TITLE

The Doctor's Dilemma: The Utilitarian Medical Ethics of Nazi Physician Karl Brandt

AUTHOR(S)
Schultz, Joshua J.
PUB. DATE
May 2013
SOURCE
University of Toronto Medical Journal;May2013, Vol. 90 Issue 4, p176
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Before World War II German physicians and scientists were responsible for major advances in medicine. The actions of doctors in the Nazi system were an aberration of this legacy; however, not all Nazi doctors operated in an ethical vacuum. This paper examines the doctors' trial at Nuremberg in 1946. This paper draws attention to the utilitarian medical ethics of the Nazi doctor Karl Brandt and discusses how utilitarianism still informs medical practice today. The Hippocratic Oath was cited by the prosecution at the Nuremberg doctors' trial as part of the common law of medicine. Brandt and his defense lawyer Dr. Robert Servatius countered by arguing that Brandt was acting in the best interests of the state. He and Servatius argued that the morality of German doctors in the Nazi system represented an alternate medical ethics to that practiced in western democracies. In the end Brandt was found guilty of negligence due to the presence of non-German citizens in the T-4 "euthanasia" program of which Brandt had been in charge. "Brandt's trial highlights utilitarianism in medical ethics whereby physicians are responsible for determining the cost that treatment of the individual represents to the community. The community sets limits and physicians must work within those limits, but in order to act as a bulwark to malevolent state power as existed in Nazi Germany, physicians have a duty to advocate for life and treatment whenever possible.
ACCESSION #
91654214

 

Related Articles

  • Vain wisdom all, and false philosophy.  // Hastings Center Report;Nov/Dec92, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p5 

    Comments on a conference in Oslo which threw doubt on the idea of a steady increase in interest, and work, in bioethics in the old Soviet empire. Communist views expressed at the conference; The paper by Zbigniew Szawarski; More.

  • View the third. Reiser, Stanley J. // Hastings Center Report;Nov/Dec93, Vol. 23 Issue 6, pS13 

    Focuses on the nature and history of medical ethics. Challenge to basic categories and beliefs as nature of medical technology; Parallelism of the history of the artificial respirator and the bioethics movement; Dark side of technology; Ethics of life support systems; Point of view of the...

  • BEFORE BIOETHICS: A HISTORY OF AMERICAN MEDICAL ETHICS FROM THE COLONIAL PERIOD TO THE BIOETHICS REVOLUTION. Gillum, R. // Journal of Religion & Health;Feb2014, Vol. 53 Issue 1, p298 

    No abstract available.

  • Geschichten vom Hippokratischen Eid. Totelin, Laurence // Medical History;Jan2010, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p135 

    The article reviews the book "Geschichten vom Hippokratischen Eid," by Thomas Rütten.

  • Bernard de Gordon (fl. 1270-1330): medieval physician and teacher. Pearn, John // Journal of Medical Biography;Feb2013, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p8 

    The Montpellier physician Bernard de Gordon flourished in the late Middle Ages in the era when university education first evolved in the training of European physicians. Fragmentary details of his life and medical influence are known from seven books, particularly his extensive (163 chapters)...

  • Is consent in medicine a concept only of modern times? Dalla-Vorgia, P; Lascaratos, J; Skiadas, P; Garanis-Papadatos, T // Journal of Medical Ethics;Feb2001, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p59 

    Although the issue of consent in medical practice has grown immensely in recent years, and it is generally believed that historical cases are unknown, our research amongst original ancient Greek and Byzantine historical sources reveals that it is a very old subject which ancient philosophers and...

  • The Cambridge World History of Medical Ethics. Pence, Gregory // Journal of the History of Medicine & Allied Sciences;Jan2011, Vol. 66 Issue 1, p136 

    A review of the book "The Cambridge World History of Medical Ethics," by Robert Baker and Laurence McCullough is presented.

  • Food for thought: ethics case discussion as slow nourishment in a fast world. Higgs, Roger // Journal of Medical Ethics;Jan2015, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p91 

    Case discussion offers important opportunities to do good medical ethics, but do we understand what the benefits might be? This paper looks at the 'Case Conference' series in the JME, its origins and methods, examines some cases in outline, and reviews issues that arise that are not usually...

  • JAMA 100 Years Ago. Reiling, Jennifer // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;5/26/99, Vol. 281 Issue 20, p1874d 

    Reprints articles from the May 27, 1899 issue of `Journal of the American Medical Association.' German surgeon who changed the operation intended while the patient was under anesthesia; Legal problems that resulted; Matricide committed and plea of insanity and justification on account of belief...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics