon H. E.; Bowersock, G. W. // New York Review of Books;6/6/2019, Vol. 66 Issue 10, p58 

    No abstract available.

  • Does the Code Civil Matter? Danet, Didier // European Journal of Law & Economics;Nov2002, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p215 

    The article discusses the importance of Code Civil in the French civil law since history. The Code Civil is characterized as the starting point of the French civil law which lies in the paradox that the Code is still a masterpiece of the French modern judicial system, other than to regulate an...

  • The Imperialist Revolution. Boreham, Judy; Heath, Duncan // Introducing Romanticism;9/ 1/2005, p51 

    This article deals with the rise of French military and political leader Napoleon Bounaparte to absolute power following the 1799 coup d'ètat. His regimen implemented an imperalist expansionism programme. According to philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Bounaparte is an agent of the...

  • La Rivoluzione francese e la Grecia. Quattro scritti di propaganda filofrancese di Korais. STAMBOULIS, GIORGIO // Journal of Constitutional History / Giornale di Storia Costituzi;2013, Issue 25, p203 

    This paper analyses the four propaganda writings by the Modern Greek Enlightenment philosopher Adamantios Korais, written between 1798 and 1805. The main issue is made up by the overlap between the values of the French Enlightenment, mediated by the French Revolution, and the rising nationalism....

  • The Hidden Cost of Cancer: Helping Clients Cope with Financial Toxicity. Chi, Maria // Clinical Social Work Journal;Sep2019, Vol. 47 Issue 3, p249 

    Financial toxicity is a term that is increasingly used in the medical literature to describe objective and subjective measures of financial strain that many people with cancer face as a result of costly care and treatment. The author first reviews the literature for evidence of financial...

  • Napoleon's treasures on view in Memphis. Doherty, M. Stephen // American Artist;Apr1993, Vol. 57 Issue 609, p8 

    Discusses the new exhibit titled `Napoleon,' made up of 40 paintings of Napolean by France's greatest painters. How it will be shown at the Grand Exhibition Hall of the Memphis Cook Convention Center in Tennessee from April 22 through September 22, 1993; Paintings and artists that will be...

  • Graceland meets Waterloo. Cerio, Gregory // Newsweek;4/5/1993, Vol. 121 Issue 14, p6 

    Reports that in April, 1993, Memphis, Tenn., home of Elvis Presley, will welcome `Napoleon,' a $9.1 million exhibit on Bonaparte that will be the largest show on the French emperor ever held in North America. Showcases more than 200 items culled from French museums.

  • On the 200th Anniversary of the Establishment of the Duchy of Warsaw: Introduction. Stanley, John // Canadian Slavonic Papers;Sep-Dec2007, Vol. 49 Issue 3/4, p169 

    The article presents an introduction in commemoration of the 200th anniversary of the establishment of the Duchy of Warsaw which highlights the relationship between Napoleon Bonaparte and Poland.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics