Assessing Evaluation Fidelity: An Examination of Student Comments and Scores on Speech Self-Evaluation Forms in a General Education Communication Course

Mazer, Joseph P.; Simonds, Cheri J.; Hunt, Stephen K.
October 2013
Ohio Communication Journal;2013, Vol. 51, p1
Academic Journal
Scholars have noted that assessment is essential to not only guide the development of individual students but also to monitor and continuously improve the quality of general education programs and remain accountable to administrators and external agencies (Gardiner, 1994). Given that the introductory communication course is a key element of most general education programs across the nation, it serves as an ideal platform to implement and assess student communication skills. This study explores student comments on two versions of informative and persuasive speech self- evaluations--an open-ended self-evaluation and a form that mirrors an instructor evaluation form. Results failed to reveal a strong association between the number of student comments and scores on a self-evaluation that mirrors the instructor evaluation form. However, analyses revealed a significant difference between the overall scores that students provided on self-evaluations and scores that instructors provided on their identical evaluation form. Findings indicated that students provided critical comments, but did not provide scores that were reflective of the criteria for evaluation. The findings suggest that instructors must better train their students to be more reflective of the criteria during the self-evaluation process. Implications for general education, classroom pedagogy, and course management are discussed.


Related Articles

  • Self-assessing general education outcomes at a community college. Kiger, Derick M. // Community College Review;Spring96, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p49 

    Examines a community college's degree of success in incorporating general education into its technical curriculum based on data from students' self-assessment. Students' self-assessed degree of improvement on the general education competencies established by the institution; Students'...

  • In the winter issue. Tritelli, David // Liberal Education;Spring2012, Vol. 98 Issue 2, p4 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue and in the winter issue on topics including diversity and civic learning as essential aspects of liberal education, workforce preparation and training in higher education's mission, and educational quality.

  • Selected Psychological Temperaments Relating to Self-Assessment on Research Capability of Undergraduate Students in Faculty of Education at Mahasarakham University. Srisa-ard, Oranuch; Luanganggoon, Nuchwana; Anantarak, Montree; Isarapreeda, Prasart // European Journal of Social Sciences;Jun2011, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p584 

    The quality of learning includes the ability of the learners to develop within themselves a capability for self-assessment: to revise, reflect and improve performance for life-long learning. The purposes of this research were to 1) examine selected psychological temperaments: self-concept,...

  • Reviving the Concept of Residential College in Taiwan: An Introductory Study. Yueh-Luen Hu; Guang-Chu Hung; Gregory Ching; Ching-Fen Liao // International Proceedings of Economics Development & Research;2013, Vol. 64, p12 

    The paper discusses the revival of the concept of residential colleges in Taiwan higher education. A comparison of the various objectives and strategies of four key institutions is accomplished. Within the model of residential colleges, it is said that a quality education experience is not...

  • Adaptation of first-year students to training in college. Matushevich, L. V.; Matushevich, D. V. // Contemporary Higher Education: Innovative Aspects / Sovremennaia;Oct2012, Issue 4, p202 

    A prog-ramme of work with first year students developed on the basis of the verified methods is presented. The approbation of the programme revealed positive impact of different forms and methods on higher interest to learning, lower aggression, higher self-assessment and, hence, better quality...

  • STVARANJE INKLUZIVNE KULTURE Å KOLE. IVANČIĆ, ĐURĐICA; STANČIĆ, ZRINJKA // Croatian Review of Rehabilitation Research / Hrvatska Revija za ;2013, Vol. 49 Issue 2, p139 

    Speaking in the contemporary context of education and school education as the transferor, necessarily talk about culture in education and the culture of the school. The paper also analyzes the concept of inclusive education and culture clearly considers its factors in relation to inclusive...

  • Creating Community College Roadmaps for Success. McNAIR, TIA // Peer Review;Spring2013, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p3 

    The article discusses aspects of the Developing a Community College Roadmap project that develops institutional models for student success in the U.S. It notes that 12 community colleges have participated in the project which aims to advance learning and career of college student. It explains...

  • Promoting the Quality of Chinese Higher Vocational Education by General Education. Yongbo Lai; Hongyao Ni // Creative Education;Nov2012, Vol. 3 Issue 7, p1184 

    Due to the quality lack of Chinese higher vocational education, this paper analyzes the quality of the higher vocational education, from the point of dominant and recessive qualities of cultivating talents respectively. Based on the present situation of vocational education, this paper puts...

  • A New Paradigm for Liberal Education. THOMPSON JR., ROBERT J. // Liberal Education;Summer2014, Vol. 100 Issue 3, p36 

    The article presents the author's views on a developmental approach for liberal undergraduate education in the U.S. He states that higher education has been the target of calls for reforms and criticisms due to the poor quality and escalating costs. He argues that higher education must adopt a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics