Quantification of the Trade-Off Between Force Attenuation and Balance Impairment in the Design of Compliant Safety Floors

Glinka, Michal N.; Cheema, Kim P.; Robinovitch, Stephen N.; Laing, Andrew C.
October 2013
Journal of Applied Biomechanics;Oct2013, Vol. 29 Issue 5, p563
Academic Journal
Safety floors (also known as compliant floors) may reduce the risk of fall-related injuries by attenuating impact force during falls, but are only practical if they do not negatively affect balance and mobility. In this study, we evaluated seven safety surfaces based on their ability to attenuate peak femoral neck force during simulated hip impacts, and their influence on center of pressure (COP) sway during quiet and tandem stance. Overall, we found that some safety floors can attenuate up to 33.7% of the peak femoral impact force without influencing balance. More specifically, during simulated hip impacts, force attenuation for the safety floors ranged from 18.4 (SD 4.3)% to 47.2 (3.1)%, with each floor significantly reducing peak force compared with a rigid surface. For quiet stance, only COP root mean square was affected by flooring (and increased for only two safety floors). During tandem stance, COP root mean square and mean velocity increased in the medial-lateral direction for three of the seven floors. Based on the substantial force attenuation with no concomitant effects on balance for some floors, these results support the development of clinical trials to assess the effectiveness of safety floors at reducing fall-related injuries in high-risk settings.


Related Articles

  • The Effect of Jump-Landing Directions on Dynamic Stability. Liu, Kathy; Heise, Gary D. // Journal of Applied Biomechanics;Oct2013, Vol. 29 Issue 5, p634 

    Dynamic stability is often measured by time to stabilization (TTS), which is calculated from the dwindling fluctuations of ground reaction force (GRF) components over time. Common protocols of dynamic stability research have involved forward or vertical jumps, neglecting different jump-landing...

  • Kinematic Variability in Running: A Caution Regarding Use of the Spanning Set Measure. Hanlon, Michael; Kearney, Philip; Condell, Joan // Journal of Applied Biomechanics;Feb2012, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p99 

    The spanning set technique quantifies intertrial variability as the span between polynomial curves representing upper and lower standard deviation curves of a repeated movement. This study aimed to assess the validity of the spanning set technique in quantifying variability and specifically to...

  • The Roles of Whole Body Balance, Shoe-Floor Friction, and Joint Strength During Maximum Exertions: Searching for the "Weakest Link". Fischer, Steven L.; Picco, Bryan R.; Wells, Richard P.; Dickerson, Clark R. // Journal of Applied Biomechanics;Feb2013, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p1 

    Exerting manual forces is critical during occupational performance. Therefore, being able to estimate maximum force capacity is particularly useful for determining how these manual exertion demands relate to available capacity. To facilitate this type of prediction requires a complete...

  • Negative Effects on Postural Control After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction as Measured by the Balance Error Scoring System. Smith, Mason D.; Bell, David R. // Journal of Sport Rehabilitation;Aug2013, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p224 

    Context: Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is the standard of care for individuals with ACL rupture. Balance deficits have been observed in patients with ACL reconstruction (ACLR) using advanced posturography, which is the current gold standard. It is unclear if postural-control...

  • COMPARISON OF THE IMMEDIATE EFFECT OF DIFFERENT TYPES OF TRUNK EXERCISE ON THE STAR EXCURSION BALANCE TEST IN MALE ADOLESCENT SOCCER PLAYERS. Atsushi Imai; Koji Kaneoka; Yu Okubo; Hitoshi Shiraki // International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy;Aug2014, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p428 

    Purpose/Background: Trunk exercises, such as trunk stabilization exercises (SE) and conventional trunk exercises (CE), are performed to improve static or dynamic balance. Recently, trunk exercises have also been often used as part of warm-up programs. A few studies have demonstrated the...

  • Comparison of Two- and Three-Dimensional Methods for Analysis of Trunk Kinematic Variables in the Golf Swing. Smith, Aimée C.; Roberts, Jonathan R.; Wallace, Eric S.; Pui Kong; Forrester, Stephanie E. // Journal of Applied Biomechanics;Feb2016, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p23 

    Two-dimensional methods have been used to compute trunk kinematic variables (flexion/extension, lateral bend, axial rotation) and X-factor (difference in axial rotation between trunk and pelvis) during the golf swing. Recent X-factor studies advocated three-dimensional (3D) analysis due to the...

  • Handle Shape Affects the Grip Force Distribution and the Muscle Loadings During Power Grip Tasks. Rossi, Jérémy; Goislard De Monsabert, Benjamin; Berton, Eric; Vigouroux, Laurent // Journal of Applied Biomechanics;Dec2015, Vol. 31 Issue 6, p430 

    The objectives of this study were to investigate the effect of handle shape on the grip force distribution in the hand and on the muscle forces during maximal power grip tasks. Eleven subjects maximally grasped 3 handles with different external shapes (circular, elliptic, and double-frustum). A...

  • THE ROLE OF ANTHROPOMETRIC CHANGES DUE TO AGING ON HUMAN WALKING: MECHANICAL WORK, PENDULUM AND EFFICIENCY. Schuch, C. P.; Balbinot, G.; Boos, M.; Peyré-Tartaruga, L. A.; Susta, D. // Biology of Sport;2011, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p165 

    The aging process modifies body composition and the inertial properties of body limbs might change accordingly. Pendular energy exchange, mechanical work and locomotion efficiency should be affected by these changes. To check this hypothesis, seven elderly subjects were asked to walk on a...

  • Compression Garments: No Enhancement of High-Intensity Exercise in Hot Radiant Conditions. Barwood, Martin J.; Corbett, Jo; Feeney, John; Hannaford, Paul; Henderson, Dan; Jones, Ian; Kirke, Jade // International Journal of Sports Physiology & Performance;Sep2013, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p527 

    Purpose: To establish the thermal and performance effects of wearing a lower-body graduated compression garment (GCG) in a hot environment (35.2°C ± 0.1°C) with a representative radiant heat load (~800 W/m2) in contrast to a control (running shorts) and sham condition (a compression...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics