Aggregating with reason(s)

Cariani, Fabrizio
October 2013
Synthese;Oct2013, Vol. 190 Issue 15, p3123
Academic Journal
Judgment aggregation is naturally applied to the modeling of collective attitudes. In the individual case, we represent agents as having not just beliefs, but also as supporting them with reasons. Can the Judgment Aggregation help model a concept of collective reason? I argue that the resources of the standard judgment aggregation framework are insufficiently general. I develop a generalization of the framework that improves along this dimension. In the new framework, new aggregation rules become available, as well as a natural account of collective reasons.


Related Articles

  • Instrumental rationality, symmetry and scope. Brunero, John // Philosophical Studies;Jan2012, Vol. 157 Issue 1, p125 

    Instrumental rationality prohibits one from being in the following state: intending to pass a test, not intending to study, and believing one must intend to study if one is to pass. One could escape from this incoherent state in three ways: by intending to study, by not intending to pass, or by...

  • Irrational Belief Tests: New Insights, New Directions. Robb III, Harold B.; Warren, Ricks // Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy;Fall1990, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p303 

    Critical appraisals of the RET model have been accompanied by closer scrutiny of measures designed to assess irrational beliefs. Problems with content and discriminant validity (Smith, 1982), and inclusion of items which describe feelings or behaviors rather than beliefs (Ramanaiah, Heerboth, &...

  • Gallup poll results: Hell/devil gainers science/rationality losers.  // Skeptic;1996, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p20 

    Reports on the increase in the American public's belief in the spiritual realm. Factors affecting beliefs on the paranormal and spiritual claims.

  • Measures of Attitudinal Consistency as Indicators of Ideological Sophistication: A Reliability and Validity Assessment. Wyckoff, Mikel L. // Journal of Politics;Feb87, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p148 

    Provides information on a study which reappraised the methods used in the study of mass belief systems which supported the assumption that attitudinal consistency is a valid indicator of ideological sophistication. Data and method; Information on attitudinal consistency and level of...

  • The Girl Who Cried Shaykh. Mair, J. Samia // Azizah;Dec2011, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p55 

    A personal narrative is presented which explores the author's experience faltering on some beliefs but has learned an insightful perception on indulgent appetites and disliked things.

  • NEW BOOKS: ANTHOLOGIES.  // Journal of Philosophy;May1988, Vol. 85 Issue 5, p279 

    No abstract available.

  • A Surefire Recipe for Unassailable Faith: Involving Four Judgments and a Vegetable Analogy. Doucet, Therese // Hotel Amerika;Fall2010, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p29 

    The article presents the author's views on faith and four judgments related to it. She states that if faith was worth having and God was worth believing, then she would have had faith. She mentions that if one chooses to have faith and believe that God exists then there are other things also...

  • Why There Are No Epistemic Duties. Wrenn, Chase B. // Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review;Winter2007, Vol. 46 Issue 1, p115 

    Epistemic duties would be duties to believe, disbelieve, or withhold judgement from propositions, and they would be grounded in purely evidential considerations. I offer a new argument for the claim that there are no epistemic duties. Though people may have duties to believe, disbelieve, or...

  • Evolution and the Normativity of Epistemic Reasons. Street, Sharon // Canadian Journal of Philosophy;Dec2009 Supplement, Vol. 35, p213 

    The article discusses epistemic normativity, arguing that antirealism should apply both to practical reason and to questions of knowledge in order to be consistent. It is said that there are no normative facts calling for belief or action that are independent of evaluative attitudes. The author...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics