Optimal Asylum

Ray, Shalini Bhargava
November 2013
Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law;Nov2013, Vol. 46 Issue 5, p1215
Academic Journal
The U.S. asylum system is noble but flawed. Scholars have long recognized that asylum is a "scarce" political resource, but U.S. law persists in distributing access to asylum based on an asylum seeker's ability to circumvent migration controls rather than the strength of the asylum seeker's claim for protection. To apply for asylum, an asylum seeker must either arrange to be smuggled into the United States or lie to the consulate while abroad to obtain a nonimmigrant visa. Nonimmigrant visa requirements effectively filter the pool of asylum applicants according to wealth, educational attainment, and intent not to remain in the United States indefinitely--criteria completely unrelated to or at odds with the purposes of refugee law. The system as currently designed, therefore, selects asylum seekers based entirely on their ability to satisfy irrelevant criteria and without regard to their relative need for protection from persecution. Such a system fails to maximize the humanitarian benefits of scarce U.S. asylum resources. To better protect individuals facing serious persecution, this Article contends, Congress should consider reforming the immigration laws to provide for an "asylum visa" to be made available to certain foreign nationals. U.S. consulates abroad, under proper and limited circumstances, might issue this visa to foreign nationals who demonstrate a credible fear of persecution on a ground enumerated in the United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (Refugee Convention). Applicants would then lawfully enter the United States and apply for asylum. Successful applicants would remain, and unsuccessful applicants would face removal. Drawing on the extant literature on "protected entry procedures" (PEPs) that once existed in Europe, this Article considers the costs and benefits of the practice of issuing asylum visas. This Article concludes that, despite serious and uncertain costs and the impracticability of issuing asylum visas in some countries, this practice would likely create substantial benefits. In particular, it would likely decrease asylum seekers' reliance on human smugglers, clear a path to protection for bona fide asylum seekers, and increase the accuracy of information possessed by both asylum seekers and the U.S. government. Thus, the asylum visa would assist asylum seekers in making better-informed decisions ex ante and help to achieve a better allocation of asylum resources ex post. For these reasons, the creation of an asylum visa and the potential details of such a proposal merit further study.


Related Articles

  • Congress should stop immigration now. Reese, Charley // Caribbean Business;7/22/1993, Vol. 21 Issue 29, p55 

    Contends that the United States Congress should pass emergency legislation imposing a five-year moratorium on all immigration into the United States. Economic conditions; Political asylum laws.

  • Deliberate Destitution as Deterrent: Withholding the Right to Work and Undermining Asylum Protection. NESSEL, LORI A. // San Diego Law Review;Spring2015, Vol. 52 Issue 2, p313 

    The article focuses on the fears and policy goals that led U.S. Congress to dramatically curtail protection and the right to work for asylum seekers. It mentions that the ban on employment for asylum seekers increases the criminalization of immigration law and inconsistent with other...

  • US Embassy to Turkey limits operations due to 'possible security threat'.  // Journal of Turkish Weekly;12/15/2015, p137 

    The article reports on the move of the U.S. embassy in Ankara, Turkey, to limit its consular services on December 14 and 15, 2015 due to security reasons. An official from the embassy declined to comment on the nature of the security threat. The embassy has canceled public services, including...

  • Random Justice.  // Atlantic;Oct2007, Vol. 300 Issue 3, p33 

    The article summarizes a study by three law professors about what factors count most in determining whether a refugee can gain asylum in the U.S. Acceptance rates vary widely across U.S states and among federal judges. The gender and ethnicity of the applicant seem to play a significant role as...

  • Ser perseguido por bandas como motivo de asilo en EE.UU. Cheng, Gracye // Revista Migraciones Forzadas;abr2011, Issue 37, p36 

    No abstract available.

  • Nigerian Mother Claims Asylum in USA for Daughter and Herself.  // Women's International Network News;Summer99, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p76 

    Reports on the asylum requested by a Nigerian woman from the United States government for her daughter and herself. Concerns regarding their return to Nigeria; Immigration law governing the case; Results of a related court case in New York State.

  • The Impact of Externalization of Migration Controls on the Rights of Asylum Seekers and Other Migrants. Frelick, Bill; Kysel, Ian M.; Podkul, Jennifer // Journal on Migration & Human Security;2016, Vol. 4 Issue 4, p190 

    Wars, conflict, and persecution have forced more people to fee their homes and seek refuge and safety elsewhere than at any time since the end of World War II. As displaced people and other migrants increasingly move out of the conflict-ridden and less developed regions of their displacement and...

  • Immigration reform--the true conservative approach. Hall, Gene // Texas Agriculture Magazine;5/2/2014, Vol. 29 Issue 18, p2 

    The author argues against the tagging of the opposition to the U.S. immigration reform as a conservative approach and advices that better conservative approach is to develop an effective guest worker visa program.

  • Don't wait for government to remind you about your rights, benefits, deadlines. GURFINKEL, MICHAEL J. // Filipino Reporter;5/30/2014, Vol. 42 Issue 26, p37 

    The article discusses an immigration case wherein a person is eligible for a visa or other benefits related to immigration but circumstances such as the death of a petitioner lead to the withdrawal of the petition by the U.S. National Visa Center (NVC).


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics