Finite-mixture structural equation models for response-based segmentation and unobserved

Jedidi, Kamel; Jagpal, Harsharanjeet S.; Desarbo, Wayne S.
March 1997
Marketing Science;1997, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p39
Academic Journal
Two endemic problems face researchers in the social sciences (e.g., Marketing, Economics, Psychology, and Finance): unobserved heterogeneity and measurement error in data. Structural equation modeling is a powerful tool for dealing with these difficulties using a simultaneous equation framework with unobserved constructs and manifest indicators which are error-prone. When estimating structural equation models, however, researchers frequently treat the data as if they were collected from a single population (Muth�n 1989). This assumption of homogeneity is often unrealistic. For example, in multidimensional expectancy value models, consumers from different market segments can have different belief structures (Bagozzi 1982). Research in satisfaction suggests that consumer decision processes vary across segments (Day 1977). This paper shows that aggregate analysis which ignores heterogeneity in structural equation models produces misleading results and that traditional fit statistics are not useful for detecting unobserved heterogeneity in the data. Furthermore, sequential analyses that first form groups using cluster analysis and then apply multigroup structural equation modeling are not satisfactory. We develop a general finite mixture structural equation model that simultaneously treats heterogeneity and forms market segments in the context of a specified model structure where all the observed variables are measured with error. The model is considerably more general than cluster analysis, multigroup confirmatory factor analysis, and multigroup structural equation modeling. In particular, the model subsumes several specialized models including finite mixture simultaneous equation models, finite mixture confirmatory factor analysis, and finite mixture second-order factor analysis. The finite mixture structural equation model should be of interest to academics in a wide range of disciplines (e.g., Consumer Behavior, Marketing, Economics, Finance, Psychology, and Sociology) where unobserved heterogeneity and measurement error are problematic. In addition, the model should be of interest to market researchers and product managers for two reasons. First, the model allows the manager to perform response-based segmentation using a consumer decision process model, while explicitly allowing for both measurement and structural error. Second, the model allows managers to detect unobserved moderating factors which account for heterogeneity. Once managers have identified the moderating factors, they can link segment membership to observable individual-level characteristics (e.g., socioeconomic and demographic variables) and improve marketing policy. We applied the finite mixture structural equation model to a direct marketing study of customer satisfaction and estimated a large model with 8 unobserved constructs and 23 manifest indicators. The results show that there are three consumer segments that vary considerably in terms of the importance they attach to the various dimensions of satisfaction. In contrast, aggregate analysis is misleading because it incorrectly suggests that except for price all dimensions of satisfaction are significant for all consumers. Methodologically, the finite mixture model is robust; that is, the parameter estimates are stable under double cross-validation and the method can be used to test large models. Furthermore, the double cross-validation results show that the finite mixture model is superior to sequential data analysis strategies in terms of goodness-of-fit and interpretability. We performed four simulation experiments to test the robustness of the algorithm using both recursive and nonrecursive model specifications. Specifically, we examined the robustness of different model selection criteria (e.g., CAIC, BIC, and GFI) in choosing the coned number of clusters for exactly identified and overidentified models assuming that the distributional form is correctly specified. We also examined the effect of distributional misspecification (i.e., departures from multivariate normality) on model performance. The results show that when the data are heterogeneous, the standard goodness-of-fit statistics for the aggregate model are not useful for detecting heterogeneity. Furthermore, parameter recovery is poor. For the finite mixture model, however, the BIC and CAIC criteria perform well in detecting heterogeneity and in identifying the true number of segments. In particular, parameter recovery for both the measurement and structural models is highly satisfactory. The finite mixture method is robust to distributional misspecification; in addition, the method significantly outperforms aggregate and sequential data analysis methods when the form of heterogeneity is misspecified (i.e., the true model has random coefficients). Researchers and practitioners should only use the mixture methodology when substantive theory supports the structural equation model, a priori segmentation is infeasible, and theory suggests that the data are heterogeneous and belong to a finite number of unobserved groups. We expect these conditions to hold in many social science applications and, in particular, market segmentation studies. Future research should focus on large-scale simulation studies to test the structural equation mixture model using a wide range of models and statistical distributions. Theoretical research should extend the model by allowing the mixing proportions to depend on prior information and/or subject-specific variables. Finally, in order to provide a fuller treatment of heterogeneity, we need to develop a general random coefficient structural equation model. Such a model is presently unavailable in the statistical and psychometric literatures.


Related Articles

  • Science, Optimality and Vindication. Reynolds, James F. // Policy Sciences;Mar1975, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p25 

    In this article the author presents his comments on the views given by Milton Marney on the article "Policy Science: A Conceptual and Methodological Analysis." Marney would seem to be an advocate of a general systems theory which along with functionalism and other types of systems theory, is a...

  • Son Dönemlerde Yazılan Kelimâtu'l-Kur'ân Türü Eserler: Yöntem, Amaç, Ä°mkân ve Sınırları. BİLGİN, Abdülcelil // Ekev Academic Review;kis2011, Vol. 15 Issue 46, p185 

    It is possible to evaluate such works as words of Qur'an (al kaleemat al Qur'an) as the first al tafseer books. Writing of this type of works, even in different ways and methods, has come up to the present time. In my opinion, these works not only have an important functionality for the past...

  • ALDERSON'S FUNCTIONALISM: A PHOENIX RISING FROM ITS OWN ASHES. Walle, A.H. // AMA Winter Educators' Conference Proceedings;1984, p78 

    Focuses on the Wroe Alderson static functionalism by similar theories in social science. Implications of dynamic functionalism in marketing; Emphasis on homeostatic aspect of culture; Impact of stability and cohesion to social change; Development of macromarketing.

  • Functional explanation and virtual selection. Pettit, Philip // British Journal for the Philosophy of Science;Jun96, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p291 

    Analyzes the missing-mechanism critique of functionalism. Functional explanations that avoid the missing-mechanism argument; Toleration of functional explanation in biological science; Functionality of a trait; Social-functional explanation as to why a trait is present in the society;...

  • The worker, the workplace, and the need for unemployment insurance. Butler, Peter M.; Smith, Ron // Canadian Review of Sociology & Anthropology;Nov83, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p393 

    Unemployment and subsequent dependence on unemployment insurance benefits cannot be explained solely in terms of the natural abilities, education, training or previous job experience of individual workers. When these attributes are analyzed, their effects are mediated through the influence of...

  • Chapter 2: Social Science Approaches to Sexually Transmitted Diseases in the Caribbean. Allen, Caroline // Caribbean AIDS Epidemic;2000, p22 

    Chapter 2 of the book "Caribbean AIDS Epidemic" is presented. It examines the social science approaches to the study of behaviour related to sexually transmitted diseases (STD) in the region. The communitarian model sees people in communities or groups as sharing similar health concerns and...

  • Reconciliation of Opposing Research Approaches by Means of Ontological Horizons. Visala, Seppo // Proceedings of the European Conference on Research Methods for B;2009, p377 

    Organization research has been one of the battlefields in the conflict between positivism/ functionalism and interpretivism. Burrell and Morgan's seminal work (1979) classified organization research into four paradigms. Their critics (Chua 1986, Deetz 1996) have mitigated their strict dualisms...

  • Searching for Effectiveness and Efficiency in Conducting Functional Assessments; A Review and Proposed Process for Teachers and Other Practitioners. Johnston, Susan S.; O'Neill, Robert E. // Focus on Autism & Other Developmental Disabilities;Winter2001, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p205 

    Provides a review of the literature on the comparative validity of different assessment and analysis approaches. Outcomes of the functional assessment process; Steps and decision points in the functional assessment process; Examples of indirect assessment tools; Case studies illustrating the...

  • Family Involvement in Functional Assessment and Positive Behavior Support. Dunlap, Glen; Newton, J. Stephen; Fox, Lise; Benito, Nila; Vaughn, Bobbie // Focus on Autism & Other Developmental Disabilities;Winter2001, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p215 

    Discusses family involvement in the process of functional assessment (FA). Information on positive behavior support (PBS); Rationale for family involvement; Explanation on the necessity of family involvement for optimal FA; Empirical support for family involvement; Considerations in promoting...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics