TITLE

Harm and Wrongdoing in Criminalisation Theory

AUTHOR(S)
von Hirsch, Andreas
PUB. DATE
January 2014
SOURCE
Criminal Law & Philosophy;Jan2014, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p245
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Contemporary theories of criminalisation address, with varying emphasis, themes concerning the harmfulness and the wrongfulness of the conduct. In his article for the present issue, Antony Duff relies chiefly on notions of wrongfulness as the basis for his proposed criminalisation doctrines; whereas in their 2011 volume on criminalisation, Andrew Simester and Andreas von Hirsch invoke both wrongfulness and harmfulness as prerequisites for prohibiting conduct. The present article assesses the comparative merits of these approaches, and argues in favour of the latter, two-element perspective. In this article, the author puts forward a number of reasons suggesting why the two-element approach (of wrongfulness and harm) is preferable. These reasons include, firstly, an inductive argument-that the kinds of wrongful conduct for which criminalisation seems a plausible response are those that include an element of harm or risk of harm. Secondly, a defining role for the state is one of resource-protection: of safeguarding the means and resources through which citizens can live good lives. Thus the concept of citizens' living resources-and the related conception of harm-should be made a constitutive and explicit element of criminalisation theory, rather than subsuming resource-protection under a general rubric of wrongfulness. Thirdly, a two-element approach provides reciprocal limiting principles concerning the scope of criminalisation. One can, for example, employ wrongfulness requirements to limit the criminalisation of conduct that has remote harmful consequences; and, conversely, use a harmfulness requirement as means for restricting the criminalisation of wrongful acts.
ACCESSION #
93447632

 

Related Articles

  • Towards a Modest Legal Moralism: Concept, Open Questions, and Potential Extension. Meyer, F. // Criminal Law & Philosophy;Jan2014, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p237 

    The article introduces and critiques Antony Duff's Modest Legal Moralism from a strictly analytical angle. It seeks to illuminate its core tenets and modestly addresses a number of aspects that deserve further elaboration from the author's point of view. Notwithstanding these points of...

  • CHANGES AND CONTINUITIES IN CRIME IN URUGUAY (1878-1907). Fessler, Daniel // Passagens: International Review of Political History & Legal Cul;May2013, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p321 

    Crime and punishment, especially in Uruguay, constitute an object of study frequently neglected by historians. Their analysis appears to be traditionally reserved for the "legal world". Their transformations are thus often accounted for by the law itself, depriving them of their social,...

  • THE IMPORTANCE OF UTOPIAS IN CRIMINOLOGICAL THINKING. Young, Peter // British Journal of Criminology;Autumn92, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p423 

    A paper on the importance of utopias in criminological thinking is presented. It is asserted that utopias have demonstrated that criminology is not a cumulative discipline in the sense of non-existence of a settled stock of knowledge. Also, utopias are responsible for the fractious argumentative...

  • CAMBIOS Y PERMANENCIAS DEL CRIMEN EN URUGUAY (1878-1907). Fessler, Daniel // Passagens: International Review of Political History & Legal Cul;May2013, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p324 

    Crime and punishment, especially in Uruguay, constitute an object of study frequently neglected by historians. Their analysis appears to be traditionally reserved for the "legal world". Their transformations are thus often accounted for by the law itself, depriving them of their social,...

  • The New School of Convict Criminology Thrives and Matures. Richards, Stephen // Critical Criminology;Sep2013, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p375 

    This article discusses the past, present, and future of the New School of Convict Criminology (CC). A short history, including a discussion of literature, major works, and research studies is provided as is a review of Convict Criminology Group origination, membership, and activities. A first...

  • Rescuing Fair-Play as a Justification for Punishment. Stichter, Matt K. // Res Publica (13564765);Feb2010, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p73 

    The debate over whether 'fair-play' can serve as a justification for legal punishment has recently resumed with an exchange between Richard Dagger and Antony Duff. According to the fair-play theorist, criminals deserve punishment for breaking the law because in so doing the criminal upsets a...

  • RADICALISM IN LAW AND CRIMINOLOGY: A RETROSPECTIVE VIEW OF CRITICAL LEGAL STUDIES AND RADICAL CRIMINOLOGY. Cardarelli, Albert P.; Hicks, Stephen C. // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Fall93, Vol. 84 Issue 3, p502 

    This article focuses on the development of a detailed history and critique of Radical Criminology and Critical Legal Studies (CLS) in the context of the last thirty years--a period that now seems fateful for the Left generally, while calling into question its continued viability in the future....

  • Introduction: special issue on criminology. Ericson, Richard V. // Canadian Journal of Sociology;Summer80, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p209 

    For sociologists, studying the organization of crime control vis-a-vis those it processes and those it serves is one substantive vehicle for studying the properties of social life in general. Crime and other forms of deviance provide good substance for inquiry because they are useful in...

  • An absence of alternatives. Podmore, John // Howard League Magazine;May2005, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p5 

    The article presents information on the Social Exclusion Unit report (SEU) on reducing reoffending by ex-prisoners. It is one of the most important documents to inform the criminal justice system in recent years. It describes the individuals whose offending has the greatest negative effect on...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics