TITLE

Dealing with Legal Conflicts in the Information Society. An Informational Understanding of Balancing Competing Interests

AUTHOR(S)
Durante, Massimo
PUB. DATE
December 2013
SOURCE
Philosophy & Technology;Dec2013, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p437
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
The present paper aims at addressing a crucial legal conflict in the information society: i.e., the conflict between security and civil rights, which calls for a “fine and ethical balance”. Our purpose is to understand, from the legal theory viewpoint, how a fine ethical balance can be conceived and what the conditions for this balance to be possible are. This requires us to enter in a four-stage examination, by asking: (1) What types of conflict may be dealt with by means of balancing? (2) What is meant by balancing? Is it a metaphor that hides and dissimulates discretionary powers and subjective decisions or a rational instrument that helps us cope with conflicts between fundamental values and interests? (3) What models of balancing are available to us? Are these models irreducible to each other? What can provide us with a common understanding of different models of balancing? (4) How can the crucial issues of rational controllability, predictability, and homogeneity of legal decisions be dealt with? Our paper will try to answer those questions by trying to reconstruct the act of balancing in terms of a rational legal reasoning, which relies upon information. In fact, every judicial decision contains some information that is delivered to the legal system: that information may serve as the basis for future evaluations, decisions, and actions, and thus influence the way we recognize and hence we protect our values, interests, and rights. In this perspective, our examination will attempt to understand those questions in informational terms. This informational treatment can provide us with a more universalistic understanding of those issues and offer us a novel way to conceptually deal with them. To this aim, we will avail yourself of Luciano Floridi’s philosophy of information: notably, we believe his constructionist conception of epistemology is crucial, based on the Maker’s Knowledge approach and his solution of the upgrading problem (i.e., from information to knowledge) in terms of a network theory of account. The informational approach will help us having a better understanding of the balance between competing interests.
ACCESSION #
91992771

 

Related Articles

  • THE "PRINCIPLE OF PUBLICITY" AND POLICIES OF THE INFORMATION AGE. Venturelli, Shalini // Javnost-The Public;1995, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p7 

    No abstract available.

  • TITLE VII PROTECTIONS FOR INMATES: A MODEL APPROACH FOR SAFEGUARDING CIVIL RIGHTS IN AMERICA'S PRISONS. Kirklin, Jackson Taylor // Columbia Law Review;Jun2011, Vol. 111 Issue 5, p1048 

    No abstract available.

  • Resolution of Support.  // Social Policy;Winter2001, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p31 

    The article outlines a resolution in support of the Charleston Dockworkers passed on April 11, 2001. Whereas, the longshore workers of International Longshoremen's Association (ILA) Local 1422 and Local 1771, like all workers, have a right to picket in defense of their jobs; and whereas the...

  • Reconciling Equal Protection and Religious Liberty. Foltin, Richard T. // Human Rights;Jan2013, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p2 

    The article presents information on the prospects on the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and the Religious Liberty Protection Act (RLPA) in the U.S. According to the author, the collapse of a consensus in support of a broader standard protecting religious free exercise between of RFRA...

  • Juggling act. Wood, Bill // Lawyer;4/19/2004, Vol. 18 Issue 15, p27 

    Considers attitudes of lawyers in Great Britain towards mediation. Judges' promotion of alternative dispute resolution; Suggestion that the present use of mediation infringes a citizen's right under Article 6 of the Human Rights Act; Operative clause of the mediation law.

  • On Setting Priorities among Human Rights. Philips, Jos // Human Rights Review;Sep2014, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p239 

    Should conflicts among human rights be dealt with by including general principles for priority setting at some prominent place in the practice of human rights? This essay argues that neither setting prominent and principled priorities nor a case-by-case approach are likely to be defensible as...

  • Newsom asks Brown to help mediate Badlands dispute. Bajko, Matthew S. // Bay Area Reporter;6/30/2005, Vol. 35 Issue 26, p1 

    Reports that Mayor Gavin Newson has asked his predecessor, Willie Brown, to mediate in the Badlands' dispute in San Francisco, California. Knowledge of Brown's in handling civil and gay rights issues; Assessment of the problems within the African American and gay community; Accusation of racist...

  • Property Rights Assignment: Conflict and the Implementability of Rules. Annen, Kurt // Economics of Governance;2006, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p155 

    The paper studies the assignment of property rights. By assignment I mean a social mechanism that transfers a valuable resource from an “unowned” state to an “owned” state (for example, a first-possession rule). I argue that any assignment mechanism faces an...

  • Unreasonable expectations. Rosendall, Richard J. // Bay Windows;5/4/2006, Vol. 24 Issue 20, p6 

    The article suggests an effective approach to achieving victory in battles ranging from simple to complicated social issues. Changing minds sufficiently to affect public policy requires more than confidence and marketing. It requires challenging people. Sitting back and hoping that someone else...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sign out of this library

Other Topics