Tri-Word Presentations With Phonemic Scoring for Practical High-Reliability Speech Recognition Assessment

Gelfand, Stanley A.
April 2003
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Apr2003, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p405
Academic Journal
Speech recognition test reliability is optimized with 450 test items, and the Computer Assisted Speech Recognition Assessment (CASRA) test is a practical approach for achieving this goal by combining 50 presentations of 3 consonant-vowel nucleus-consonant (CNC) words each with phonemic scoring (S. A. Gelfand, 1998). However, optimized reliability might not be essential if reliability is as high as possible in light of practical constraints and what the clinician is trying to do with the results. The CASRA paradigm addresses these compromise goals with a reduced number of 3-word sets: 25 sets yield 25 (groups)...3 (words)...3 (phonemes) = 225 test items, 20 sets give 20 x 3 x 3 = 180 items, and 10 sets provide 10 x 3 x 3 = 90 items. This study addressed the empirical reliability of such an approach, and the extent to which results on shortened versions predict full-test scores. Test and retest scores were obtained for 10-, 20-, and 25-set versions of the CASRA for 144 participants with a wide range of hearing ability. For group data, first and second scores were highly correlated and not significantly different from each other for all 3 test sizes. Performance based on 20 and 25 sets accounted for roughly 97% of the variance of full (50-set) test scores, and scores based on 10 sets accounted for about 88% of the full-test variance. Individual test-retest reliability agreed with theoretical expectations based on 95% binomial confidence intervals. Cases outside the 95% confidence limits were 7.6% for 10 sets, and 3.5% for 20 and 25 sets with phoneme scoring, and 4.9% for 10 and 20 sets and 3.5% for 25 sets with word scoring. The shortened CASRA is a practical way to achieve improvements in reliability over traditional word tests. The 20-set version may approximate the strongest compromise when trying to shorten test size without appreciably..


Related Articles

  • Audiologic-Acoustic Evaluation of Speech Perception in Children with Cochlear Implants. Stieler, O.; Sekula, A.; Karlik, M. // Acta Physica Polonica, A.;Jun2011, Vol. 119 Issue 6A, p1077 

    An early diagnosis of the congenital disorder of hearing creates new challenges for a multidisciplinary team: paedoaudiologists, ear nose throat specialists, and speech therapists. The cross modality matching method is based on the objective and subjective techniques in the evaluation of hearing...

  • FURTHER DELINEATION OF THE DFNA5 PHENOTYPE: RESULTS OF SPEECH RECOGNITION TESTS. van Zuijlen, Diedrick A.; Huygen, Patrick L.M.; van Laer, Lut; Huizing, Egbert H.; van Camp, Guy; Cremers, Cor W.R.J. // Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology;Jul2002, Vol. 111 Issue 7, p639 

    Analyzes the speech recognition scores of DFNA5 mutation carriers. Speech reception threshold; Performance intensity curves; Maximum phoneme recognition scores.

  • Dialogue as a basis for construction of speech systems. R. Meshcheryakov; V. Bondarenko // Cybernetics & Systems Analysis;Mar2008, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p175 

    Abstract  The structure of speech dialogue systems is analyzed. It is shown that the creation of speech recognition and synthesis systems is connected with the solution of direct and inverse problems as applied to the organization of speech dialogue. Attention is paid to the multilevel...

  • EFFECTS OF SPEAKER VARIABILITY AND PHONEME LOCATION ON SPEECH PERCEPTION. Mullennix, John W.; Farnsworth, Lynn M. // Perceptual & Motor Skills;Aug2000, Vol. 91 Issue 1, p299 

    Assesses the effects of variation in a speaker's voice and temporal phoneme location through a series of speeded-classification experiments. Monitoring of speech syllables for target consonants or vowels by listeners; Unresolved issues regarding the relationship between attention and speech...

  • Duplex Perception: A Comparison of Monosyllables and Slamming Doors. Fowler, Carol A.; Rosenblum, Lawrence D. // Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception & Performan;Nov90, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p742 

    This article presents a comparative study of monosyllables and slamming doors related to speech perception. According to a previously conducted research, speech perception is subserved by a "module" distinct from the general auditory system. There is neurophysiological evidence for a distinct...

  • How may the basal ganglia contribute to auditory categorization and speech perception? Sung-Joo Lim; Fiez, Julie A.; Holt, Lori L. // Frontiers in Neuroscience;Aug2014, p1 

    Listeners must accomplish two complementary perceptual feats in extracting a message from speech. They must discriminate linguistically-relevant acoustic variability and generalize across irrelevant variability. Said another way, they must categorize speech. Since the mapping of acoustic...

  • Pure tone audiogram and speech audiometry in patients with hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy. Alčin, Branka; Vatovec, Jagoda; Žargi, Miha // Pflugers Archiv European Journal of Physiology;Apr2000, Vol. 439 Issue 7, pr202 

    The goal of our work was to determine hearing thresholds in patients with hearing impairment due to hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy(HMSN I). In assessment of auditory function we used two methods: pure tone and speech audiometry. Pure tone audiometry was performed using air and bone...

  • Non-verbal visual reinforcement affects speech audiometry in the elderly. Di Berardino, Federica; Forti, Stella; Mattei, Valentina; Alpini, Dario; Cesarani, Antonio // European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology;Sep2010, Vol. 267 Issue 9, p1367 

    The purpose of this study was to investigate how non-verbal visual reinforcement provided by the audiologist during speech testing influences performance in the elderly. Thirty-two volunteers with age-related hearing loss with or without dual sensory-impairment (DSI), were administered a speech...

  • Back to Basics: Speech Audiometry. Schoepflin, Janet R. // Audiology Online;Jul2012, p1 

    The article discusses the basics of speech audiometry. Speech is defined as the auditory stimulus wherein people communicate. Some of tests for speech include speech threshold testing, suprathreshold speech recognition testing, uncomfortable listening level testing, and most comfortable...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics