Innovation or imitation? The effect of spillovers and competitive pressure on firms' R&D strategy choice

Slivko, Olga; Theilen, Bernd
July 2014
Journal of Economics;Jul2014, Vol. 112 Issue 3, p253
Academic Journal
In this paper a firm's R&D strategy is assumed to be endogenous and allowed to depend on both internal firm characteristics and external factors. Firms choose between two strategies, either they engage in R&D or abstain from own R&D and imitate the outcomes of innovators. This yields three types of equilibria, in which either all firms innovate, some firms innovate and others imitate, or no firm innovates. Firms' equilibrium strategies crucially depend on external factors. We find that the efficiency of intellectual property rights protection positively affects firms' incentives to engage in R&D, while excessive competitive pressure has a negative effect. In addition, smaller firms are found to be more likely to become imitators when the product is homogeneous and the level of spillovers is high. Regarding social welfare our results indicate that strengthening intellectual property protection can have an ambiguous effect. In markets characterized by a high rate of innovation a reduction of intellectual property rights protection can discourage innovative performance substantially. However, a reduction of patent protection can also increase social welfare because it may induce imitation. This indicates that policy issues such as the optimal length and breadth of patent protection cannot be resolved without taking into account specific market and firm characteristics.


Related Articles

  • Fragmented Property Rights and Incentives for R&D. Clark, Derek J.; Konrad, Kai A. // Management Science;May2008, Vol. 54 Issue 5, p969 

    Where product innovation requires several complementary patents, fragmented property rights can limit firms' willingness to invest in R&D. We consider the research intensity in multiple simultaneous R&D contests and how it depends on whether firms already hold relevant patents as well as the...

  • Co-Ownership of Intellectual Property: Exploring the Value Appropriation and Value Creation Implications of Co-Patenting With Different Partners. Belderbos, Rene; Cassiman, Bruno; Faems, Dries; Leten, Bart; Looy, Bart Van // Proceedings of the European Conference on Innovation & Entrepren;2013, p96 

    Combining interview data and empirical analyses, we explore the value appropriation and value creation implications of R&D collaboration involving co-ownership of intellectual property (i.e. co-patents). We make an explicit distinction between three different types of co-patenting partners:...

  • US Patent Law and Cross-Border R&D. Baluch, Andrew S.; Zhang, Helen H. // China Business Review;Apr2013, p18 

    The article discusses the U.S.' Leahy-Smith America Invents Act of 2011 (LAIA) with regards to its impact on U.S.-China joint ventures. It states that cross-border innovation has been increasing and that almost 40 percent of patents in the U.S. naming a Chinese inventor also involves at least...

  • Process Spillovers and Growth: A Comment on the Existence of a Stable Closed-Loop Nash Equilibrium. Luckraz, Shravan // Journal of Optimization Theory & Applications;Apr2011, Vol. 149 Issue 1, p229 

    In a recent paper Luckraz (J. Optim. Theory Appl. 139:315-335, ) develops a differential game model to show that a lack of intellectual property protection can improve economic growth in economies, where large technology gaps prevail. However, this conclusion depends crucially on the fact that...

  • Patent law in dentistry: An overview. Bijle, Mohammed Nadeem A. // Indian Journal of Dental Research;Jul/Aug2011, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p574 

    Dentistry in recent years has developed interest in the field of intellectual property rights (IPR) and Patents due to extensive research in the fraternity and existing competition. There have been various patent applications and grants in the field of dentistry abroad due to better...

  • Insights into US public biotech sector using patenting trends. Aggarwal, Saurabh; Gupta, Vinay; Bagchi-Sen, Sharmistha // Nature Biotechnology;Jun2006, Vol. 24 Issue 6, p643 

    The article provides information on the patenting trends of public biotechnology sector in the U.S. The biotechnology companies played an important role in research and developments for drugs, technologies and tools. An analysis on the patent data from 1995-2005, which was obtained from the U.S....

  • The Sale of Ideas: Strategic Disclosure, Property Rights, and Contracting. Anton, J.J.; Yao, D.A. // Review of Economic Studies;Aug2002, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p513 

    Ideas are difficult to sell when buyers cannot assess an idea’s value before it is revealed and sellers cannot protect a revealed idea. These problems exist in a variety of intellectual property sales ranging from pure ideas to poorly protected inventions and reflect the nonverifiability...

  • Protect Your Company. Minsk, Alan D. // Seattle Business;Oct2012, Vol. 23 Issue 10, p17 

    The article discusses the value for a company that can be obtained from innovations created by employees and consultants. It states that such can be captured by forming a strategic patent portfolio and then be used to create new value and retain previously created value, and as a resource for...

  • PROTECTING YOUR IDEA.  // NZ Marketing Magazine;Jan/Feb2010, p50 

    The article discusses the importance of early intellectual property (IP) management for businesses. It says that protecting and reviewing IP is a much needed extension of the innovation process. According to the author, IP management is all about preventing problems in the future in order that...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics