Sexual Privacy in the Internet Age: How Substantive Due Process Protects Online Obscenity

Kinsley, Jennifer M.
October 2013
Vanderbilt Journal of Entertainment & Technology Law;Fall2013, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p103
Academic Journal
Obscenity is one of the narrow categories of speech that has historically lacked First Amendment free-speech protection, and courts and scholars alike have wrestled with the indefinable and often unworkable nature of the obscenity test. The advent of the Internet has both intensified and yet potentially resolved these problems. Recent Supreme Court cases, such as Lawrence v. Texas, suggest that sexually explicit expression that falls outside the scope of the First Amendment may nevertheless be entitled to privacy protection under Fourteenth Amendment substantive due process. Yet Lawrence's potential applicability to online obscenity has created tension in lower-court decisions and produced more questions than it has answered. In an attempt to address these lingering questions, this Article discusses the burgeoning right to sexual privacy and argues that certain sexual decisions fall within the autonomy of personhood protected by the Fourteenth Amendment, even when those decisions involve some public action. Relying on Stanley v. Georgia and Lawrence v. Texas, this Article examines the intersection of public expression and private decision making in the context of the Internet and argues that online obscenity that neither involves children nor unwitting adult viewers is entitled to privacy protection.


Related Articles

  • Case Notes.  // Urban Lawyer;Fall2014, Vol. 46 Issue 4, p921 

    The article lists the decisions and holdings of several U.S. federal courts as of October 2014. It mentions the case "McCullen v. Coakley" involving violation of free speech rights under the First Amendment by abortion clinics; "Plumhoff v. Rickard" related to violation of the Fourth and...

  • UNDERMINING PATIENT AUTONOMY BY REGULATING INFORMED CONSENT FOR ABORTION. Furdyna, Aimee // Albany Government Law Review;2013, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p635 

    The article focuses on the laws and legislations made for the regulation of the provisions of abortion rights of the individuals. Topics discussed include laws and legislations made for the regulation of abortion rights, violation of the laws made for due process clause of the Fourteenth...

  • A JOYFUL HEART IS GOOD MEDICINE: SEXUALITY CONVERSION BANS IN THE COURTS. Fore, Wyatt // Michigan Journal of Gender & Law;2014, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p311 

    Led by California and New Jersey, states have begun to ban Sexual Orientation Change Efforts (SOCE) for minors. States have targeted SOCE, also called 'gay conversion therapy, ' by regulating state licensure requirements for mental health professionals. Conservative legal groups have challenged...

  • Mediation Fails, But Protection Orders Succeed in Domestic Violence Cases. Fields, Marjory D. // Domestic Violence Report;Aug/Sep2012, Vol. 17 Issue 6, p81 

    The article discusses the failure of mediation, as well as the success of protection order as alternatives to civil protection orders and criminal prosecutions for domestic violence. It notes mandatory mediation's violation of the U.S. Constitution First Amendment right of access to court and...

  • RECONCILING LAWRENCE V. TEXAS WITH "DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL": THE VALUE OF THE Cook V. GATES INIERMEDIATE-DEFERENTIAL APPROACH. Fugelsang, Steven J. // George Mason University Civil Rights Law Journal;Spring2010, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p237 

    The article focuses on the legal challenges to the Don't Ask, Don't Tell (DADT) policy of the U.S. military. It provides a brief historical overview of DADT and the development of due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment. It also offers a summary of the holding and import of the 2003...

  • THE CHILD QUESTION. Appell, Annette R. // Michigan State Law Review;2013, Vol. 2013 Issue 4, p1137 

    An essay is presented on the legal construction of childhood. Topics discussed include the foundational role of childhood in liberal, democratic republic and the importance of that role for adult autonomy, and the challenges it presents to children's autonomy, the parental liberty interests...


    The article discusses the policy reasons and compelling state interests regarding enactment of child pornography laws in Ohio. The House Bill 132 has been proposed by Ohio State for punishing sexting as a misdemeanor. The Bill has restriction on minors' sexual expression, a form of speech...

  • Censorship as 'Tolerance' MCHANGAMA, JACOB // National Review;7/19/2010, Vol. 62 Issue 13, p37 

    The article presents the author's opinions criticizing the use of hate-speech legislation throughout Europe. The author asserts that the freedom of speech is a human right which should not be limited in the name of "tolerance." It is further suggested that the United States' prohibition of...

  • MARRYING LIBERTY AND EQUALITY: THE NEW JURISPRUDENCE OF GAY RIGHTS. Franklin, Cary // Virginia Law Review;Sep2014, Vol. 100 Issue 5, p817 

    The article discusses the implication of the intersection of due process and equal protection of the law concerning same-sex marriage in the U.S. and the liberty for same-sex couples to marry. It examines several U.S. Supreme Court cases including Lawrence v. Texas, United States v. Windsor, and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics