Introducing layer of protection analysis for water safety risk assessments

Bradshaw, Roland Alexander; Illaszewicz, George Leslie; Avrahamson, Yehoshuah Gershom
January 2013
Water Quality Research Journal of Canada (IWA Publishing);2013, Vol. 48 Issue 1, p76
Academic Journal
In pursuing their mandate of providing good and safe drinking water, water system operators and asset owners work continuously towards developing and maintaining the trust and confidence of their customers. The goal of developing and maintaining customer trust has led to an increased emphasis in the water sector to explicitly assess and manage risks. In this paper, we introduce Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA) as an approach to assessing technical and organizational risk in the water industry. LOPA offers a robust, rational and defensible approach for assessing the adequacy of independent protection layers (IPLs), such as treatment units, standard operating procedures and incident response procedures, used to mitigate environmental and process risks in water supply systems. The strength of LOPA is not only its ability to facilitate a review of technical systems' reliability, but also its versatility to be used for the review of organizational resilience under trying conditions and the opportunity to learn from failure. This is demonstrated in this paper with a review of more than 400 incidents affecting a large water utility serving some six million customers between 1997 and 2006.


Related Articles

  • Water safety plans: planning for adverse events and communicating with consumers. Byleveld, Paul M.; Deere, Daniel; Davison, Annette // Journal of Water & Health;Mar2008 Supplement 1, Vol. 6, p1 

    A wide range of microbial and chemical characteristics in drinking water have the potential to affect human health. However, it is not possible or practical to test drinking water for all potentially harmful characteristics. If drinking water is contaminated, people may already be exposed by the...

  • Security Program Safeguards Tel Aviv's Drinking Water.  // Journal: American Water Works Association;Feb2009, Vol. 101 Issue 2, p116 

    The article reports on the Whitewater Security's completion of the first phase of a comprehensive three-phase program to safeguard the drinking water of Tel Aviv, Israel. Whitewater Security is a subsidiary of the Whitewater Technology Group. The article describes the company's groundbreaking...

  • Experiences and lessons learned from practical implementation of a software-supported Water Safety Plan (WSP) approach. Mayr, Ernest; Lukas, Aditya; Aichlseder, Wolfgang; Perfler, Reinhard // Water Science & Technology: Water Supply;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p101 

    The Water Safety Plan (WSP) is considered the preferred approach to ensure drinking water safety by the World Health Organization (WHO). This approach ideally requires extensive scientific and technical input from a multidisciplinary team of experts. However, in small- and medium-sized...

  • Quantitative risk assessment in the water Safety Plan: case studies from drinking water practice. Medema, Gertjan; Smeets, Patrick // Water Science & Technology: Water Supply;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p127 

    System assessment is the part of the Water Safety Plan that evaluates whether a water supply system is capable of producing drinking water that meets the health-based targets. System assessment can be done at increasing level of detail, requiring more site specific information as the level of...

  • Occurrence of perchlorate in drinking water sources in Korea. Kim, H. K.; Kim, J. H.; Lee, B. C.; Vu, S. J.; Kim, H. J. // Water Science & Technology: Water Supply;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p133 

    Perchlorate is an unregulated contaminant, and recently, many cases of perchlorate contamination have been reported in the US. Unregulated contaminants (e.g. perchlorate) in drinking water are also of significant concern in Korea. we investigated perchlorate levels in tap water, river water, and...

  • Evolución y perspectivas del sistema de abastecimiento de la ciudad de Santiago de Cali frente al aseguramiento de la calidad del agua potable. Pérez-Vidai, Andrea; Delgado-Cabrera, Luis G.; Torres-Lozada, Patricia // Ingeniería y Competitividad;Dec2012, Vol. 14 Issue 2, p69 

    The city of Santiago de Cali was founded in 1536 and began its development and expansion around the Cali river; in 1778 was founded the first aqueduct that supplied water to people of the time by public piles and at the end of the decade of 50's, the Cauca river became the main solution to...

  • An international review of the challenges associated with securing 'buy-in' for water safety plans within providers of drinking water supplies. Summerill, Corinna; Smith, Jen; Webster, James; Pollard, Simon // Journal of Water & Health;Jun2010, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p387 

    Since publication of the 3rd Edition of the World Health Organisation (WHO) Drinking Water Quality guidelines, global adoption of water safety plans (WSPs) has been gathering momentum. Most guidance lists managerial commitment and 'buy-in' as critical to the success of WSP implementation; yet...

  • VÍZBIZONSÁGI TERV SZEREPE AZ IVÓVÍZELLÁTÁS BIZTONSÁGI RENDSZERÉBEN. Tamás, Berek; Zsuzsanna, Dávidovits // Hadmérnök;sze2012, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p14 

    According to WHO inscriptions the most appropriate method to ensure the maintenance of security of the drinking water supply system is preparing and maintening of the Water Safety Plans. The hazard analysis and risk assesment based water safety plan system can provide to achive this purposes...

  • Evolution of Water Management in Shanxi and Shaanxi Provinces since the Ming and Qing Dynasties of China. Xiaohong Dang; Webber, Michael; Dan Chen; Mark Yaolin Wang // Water (20734441);Jun2013, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p643 

    This article examines some of the forms of water management in Shanxi [...] and Shaanxi [...] provinces during the Ming and Qing dynasties. Facing serious water shortages and shrinking state power for water management, the local society in Shanxi and Shaanxi took over water management and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics