Going to the Source: Using an Upstream Point of Regulation for Energy in a National Chinese Emissions Trading System

Kerr, Suzi; Duscha, Vicki
June 2014
Energy & Environment;Jun2014, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p593
Academic Journal
There are many choices within the design of an emissions trading system. In this paper we focus on one specific aspect - the point of regulation for the energy sector. This choice affects transaction costs; comprehensiveness, and hence the amount of emissions covered and the extent to which the potential cost-effectiveness gains are realised; and credibility of the system. We discuss how an 'upstream' energy sector emissions trading system works and present arguments for going upstream (in particular, simplicity of administration) while also discussing arguments for other points of regulation in the light of Chinese circumstances. We further present experiences with the New Zealand system, the only system that is entirely upstream for energy, showing ways to address issues that may arise with an upstream system. Ultimately the success of emissions trading depends on flexible markets that operate in a relatively free and competitive way. Simply copying others' systems in the context of a largely controlled economy such as the Chinese one is likely to be ineffective; each system must be uniquely tailored to local circumstances, possibly in China more than ever before.


Related Articles

  • Emissions Trading in the Climate Policy Mix - Understanding and Managing Interactions with Other Policy Instruments. Görlach, Benjamin // Energy & Environment;Jun2014, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p733 

    Emissions trading promises the achievement of a pre-defined environmental outcome at least cost. If the system works and key assumptions hold, it would seem to be an "optimal" climate policy instrument. On closer inspection, however, it is less clear what constitutes an "optimal" climate policy....

  • Interaction Between Climate, Emissions Trading and Energy Efficiency Targets. Schlomann, Barbara; Eichhammer, Wolfgang // Energy & Environment;Jun2014, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p709 

    The European Union has set a system of climate and energy targets comprising target values for greenhouse gas emissions (GHG), Emission Trading Sectors ETS and non-ETS sectors, energy efficiency and renewable energies until 2020. A new framework up to 2030 is just being developed. We analyse...

  • Review of Carbon Emissions Trading Pilots in China. Duan, Maosheng; Pang, Tao; Zhang, Xiliang // Energy & Environment;Jun2014, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p527 

    China's carbon emissions trading pilot schemes have already made significant progress, with five out of the seven pilot systems having started operation by the end of 2013. The experience in establishing and operating the pilot schemes will be valuable to the establishment of China's unified...

  • THE LEGAL AND ECONOMIC BASES FOR AN EMISSIONS TRADING SCHEME. Stein, Leslie A. // Monash University Law Review;2010, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p192 

    The article explores the legal and economic bases for the establishment of an emissions trading scheme (ETS) in Australia. It explains that the ETS is an inevitable consequence of perceiving climate change that requires a top-down approach where the problem involves global scope. It expounds...

  • Emissions cost hits home. Lee, Anne // New Zealand Dairy Exporter;Aug2008, Vol. 84 Issue 1, p80 

    The article discusses the emissions trading scheme (ETS). Through the scheme, the agriculture industry will be paying the full cost of its greenhouse gas emissions by 2030. Under the scheme having carbon valued at $25 per tonne, the farm would have to pay $50,160 per year if it would not utilize...

  • WELFARE ANALYSIS OF AN OPTIMAL CARBON TAX IN CHILE. ESPINOSA, CRISTIAN; FORNERO, JORGE // Revista de Analisis Economico;oct2014, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p75 

    We analyze a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium model which includes a negative externality that arises from fossil fuels burning. The carbon released to the atmosphere by electricity producers is the main driver of climate change. We adapt the optimal tax derived by Golosov et al. (2011) to...

  • Can we reduce emissions without an emissions trading scheme? Sullivan, Rachel // Ecos;Jun/Jul2010, Issue 155, p10 

    The article reports on the concept of reducing emissions without the use of an emissions trading scheme (ETS) in Australia. It notes the announcement of the federal government regarding the postponement of the founding of a Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme (CPRS) until after the expiry of the...

  • China has the capacity to lead in carbon trading. Wang, Qiang // Nature;1/17/2013, Vol. 493 Issue 7432, p273 

    The author reflects on the progress of the emissions trading scheme in China. He cites the implementation of seven trading trials of the scheme in the country that covers around one-third of energy use, however, he also mentions the challenges and issues associated with the program due to...

  • Environmental Policy and Tournaments: A Theoretical Formulation with Over-compliance. Nyiwul, Linus // Journal of Energy Technologies & Policy;2013, Vol. 3 Issue 11, p107 

    In this paper the concept of rank-order tournament is illustrated as an incentive mechanism targeting potential over-compliant polluters - those already complying with existing environmental regulations but can further develop the capacity to exceed such regulatory requirements. Employing...


Read the Article

Courtesy of

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics