The Structure of Practical Expertise

Tsai, Cheng-hung
June 2014
Philosophia;Jun2014, Vol. 42 Issue 2, p539
Academic Journal
Anti-intellectualists in epistemology argue for the thesis that knowing-how is not a species of knowing-that, and most of them tend to avoid any use of the notion 'knowing-that' in their explanation of intelligent action on pain of inconsistency. Intellectualists tend to disprove anti-intellectualism by showing that the residues of knowing-that remain in the anti-intellectualist explanation of intelligent action. Outside the field of epistemology, some philosophers who try to highlight the nature of their explanation of intelligent action in certain fields, such as ethics, tend to classify themselves as intellectualist simply because they appeal to the notion of knowing-that in their explanation. In a word, the idea of knowing-that is harmful to the anti-intellectualist explanation of intelligent action, whether from an insider or outsider perspective. In this paper, I argue that these tendencies are unjustified because they are based on an unclear conception of anti-intellectualism. I shall use Gilbert Ryle's anti-intellectualism as a paradigm with which to describe anti-intellectualism and to illustrate why the notion of knowing-that is not harmful to but is, on the contrary, beneficial to the anti-intellectualist explanation of intelligent action. If my explication of Ryle's anti-intellectualism is correct, then most anti-intellectualists in the literature blindly worry about the notion of knowing-that, most intellectualists fire into the wrong flock, and some philosophers outside epistemology mischaracterize their own position.


Related Articles

  • Knowing How, Knowing That, Knowing Technology. Norström, Per // Philosophy & Technology;Dec2015, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p553 

    A wide variety of skills, abilities and knowledge are used in technological activities such as engineering design. Together, they enable problem solving and artefact creation. Gilbert Ryle's division of knowledge into knowing how and knowing that is often referred to when discussing this...

  • Ryle's regress defended. Fantl, Jeremy // Philosophical Studies;Oct2011, Vol. 156 Issue 1, p121 

    The article offers the author's insights on the argument of Jason Stanley on the argument of Gilbert Ryle in his book "The Concept of Mind" that intellectualism involves regress while anti-intellectualism is not. The author mentions that Stanley argues that the argument which propose that...

  • category mistake Philosophy.  // Dictionary of Theories;2002, p79 

    Definition of the term "category mistake," is presented. The concept was developed by English philosopher Gilbert Ryle for cases where people talk of something which is appropriate only to something of a radically different kind. According to Ryle, the mind and body cannot be spoken of in...

  • RYLE, Gilbert (1900-76). Sprague, Elmer // Continuum Encyclopedia of British Philosophy;2006, Vol. 4, p2799 

    An encyclopedia entry for British philosopher Gilbert Ryle is presented. It offers information on his educational and career background. His contributions to philosophy are highlighted, including his efforts in instituting the degree of Bachelor of Philosophy at Oxford and arranging joint...

  • PLATONIC DUALISM. Gerson, L. P. // Monist;Jul86, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p352 

    The article reports that Gilbert Ryle in "The Concept of Mind," has pronounced the "official doctrine" regarding the nature of the mind and the body as "hailing chiefly from Descartes." That doctrine, anathematized by Ryle as "the dogma of the ghost in the machine," is said to hold that every...

  • Cartesian Dualism: An Evaluation of Wireduan and Gilbert Ryle's Refutations. Steven, Samuel Olusegun // KRITIKE: An Online Journal of Philosophy;Dec2011, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p156 

    This paper takes a philosophical look at how the views of Gilbert Ryle and Kwasi Wiredu can be used to resolving the mind-body problem located in Rene Descartes' philosophy. The common sense account of the mind-body theory was first systematically carried out by Descartes. To him, mind and body...

  • Knowing Our Minds: Why some philosophers say we can't. Byrne, Alex // Boston Review;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 30 Issue 6, p21 

    This essay presents the author's perception of self-knowledge. The phrase "self-knowledge" tends to evoke the Delphic kind of knowledge of oneself, and it is freely sprinkled around the metaphysical and self-help sections of bookstores. Contemporary philosophers understand the phrase...

  • BEHAVIOURISM. Wanderer, Jeremy // Continuum Encyclopedia of British Philosophy;2006, Vol. 1, p281 

    The article presents an encyclopedia entry for behaviourism that is associated with British philosophy. The British version of behaviourism displays a marked tendency to criticize attempts at strict reduction of the psychological to the physical and to stress the independence of folk...

  • Savoring time: desire, pleasure and wholehearted activity. Brewer, Talbot // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jun2003, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p143 

    There is considerable appeal to the Aristotelian idea that taking pleasure in an activity is sometimes simply a matter of attending to it in such a way as to render it wholehearted. However, the proponents of this idea have not made adequately clear what kind of attention it is that can perform...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics