On the role of simplicity in science

Scorzato, Luigi
September 2013
Synthese;Sep2013, Vol. 190 Issue 13, p2867
Academic Journal
Simple assumptions represent a decisive reason to prefer one theory to another in everyday scientific praxis. But this praxis has little philosophical justification, since there exist many notions of simplicity, and those that can be defined precisely strongly depend on the language in which the theory is formulated. The language dependence is a natural feature—to some extent—but it is also believed to be a fatal problem, because, according to a common general argument, the simplicity of a theory is always trivial in a suitably chosen language. But, this trivialization argument is typically either applied to toy-models of scientific theories or applied with little regard for the empirical content of the theory. This paper shows that the trivialization argument fails, when one considers realistic theories and requires their empirical content to be preserved. In fact, the concepts that enable a very simple formulation, are not necessarily measurable, in general. Moreover, the inspection of a theory describing a chaotic billiard shows that precisely those concepts that naturally make the theory extremely simple are provably not measurable. This suggests that—whenever a theory possesses sufficiently complex consequences—the constraint of measurability prevents too simple formulations in any language. This explains why the scientists often regard their assessments of simplicity as largely unambiguous. In order to reveal a cultural bias in the scientists’ assessment, one should explicitly identify different characterizations of simplicity of the assumptions that lead to different theory selections. General arguments are not sufficient.


Related Articles

  • Does a Parsimony Principle Entail a Simple World? DeLancey, Craig // Metaphysica;Oct2011, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p87 

    Many scholars claim that a parsimony principle has ontological implications. The most common such claim is that a parsimony principle entails that the 'world' is simple. This ontological claim appears to often be coupled with the assumption that a parsimony principle would be corroborated if the...

  • Quantitative Parsimony, Explanatory Power and Dark Matter. Vanderburgh, William // Journal for General Philosophy of Science;Oct2014, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p317 

    Baker (Br J Philos Sci 54:245-259, ) argues that quantitative parsimony-the principle that hypotheses requiring fewer entities are to be preferred over their empirically equivalent rivals-is a rational methodological criterion because it maximizes explanatory power. Baker lends plausibility to...

  • Relevance of Correlation Dimension and Kolmogorov Entropy in the State Discriminant of Gearbox. Xiangdong Mao; Huiqun Yuan; Huagang Sun // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2014, Issue 644-650, p858 

    This paper introduces the basic principles and calculation methods for the correlation dimension and Kolmogorov entropy. By calculating the correlation dimension and Kolmogorov entropy when the gear is under different working conditions, we can analyze the inherent relationship between the two...

  • Gruesome Connections. McGowan, Mary Kate // Philosophical Quarterly;Jan2002, Vol. 52 Issue 206, p21 

    It is widely recognized that Goodman's grue example demonstrates' that the rules for induction, unlike those for deduction, cannot be purely syntactic. Ways in which Goodman's proof generalizes, however, are not widely recognized. Gruesome considerations demonstrate that neither theories of...

  • The Ideological Reductionism. Dinu, Marin // Theoretical & Applied Economics;Oct2011, Vol. 18 Issue 10, p1 

    The article discusses Ideological Reductionism in Economics and states that the form of parsimony in the context of postmodern neo reductionism is the construction of analyses in the self-sufficiency of mainstream theory hypotheses. It is stated that theory occupies an epicenter of...

  • A Comparison of Three Occam's Razors for Markovian Causal Models. Zhang, Jiji // British Journal for the Philosophy of Science;Jun2013, Vol. 64 Issue 2, p423 

    The framework of causal Bayes nets, currently influential in several scientific disciplines, provides a rich formalism to study the connection between causality and probability from an epistemological perspective. This article compares three assumptions in the literature that seem to constrain...

  • Nonlinear Dynamic Properties of Acupuncture Point Signals. Zimin Wang; Yonghong Tan; Miyong Su // International Journal of Advancements in Computing Technology;Jan2013, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p844 

    In this paper, the nonlinear dynamic properties were introduced to the analysis of the acupuncture point signals from a meridian channel, i.e. the signals acquired from the Lung Channel of Hand-Taiyin (LU). Then, Lyapunov exponent, Kolmogorov entropy, correlation dimension etc. nonlinear dynamic...

  • Three subsets of sequence complexity and their relevance to biopolymeric information. Abel, David L.; Trevors, Jack T. // Theoretical Biology & Medical Modelling;2005, Vol. 2, p29 

    Genetic algorithms instruct sophisticated biological organization. Three qualitative kinds of sequence complexity exist: random (RSC), ordered (OSC), and functional (FSC). FSC alone provides algorithmic instruction. Random and Ordered Sequence Complexities lie at opposite ends of the same...

  • Possibilities of predicting flare productivity based on magnetic field power spectra in active regions. Abramenko, V. // Geomagnetism & Aeronomy;Dec2015, Vol. 55 Issue 7, p860 

    Photospheric plasma is in a state of developed turbulence. Chaotic motions in the photosphere and below are among the main sources of eruptive processes in the solar atmosphere. The magnetic field power spectra, as measured in the active region (AR) photosphere, were used as a source of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics