Crimes Against Minds: On Mental Manipulations, Harms and a Human Right to Mental Self-Determination

Bublitz, Jan; Merkel, Reinhard
January 2014
Criminal Law & Philosophy;Jan2014, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p51
Academic Journal
The neurosciences not only challenge assumptions about the mind's place in the natural world but also urge us to reconsider its role in the normative world. Based on mind-brain dualism, the law affords only one-sided protection: it systematically protects bodies and brains, but only fragmentarily minds and mental states. The fundamental question, in what ways people may legitimately change mental states of others, is largely unexplored in legal thinking. With novel technologies to both intervene into minds and detect mental activity, the law should, we suggest, introduce stand alone protection for the inner sphere of persons. We shall address some metaphysical questions concerning physical and mental harm and demonstrate gaps in current doctrines, especially in regard to manipulative interferences with decision-making processes. We then outline some reasons for the law to recognize a human right to mental liberty and propose elements of a novel criminal offence proscribing severe interventions into other minds.


Related Articles

  • The neuroscience of decision making: Deciphering how the brain chooses and decides.  // Biomedical Market Newsletter;9/26/2011, Vol. 21, p621 

    The article reports that researchers have explored the field of decision neuroscience, with studies shedding light on mental disorders such as depression and schizophrenia.

  • Evidence of Professionalism or Quackery: Measuring Practitioner Awareness of Risk/Need Factors and Effective Treatment Strategies. Flores, Anthony W.; Russell, Amanda L.; Latessa, Edward J.; Travis III, Lawrence F. // Federal Probation;Dec2005, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p9 

    The article examines the level of awareness of juvenile correctional workers on the research relevant to juvenile correctional strategies, the practitioner knowledge of risk factors for delinquency and the fact of empirically supported treatment modalities in the U.S. Practitioners use common...

  • A legalidade da intervanção preventiva e a Carta das Nações Unidas. Granja, Ana Flávia; Platiau, Barros; Silva Vieira, Priscilla Brito // Revista Brasileira de Política Internacional;jul2006, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p179 

    This paper aims to analyze the lawfullness of preventive intervention under the United Nations Charter. The objective is to assess a legal perspective. In doing so, case-studies will be presented to illustrate the arguments in favor of and against the preventive use of force. In addition, the...

  • Human Rights: meaningless to those with mental health issues. De Kleuver, Lorraine // Australian Nursing Journal;Feb2013, Vol. 20 Issue 7, p24 

    The article focuses on the case of an Australian woman who suffered from mental illness, lost her husband quite suddenly and was denied access to his funeral service. In the article the author offers his opinions on the woman's case and on a lack of human rights which is often afforded to people...

  • Concerns voiced over human rights' violations in South African hospitals.  // Mental Health Practice;Mar2003, Vol. 6 Issue 6, p7 

    Reports on the finding that South Africans with mental illnesses who exhibit disturbed behavior have routinely been handcuffed to beds or tied up during their hospital stay. Investigation on the use of seclusion, restraint and sedation in Western Cape; Discovery of anecdotal evidence from staff...

  • Supported Decision-Making for Persons with Mental Illness: A Review. Pathare, Soumitra; Shields, Laura S. // Public Health Reviews (2107-6952);2012, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p1 

    Persons with mental illness (PWMI) are often not afforded the same opportunity to make decisions on a par with others in society. Article 12 of the International Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) states that persons with disabilities should have equal recognition...

  • Solitary Confinement and Mental Illness Among Prison Populations. Bennett, Amy E. // Victimization of the Elderly & Disabled;Sep/Oct2015, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p33 

    The article discusses the impact of solitary confinement on prison inmates. Topics include suicide by prisoner Kalief Browder after suffering violence by inmates and prison guards and solitary confinement; abuse of mentally ill detainees and inmates by correction officers; and views of...

  • Materialisierung des Strafrechts: Funktionen, Folgeprobleme und Perspektiven.  // Zeitschrift für Rechtssoziologie;1989, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p1 

    Summary: Substantivation of Criminal Law: Functions, Follow-up Problems, and Perspectives. This article analyses functions and follow-up problems of substantivized criminal law. Its background is the present debate on the substantivation of law, following Max Weber's early observations, and the...

  • Neurolaw and Direct Brain Interventions. A Vincent, Nicole // Criminal Law & Philosophy;Jan2014, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p43 

    This issue of Criminal Law and Philosophy contains three papers on a topic of increasing importance within the field of 'neurolaw'-namely, the implications for criminal law of direct brain intervention based mind altering techniques (DBI's). To locate these papers' topic within a broader...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics