European renewable energy directive: Critical analysis of important default values and methods for calculating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of palm oil biodiesel

Stichnothe, Heinz; Schuchardt, Frank; Rahutomo, Suroso
June 2014
International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment;Jun2014, Vol. 19 Issue 6, p1294
Academic Journal
Purpose: The aim of this paper is to evaluate assumptions and data used in calculations related to palm oil produced for biodiesel production relative to the European Renewable Energy Directive (EU-RED). The intent of this paper is not to review all assumptions and data, but rather to evaluate whether the methodology is applied in a consistent way and whether current default values address relevant management practices of palm oil production systems. Methods: The GHG calculation method provided in Annex V of the EU-RED was used to calculate the GHG-emissions from palm oil production systems. Moreover, the internal nitrogen recycling on the plantation was calculated based on monitoring data in North Sumatra. Results and discussion: A calculation methodology is detailed in Annex V of the EU-RED. Some important aspects necessary to calculate the GHG emission savings correctly are insufficiently considered, e.g.: • 'Nitrogen recycling' within the plantation due to fronds remaining on the plantation is ignored. The associated organic N-input to the plantation and the resulting nitrous oxide emissions is not considered within the calculations, despite crop residues being taken into account for annual crops in the BIOGRACE tool. • The calculation of GHG-emissions from residue and waste water treatment is inappropriately implemented despite being a hot-spot for GHG emissions within the life cycle of palm oil and palm oil biodiesel. Additionally, no distinction is made between palm oil and palm kernel oil even though palm kernel oil is rarely used for biodiesel production. • The allocation procedure does not address the most relevant oil mill management practices. Palm oil mills produce crude palm oil (CPO) in addition either nuts or palm kernels and nut shells. In the first case, the nuts would be treated as co-products and upstream emissions would be allocated based on the energy content; in the second case the kernels would be treated as co-products while the shelöls are considered as waste without upstream emissions. This has a significant impact on the resulst or GHG savings, respectively. • It is not specified whether indirect GHG emissions from nitrogen oxide emission from the heat and power unit of palm oil mills should be taken into account. Conclusions and recommendations: In conclusion, the existing calculation methodology described in Annex V of the EU-RED and default values are insufficient for calculating the real GHG emission savings from palm oil and palm oil biodiesel. The current default values do not reflect relevant management practices. Additionally, they protect poor management practices, such as the disposal of empty fruit bunches (EFB), and lead to an overestimation of GHG savings from palm oil biodiesel. A default value for EFB disposal must be introduced because resulting GHG emissions are substantial. Organic nitrogen from fronds must be taken into account when calculating real GHG savings from palm oil biodiesel. Further, more conservative data for FFB yield and fugitive emissions from wastewater treatment should be introduced in order to foster environmental friendly management options. Moreover, credits for bioenergy production from crop residues should be allowed in order to foster the mobilization of currently unused biomass.


Related Articles

  • An Investigation of Sustainable Power Generation from Oil Palm Biomass: A Case Study in Sarawak. Aghamohammadi, Nasrin; Li Ping Wong; Reginald, Stacy Simai; Nik Sulaiman, Nik Meriam Binti; Shamiri, Ahmad; Zinatizadeh, Ali Akbar // Sustainability (2071-1050);2016, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p416 

    Sarawak is the largest state in Malaysia, with 22% of the nation's oil palm plantation area, making it the second largest contributor to palm biomass production. Despite the enormous amount of palm biomass in the state, the use of biomass as fuel for power generation remains low. This study is...

  • Long-term CO2 emission reduction scenarios in Japan. Masul, Toshihiko; Matsuoka, Yuzuru; Kainuma, Mikiko // Environmental Economics & Policy Studies;2006, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p347 

    Japan's long-term CO2 emission reduction scenarios are assessed with a computable general equilibrium model with recursive dynamics, which was modified in order to assess the effects of renewable energy supply. The period of assessment is from 2000 to 2050 and the increase of gross domestic...

  • Bioenergy Sustainability in China: Potential and Impacts. Jie Zhuang; Gentry, Randall W.; Gui-Rui Yu; Sayler, Gary S.; Bickham, John W. // Environmental Management;Oct2010, Vol. 46 Issue 4, p525 

    The sustainability implications of bioenergy development strategies are large and complex. Unlike conventional agriculture, bioenergy production provides an opportunity to design systems for improving eco-environmental services. Different places have different goals and solutions for bioenergy...

  • Car CO2 target proposals dominate Environment Council meeting.  // ENDS (Environmental Data Services);Jun2008, Issue 401, p53 

    The article discusses the highlights of the Council meeting of the European Union (EU) environment ministers held in June 2008. They discussed the proposals on climate and energy which include car emissions, emissions trading scheme, biofuels and renewable energy. No new policy resolutions or...

  • Production of green energy from co-digestion: perspectives for the Province of Cuneo, energetic balance and environmental sustainability. Panepinto, Deborah; Genon, Giuseppe; Brizio, Enrico; Russolillo, Daniele // Clean Technologies & Environmental Policy;Dec2013, Vol. 15 Issue 6, p1055 

    In Italy and many European countries, energy production from biomass is encouraged by strong economic subsidies so that biomass energy plants are getting large diffusion. Nevertheless, it is necessary to define the environmental compatibility taking into account global parameters as well as...

  • Multi-state Modeling Incorporated with Analytical Approach for Reliability Evaluation. Zulkifli, Nadiah Amalina; Razali, Noor Miza Muhamad; Tengku Juhana Tengku Hashim; Ramasamy, Agileswari K.; Marsadek, Marayati // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2015, Vol. 785, p642 

    Renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, biomass, wave and tidal energy have become favourable alternatives to replace conventional generators due to excessive emission of harmful gaseous and depletion of natural resources. From all of the energy sources, solar photovoltaic is chosen in...

  • IN BRIEF.  // ENDS (Environmental Data Services);Sep2011, Issue 440, p15 

    This section offers news briefs in the sustainable energy sector of Great Britain as of September 2011. The Department for Transport said that a number of fuel suppliers were not able to meet the voluntary carbon target for biofuels in 2010/2011. From 2008-2009, the carbon dioxide statistics of...

  • A TEST OF FUEL SWITCHING WITH BIOFUELS. Gillespie, David; Johnson, Kim // Electric Perspectives;Nov/Dec2008, Vol. 33 Issue 6, p88 

    The article cites that the electric power industry in the U.S. are beginning to use biofuels to meet the renewable energy standards (RES) requirements through 2020. According to the author, switching to next-generation biofuel from fossil fuels would reduce emissions of carbon dioxide, sulfur...

  • Exhaust emission characteristics of various types of biofuels. De-Xing Peng // Advances in Mechanical Engineering (Sage Publications Inc.);Jul2015, Vol. 7 Issue 7, p1 

    Meeting the growing demand for sustainable energy is one of the major challenges of the 21st century. In the Kyoto conference on global climate change, numerous nations committed to large reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. Reduced greenhouse gas emissions are a major advantage of using...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics