Accuracy and Variability of Isochronous Rhythmic Timing Across Motor Systems in Stuttering Versus Nonstuttering Individuals

Max, Ludo; Yudman, Elana M.
February 2003
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Feb2003, Vol. 46 Issue 1, p146
Academic Journal
Ten adults who stutter and ten adults who do not stutter completed speech, orofacial nonspeech, and finger isochronous rhythmic timing tasks in a synchronization-continuation paradigm with auditory stimuli and with 450 ms, 650 ms, and 850 ms interstimulus onset intervals. Responses consisted of bilabial contact in the syllable /pa/ during a speech task, bilabial contact in an orofacial nonspeech task, and thumb-index finger contact in a finger movement task. Effector movements were transduced, and time points associated with minima in the derived lip or finger aperture signals were automatically extracted. Multiple analyses of timing accuracy and variability were completed for both the synchronization and continuation phases, including decomposition of total timing variance into central clock and motor implementation variance according to the Wing-Kristofferson model. The combined results from descriptive comparisons, statistical significance testing, and effect size computations suggest that the stuttering and nonstuttering participants showed highly similar levels of both timing accuracy and timing variability. This was true (a) for all three motor tasks, (b) at all movement rates, and (c) for synchronization as well as continuation movements. As one component of a systematic approach to investigating the role, if any, of timing difficulties in stuttering, these findings extend growing evidence that stuttering individuals do not differ from nonstuttering individuals in the ability to generate temporal movement patterns with a simple isochronous rhythm. We present some hypotheses about the implications that may follow from brain imaging and clinical neurological studies that have investigated the neural substrates recruited by this particular experimental task.


Related Articles

  • Words Fail Me. Whirty, Ryan // Indianapolis Monthly;May2003, Vol. 26 Issue 10, p90 

    Focuses on stuttering and problems faced by the author due to it. There are three million stutterers in the U.S., people for whom the simple act of talking is an often-humiliating, nerve-wracking experience. Stuttering is like other conditions that negatively affect normal, everyday human...

  • Understanding stuttering.  // Current Health 1;Sep98, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p29 

    Discusses the causes of stuttering. How to talk to people who stutter; List of the famous people who stuttered.

  • Commentary on 'A Theory of Neuropsycholinguistic Function in Stuttering'. Smith, Anne // Journal of Speech & Hearing Research;Aug92, Vol. 35 Issue 4, p805 

    Comments on a study which proposed a neuropsycholinguistic theory of stuttering. Definition of stuttering; Analysis on the absence of citations to experimental work; Assessment on the theory.

  • Long-Term Follow-up of Self-Modeling as an Intervention for Stuttering. Bray, Melissa A.; Kehle, Thomas J. // School Psychology Review;2001, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p135 

    Reports on a long-tern follow-up of the effects of self-modeling on the reduction of stuttering in two groups of students. Percentage of the students who exhibited normal fluency and dysfluency after a four-year follow-up period; Number of students who maintained their treatment effects; Speech...

  • Stuttering--no problem! Kelly, Elizabeth; Fallows, Carol // Australia's Parents;Apr/May99, Issue 110, p67 

    Provides information stuttering, a speech disorder. Causes; Treatment; Information on America's National Stuttering Project.

  • Stuttering. Benaroch, Roy // Pediatrics for Parents;2008, Vol. 24 Issue 8, p14 

    The article provides an answer to a question on how to help a kid from stuttering.

  • Interpreting results of the fluent speech paradigm in stuttering research: Difficulties in... Armson, Joy; Kalinowski, Joseph // Journal of Speech & Hearing Research;Feb94, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p69 

    Examines difficulties in interpreting results of studies that compare the fluent speech characteristics of stutterers and nonstutterers. Temporal parameters of fluent speech production; Context of experimental samples; Treatment history of subjects; Stuttering severity of subjects;...

  • Evaluating differences between stuttering and nonstuttering speakers: The group difference design. Young, Martin A. // Journal of Speech & Hearing Research;Jun94, Vol. 37 Issue 3, p522 

    Focuses on suggested analytical indices to be used in group difference research comparing stuttering with nonstuttering speakers. Relationship of group difference design to underlying conceptualizations of the nature of stuttering; Development, interpretation and application of the analytical...

  • Intersyllabic movement timing in the fluent speech of stutters with different disfluency levels. McClean, Michael D.; Levandowski, Donna R. // Journal of Speech & Hearing Research;Oct94, Vol. 37 Issue 5, p1060 

    Discusses a study on intersyllabic movement timing in the fluent speech of stutterers with different disfluency levels. Identification of possible differences in movement timing in the fluent speech of adult stutterers as the goal of the study; Measures of speech disfluency; Speech kinematics.

  • Disfluency clusters of children who stutter: Relation of stutterings to self-repairs. LaSalle, Lisa R.; Conture, Edward G. // Journal of Speech & Hearing Research;Oct95, Vol. 38 Issue 5, p965 

    Accounts for the frequency, type and possible origins of speech disfluency clusters in the spontaneous speech of three to six-year old children who do and do not stutter. Covert Repair Hypothesis (CRH) of stuttering; Number and nature of speech disfluencies and errors; Speculations to the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics