An Investigation of Editorial Favoritism in the AER

Coelho, Philip R P; McClure, James E; Reilly, Peter J
March 2014
Eastern Economic Journal;Spring2014, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p274
Academic Journal
This paper contributes to a substantial literature assessing the credibility of academic research. We examine the hypothesis that selection procedures of journals favor submissions that cite journal insiders. Our tests use data from the American Economic Review (AER) and the number of citations to AER publications that appear in non-AER journals. We find that citations to AER-insiders in articles in the AER were statistically insignificant; however, increased frequency of citations in non-AER journals were positively (albeit statistically insignificant) related to references to AER insiders. The sign is precisely opposite of what one would expect if submissions were judged on criteria other than intellectual merit. The evidence is robust across specifications. Given our metric, sample, and procedures, we do not find any significant support for the hypothesis of editorial favoritism.


Related Articles

  • IMPACT OF FAVORITISM, NEPOTISM AND CRONYISM ON JOB SATISFACTION A STUDY FROM PUBLIC SECTOR OF PAKISTAN. Sadozai, Arshad Mahmood; Fakhar Zaman, Hafiz Muhammad; Khan Marri, Muhammad Yousuf; Ramay, Muhammad I. // Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business;Oct2012, Vol. 4 Issue 6, p760 

    The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of favoritism, nepotism and cronyism on job satisfaction in the public sector organizations of Pakistan. A convenience sampling technique was used to collect the data. 250 Questionnaires were distributed to full time employees of 8 public...

  • The honest h index: when a research performance indicator turns into an oxymoron. Lentini, Giovanni // European Science Editing;Feb2013, Vol. 39 Issue 1, p26 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "The journal impact factor as a performance indicator," by F.-T. Krell in the 2012 issue.

  • Theoretical difference between impact factor and influence factor. Pečarić, Đilda; Tuđman, Miroslav // Central European Conference on Information & Intelligent Systems;9/23/2009, p23 

    Bibliometric constructions of "knowledge maps" and "cognitive structures of science" do not differentiate between impact and influence factors. The difference can be constructed according to different meaning and interpretation of the terms reference and citation. Reference is "acknowledgment...

  • Scientific indicators of productivity - time for action. Dainesi, Sonia Mansoldo; Pietron, Ricardo // Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria;Jun2007, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p100 

    The article discusses the use of bibliometric methods such as citation indices as a tool for research performance evaluation. It says that research should continue to identify which citation measures are best and whether these measures are statistically reliable. Meanwhile, an innovative metric...

  • Research Productivity in a Management Institute: An Analysis of Research Performance of Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad during 1999-2010. Kumar, H. Anil; Dora, Mallikarjun // DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology;Jul2012, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p365 

    Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad (IIMA) is one of the oldest institutes of management and generally accepted as one of the leading business schools in India. Established in 1961, IIMA is frequented by the industry, local and global, to recruit its future leaders. An inherently academic...

  • Citation Type Analysis on Humanity Literature of Taiwan. Ming-Yueh Tsay; Chi-Ju Chiu // Journal of Educational Media & Library Sciences;2014, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p1 

    Using informetrics and citation analysis, the present study explores and compares characteristics and types of citations in the humanity journal articles that published in Taiwan. Research articles published in 2011, from top humanity journals, assessed by the Institute of Humanities and Social...

  • The State of Materials Research. Livingstone, Paul // R&D Magazine;Aug2011, Vol. 53 Issue 4, p20 

    The article presents the results of "Global Research Report: Materials Science and Technology," by Jonathan Adams and David Pendlebury, and published by Thomson Reuters, that focused on the publication and citation data to reveal the size and structure of materials science research around the...

  • Scientometric portrait of biochemist Santiago Grisolía: publication productivity, collaboration patterns, and citation analysis. González-Alcaide, Gregorio // Research Evaluation;Apr2014, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p150 

    Santiago Grisolía has made numerous scientific discoveries and contributions of great relevance to the advancement of biochemistry and molecular biology, particularly in the field of enzymology in the metabolism of nitrogen related to the urea cycle and the impoverishment of pyrimidines. This...

  • Global research output of nanobiotechnology research: a scientometrics study. Karpagam, R. // Current Science (00113891);Jun2014, Vol. 106 Issue 11, p1490 

    An effective scientometric analysis based on SCOPUS database was conducted to evaluate nanobiotechnology research from a different perspective for the period 2003-2012. Nanobiotechnology has been intensively investigated by bibliometric methods due to its technological importance and expected...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics