The Antitrust Constitution

Nachbar, Thomas B.
November 2013
Iowa Law Review;Nov2013, Vol. 99 Issue 1, p57
Academic Journal
Antitrust is today viewed almost exclusively in strictly economic terms. Under the nearly ubiquitous "rule of reason, " conduct is condemned or saved by courts largely based on their evaluation of the conduct's effect on economic efficiency. But many aspects of antitrust law cannot be explained by efficiency analysis. The full sweep of antitrust makes sense only when one considers other values that underlie the antitrust laws, values contained in the allocation of public and private power inherent in the larger constitutional order. This Article attempts to provide a more comprehensive understanding of antitrust as policing the private exercise of regulatory power. This Article considers both the dominant, efficiency-maximizing approach to antitrust and the "societal" alternatives offered by critics. The two approaches are more alike than they are different, and gaps in each suggest a missing factor in both approaches: a recognition that a harm to competition consists of both a harm to efficiency (a "market harm") and a harm to freedom of choice (a "regulatory harm"). After developing a conception of "régulation" as control over properly separated from ownership, this Article explores the constitutional law of private regulation--the constitutional prohibition against delegations of governmental power to private parties---followed by a discussion of the same prindples in the specific context of antitrust and identifies the nature of the right to choice that the antitrust laws protect. This Article then considers specific implications of recognizing the role of regulatory harms in antitrust, including changes to how antitrust treats horizontal and vertical restraints and mergers, the ability to explain some cases--especially in the area of tying--often considered outliers when viewed exclusively through the lens of economic analysis, and the possibility of a renewed role for concepts that have been largely forgotten in the rise of the rule of reason, such as conduct, intent, and the role of the per se rule in antitrust.


Related Articles


    The article discusses corporate jurisprudence in Delaware pertaining to corporate takeovers, with focus given to the concept of proportionality. Delaware court cases are discussed in relation to the concept, including Unocal Corp. v. Mesa Petroleum C., Cheff v. Mathes, and Unitrin, Inc. v....

  • Merger remedies in the European Union: An overview. Motta, Massimo; Polo, Michele; Vasconcelos, Helder // Antitrust Bulletin;Fall/Winter 2007, Vol. 52 Issue 3/4, p603 

    This article provides information on the issues concerning merger remedies in the European Union. It has recently been observed that the merger task force of the European Commission (EC) has been adopting a tougher stance in merger control. In addition, the EC Notice on merger remedies would be...

  • New government merger rules may stimulate growth and acquisition. Jacobsen, Raymond A.; Megregian, Scott S. // Business Forum;Winter/Spring93, Vol. 18 Issue 1/2, p21 

    Discusses how guidelines for evaluating the legality of mergers and acquisitions under United States antitrust laws issued by the Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission may affect businesses. Competitive effects test to determine whether a merger should be opposed by the government;...

  • Does it pay to fight a rival's deal in court? Smith, Tefft W.; Sterling, Hillard M. // Mergers & Acquisitions: The Dealermaker's Journal;Sep/Oct96, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p21 

    Focuses on the legal basis of filing antitrust lawsuits against corporate mergers in the United States. Principles involved in antitrust injury requirements; Applicability of the principles according to the case, Mr. Furniture Warehouse Inc. vs. Barclay's American/Commercial Inc. INSETS:...

  • NEW ANTI-MERGER THEORIES: A CRITIQUE. Lopez, Edward J. // CATO Journal;Winter2001, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p359 

    Evaluates anti-merger instruments in the United States (U.S.) on the basis of economic theory and evidence. Increase of merger activity in the U.S.; Emergence of innovative merger laws; Discussion on the structure-conduct performance paradigm based the economics of antitrust; Use of innovative...

  • Antitrust policy and vertical mergers. Rosengren, Eric S.; Meehan Jr., James W. // New England Economic Review;Sep/Oct95, p27 

    Examines the empirical evidence of anticompetitive foreclosure in vertical mergers challenged by the US Justice Department and the Federal Trade Commission from 1963 to 1982. Lack of evidence of anticompetitive market foreclosure for the sample of vertical merger cases challenged by the...

  • INTERNATIONAL MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS�EMERGING ISSUES AND SPECIAL PROBLEMS. Barnard, Robert C. // Antitrust Law Journal;1971, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p858 

    Focuses on the issues and problems prior to international mergers and acquisitions. Regulations of Sherman Act and the Clayton Act on commercial operations; Analysis of cases using the provisions of antitrust laws; Assessment of antitrust enforcement on multinational corporation activities.

  • OVERVIEW: COMPETITIVE PRINCIPLES IN REGULATED INDUSTRIES. Zimmerman, Edwin M. // Antitrust Law Journal;1970, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p427 

    Focuses on the antitrust laws and the schemes of statutory regulation of specific industries in the United States. Interplay of the antitrust principles; Evaluation of jurisdictional problems within the regulated industries; Approval of mergers for natural gas pipelines by the Federal Power...

  • Can international antitrust be saved for the post-Boeing merger world? A proposal to minimize.... Gifford, Daniel J.; Sullivan, E. Thomas // Antitrust Bulletin;Spring2000, Vol. 45 Issue 1, p55 

    Proposes a way to minimize international conflict arising from the administration and enforcement of antitrust and competition laws in the context of mergers between corporations. Justification of efficiency as the guiding principle in the application of the laws; Potential benefits of the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics