Toye, Richard
August 2002
Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Aug2002, Vol. 67 Issue 2, p187
Academic Journal
In his book the Socialist Case, first published in 1937, Douglas Jay wrote: 'in the case of nutrition and health, just as in the case of education, the gentleman in Whitehall really does know better what is good for people than the people know themselves.' This phrase became notorious, and, as a result, Jay's views on economic planning and consumer choice have frequently been misrepresented. Far from wanting to dictate to people what they should consume, Jay was a planning sceptic who believed that the price mechanism had many virtues. The experience of World War Two, however, convinced him of the merits of central planning, and this was reflected in key changes he introduced to the new edition of The Socialist Case, published in 1947. The changed role envisaged for Jay's 'gentleman in Whitehall' not only illustrates important points about the impact of war on the Labour Party's attitudes to planning and consumer sovereignty, but also casts light on the relationship between the socialist revisionism of the 1930s and that of subsequent decades.


Related Articles

  • Relaxing benevolence: public choice, socialist calculation, and planner self-interest. Crampton, Eric; Farrant, Andrew // Review of Austrian Economics;Mar2006, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p81 

    The Austrian calculation argument suggests that inability to engage in economic calculation worsened outcomes in socialist states. We suggest that this is hardly the case. When Austrian assumptions of benevolence are relaxed, inability to engage in economic calculation prevents the...

  • On the Free Rider Problem in the M.D.P. Procedure. Henry, Claude // Review of Economic Studies;Apr79, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p293 

    To ensure an efficient provision of public goods in an economy with both private and public goods, various scholars have proposed a planning procedure that will be called the M.D.P. procedure--which enjoys two important properties: 1) if the consumers involved in the procedure truthfully report...

  • Análisis actitudinal del consumidor ante la provisión de alimentos, en la Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires y conurbano bonaerense. Aulicino, Maria José; Pereyra, Ana María; Abbiati, Nidia Nora // Cuadernos del CEAgro;2004, Issue 6, p61 

    The social changes have structured the existence of a new consumer whose action isn't explained sufficiently by such variables as age, sex, etc. The present work carries out a description of the consumer's attitudes in front of the provision chains, combining technical qualitative and quantitative

  • Equality is a pretence. Byrnes, Sholto // New Statesman;7/30/2007, Vol. 136 Issue 4855, p50 

    The article discusses the notion of elitism in Great Britain. Issues surrounding the idea of egalitarianism in Great Britain are addressed. The author announces his support for elites and notes that notions of elitism can be found on the left side of the political spectrum, as exemplified by...

  • Features of behavior of tourism services consumer. Danilina, Marianna; Derevyankina, Vasilisa; Potehin, Alexander // Concept / Koncept;2014, Issue 5, p1 

    The authors speak about the important issue of recent years such as the behavior of the consumer. The authors give the review of theoretical and methodological approaches to these issues in the context of sociological theories of consumption. The authors present separate findings of internal and...

  • Russia Between Two Plans. Chamberlin, William Henry // New Republic;2/15/33, Vol. 74 Issue 950, p7 

    The article discusses the second Five Year Plan of national economic and social development of Russia, which runs from 1933 until the end of 1937, and offers a look on the first Five Year Plan. According to the author, the second plan will be different from the first, not only in its specific...

  • The Planning Gap and the Role of Regulation. Keyes, Lucile Sheppard // Land Economics;May65, Vol. 41 Issue 2, p111 

    It is sometimes suggested that the difficulties facing Socialist planners in the USSR and elsewhere arise largely from the "natural" tendency of profit-motivated enterprise to persist in spite of the regime and to divert economic activity away from the efficient fulfilment of the national plan....

  • Chapter 6: Planning in the Caribbean under Capitalism and Socialism. Levit, Kari // George Beckford Papers;2000, p57 

    Chapter 6 of the book "The George Beckford Papers" is presented. It highlights planning in the Caribbean under capitalism and socialism. It explores the first meeting of planning officials of member countries of the Caribbean Development and Cooperation Committee, with the main purpose of...

  • Framework faulted for Scots site risks. Webb, Flemmich // Planning (14672073);9/11/2009, Issue 1835, p4 

    The article reports that the national planning framework (NPF) in Scotland has the possibility to affect vulnerable wildlife. The Scottish government will have to conduct an appropriate assessment of the NPF on Scotland's 430 Natura 2000 sites. It also states that the NPF will have a national...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics