Single-incision laparoscopic appendectomy versus traditional three-port laparoscopic appendectomy: an analysis of outcomes at a single institution

Buckley, F.; Vassaur, Hannah; Monsivais, Sharon; Jupiter, Daniel; Watson, Rob; Eckford, John
February 2014
Surgical Endoscopy;Feb2014, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p626
Academic Journal
Background: Questions have emerged as to whether single-incision laparoscopy has reproducible or superior patient outcomes compared with traditional laparoscopy. A retrospective review comparing single-incision laparoscopic (SILS) appendectomy and traditional multiport laparoscopic (MP) appendectomy was conducted to assess the safety and feasibility of the less invasive laparoscopic technique. Methods: All SILS and MP appendectomies performed by three surgeons at a single institution during 43 months were reviewed. Statistical evaluation included descriptive analysis of demographic data including age and gender, as well as bi- and multi-variate analyses of operative outcomes including operative time, conversions, complications, and hospital length of stay. Results: The study reviewed 168 patients who underwent SILS appendectomy and 108 patients who underwent MP appendectomy. No statistically significant difference was found between the mean SILS and MP operative times (43.63 vs. 40.95 min; p = 0.29). Additionally, no statistically significant association was noted between surgical approach and length of hospital stay. Although 0.93 % of MP appendectomies and 2.38 % of SILS appendectomies were converted to open procedure, this difference was not statistically significant ( p = 0.65, Fisher's exact test). After exclusion of cases converted to open procedure from the study, the findings showed that 3.66 % of SILS cases were converted to multiport laparoscopy. No increase in the overall complication rate was associated with SILS compared with MP appendectomy. The wound complications documented included one incisional hernia for SILS appendectomy and two wound infections for MP appendectomy. Conclusion: The findings showed SILS appendectomy to be a safe and feasible alternative to traditional MP appendectomy that can be conducted with operative times, lengths of stay, and complication rates similar to those of the standardized technique. This review is a precursor to prospective studies, which are warranted to demonstrate conclusively the equivalence of operative times, complications, and lengths of hospital stay, as well as to elucidate differences in patient-centered outcomes including postoperative pain, cosmesis, and quality of life.


Related Articles

  • Outcomes of Pure Laparoscopic versus Open Hepatic Resection for Hepatocellular Carcinoma in Cirrhotic Patients: A Case-Control Study with Propensity Score Matching. Tanaka, Shogo; Takemura, Shigekazu; Shinkawa, Hiroji; Nishioka, Takayoshi; Hamano, Genya; Kinoshita, Masahiko; Ito, Tokuji; Kubo, Shoji // European Surgical Research;Dec2015, Vol. 55 Issue 4, p291 

    Background/Purpose: Laparoscopic hepatic resection (LH) for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) has gradually gained ground as a safe and minimally invasive treatment, although LH for cirrhotic patients remains challenging. Methods: Between January 2007 and August 2014, 28 and 57 patients with...

  • Surgical management of the esophageal leiomyoma: lessons from a retrospective review. Choi, S. H.; Kim, Y. T.; Han, K. N.; Ra, Y. J.; Kang, C. H.; Sung, S. W.; Kim, J. H. // Diseases of the Esophagus;Jun2011, Vol. 24 Issue 5, p325 

    SUMMARY Esophageal leiomyoma is the most common benign tumor of the esophagus. Although enucleation via thoracotomy has been considered standard treatment, minimally invasive surgery is increasingly used for the treatment of this disease. We analyzed our surgical outcomes by comparing...

  • Outcome of medial sphenoidal wing meningioma surgery. El Badry, Ashraf; Abdelazeez, Azza // Romanian Neurosurgery;Mar2018, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p40 

    Background: Sphenoid wing meningiomas among difficult surgery tumours due to involvement of important structures like optic nerve, cavernous sinus or carotid artery. Objective: to evaluate outcome and prognostic factors in patients with medial sphenoid wing meningiomas after microsurgery in a...

  • Resection of Obstructive Left-Sided Colon Cancer at a National Level: A Prospective Analysis of Short-Term Outcomes in 1,816 Patients. Tanis, Pieter J.; Paulino Pereira, Nuno R.; van Hooft, Jeanin E.; Consten, Esther C.J.; Bemelman, Willem a. // Digestive Surgery;Sep2015, Vol. 32 Issue 5, p317 

    Background/Aims: The prematurely closed Stent-In II trial in patients with left-sided obstructive colon cancer may have influenced clinical decision making in The Netherlands. The aim of this study was to evaluate treatment of left-sided malignant colon obstruction at a population level since...

  • Long-Term Outcomes of 80-Watt KTP and 120-Watt HPS GreenLight Photoselective Vaporization of the Prostate. Broggi, E.; May, a.; Giretti, G.; Tabchouri, N.; Lorphelin, H.; Brichart, N.; Bruyère, F. // Urologia Internationalis;Sep2014, Vol. 93 Issue 2, p229 

    Objective: Photoselective vaporization of the prostate (PVP) is becoming a surgical treatment alternative of transurethral resection of the prostate for male lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) secondary to benign prostatic obstruction (BPO). We evaluated the outcome and postoperative...

  • Ureteral Reconstruction after Renal Transplantation: Clinical Outcome and Risk Factors. Alberts, V.P.; Minnee, R.C.; Bemelman, F.J.; van Donselaar-van der Pant, K.A.M.I.; Laguna Pes, P.; Idu, M.M. // Urologia Internationalis;Apr2012, Vol. 88 Issue 3, p333 

    Introduction: The incidence of urological complications after renal transplantation ranges from 2.5 to 30%. Often surgical revision is necessary. The risk factors for surgical revision and which surgical techniques to apply are not elucidated. This study investigates the outcome and risk factors...

  • Comparative Outcomes of the Two Types of Sacral Extradural Spinal Meningeal Cysts Using Different Operation Methods: A Prospective Clinical Study. Sun, Jian-jun; Wang, Zhen-yu; Teo, Mario; Li, Zhen-dong; Wu, Hai-bo; Yen, Ru-yu; Zheng, Mei; Chang, Qing; Yisha Liu, Isabelle // PLoS ONE;Dec2013, Vol. 8 Issue 12, p1 

    This prospective study compares different clinical characteristics and outcomes of patients with two types of sacral extradural spinal meningeal cysts (SESMC) undergoing different means of surgical excision. Using the relationship between the cysts and spinal nerve roots fibers (SNRF) as seen...

  • Adrenal Incidentaloma: The Influence of a Decision-Making Algorithm on the Short-Term Outcome of Laparoscopy. Valeri, Andrea; Bergamini, Carlo; Manca, Giuseppe; Mannelli, Massimo; Presenti, Luigi; Peri, Alessandro; Borrelli, Andrea; Tonelli, Pietro // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Oct2005, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p451 

    Background: At the present time, the precise indications for laparoscopic surgery of adrenal incidentaloma (AI) have yet to be completely clarified. The most controversial issue is the role of laparoscopy in the treatment of potentially malignant and large adrenal masses. Trying to address these...

  • Spectrum of Disease and Outcome among Patients with Acute Diverticulitis. Mäkelä, Jyrki T.; Kiviniemi, Heikki O.; Laitinen, Seppo T. // Digestive Surgery;2010, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p190 

    Background: This study was designed to evaluate the natural history of patients admitted for acute diverticulitis. Methods: Nine hundred and seventy-seven patients admitted to Oulu University Hospital for acute symptoms of diverticular disease during the 20-year period from 1986 to 2005 were...

  • Clinical outcome of endoscopic mucosal resection for esophageal squamous cell cancer invading muscularis mucosa and submucosal layer. Yoshii, T.; Ohkawa, S.; Tamai, S.; Kameda, Y. // Diseases of the Esophagus;Jul2013, Vol. 26 Issue 5, p496 

    SUMMARY When a tumor invades the muscularis mucosa and submucosal layer (T1a-MM and T1b in Japan), esophageal squamous cell cancer poses 10-50% risk of lymph node metastasis. By this stage of esophageal cancer, surgery, although very invasive, is the standard radical therapy for the patients....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics