Assessment methods in surgical training in the United Kingdom

Evgeniou, Evgenios; Peter, Loizou; Tsironi, Maria; Iyer, Srinivasan
January 2013
Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions;2013, Vol. 10, p1
Academic Journal
A career in surgery in the United Kingdom demands a commitment to a long journey of assessment. The assessment methods used must ensure that the appropriate candidates are selected into a programme of study or a job and must guarantee public safety by regulating the progression of surgical trainees and the certification of trained surgeons. This review attempts to analyse the psychometric properties of various assessment methods used in the selection of candidates to medical school, job selection, progression in training, and certification. Validity is an indicator of how well an assessment measures what it is designed to measure. Reliability informs us whether a test is consistent in its outcome by measuring the reproducibility and discriminating ability of the test. In the long journey of assessment in surgical training, the same assessment formats are frequently being used for selection into a programme of study, job selection, progression, and certification. Although similar assessment methods are being used for different purposes in surgical training, the psychometric properties of these assessment methods have not been examined separately for each purpose. Because of the significance of these assessments for trainees and patients, their reliability and validity should be examined thoroughly in every context where the assessment method is being used.


Related Articles

  • Implementing Assessment Engineering in the Uniform Certified. Burke, Matthew; Devore, Richard; Stopek, Josh // Journal of Applied Testing Technology;Apr2013, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    This paper describes efforts to bring principled assessment design to a large-scale, highstakes licensure examination by employing the frameworks of Assessment Engineering (AE), the Revised Bloom's Taxonomy (RBT), and Cognitive Task Analysis (CTA). The Uniform CPA Examination is...

  • The effect of medical school on postgraduate fitness to practise decisions: a retrospective cohort study. Sanders, Alexander; Taylor, Celia A // British Journal of Hospital Medicine (17508460);Oct2013, Vol. 74 Issue 10, p581 

    The article presents the retrospective cohort study which analysed the effects of medical school on the incidence of General Medical Council fitness to practise sanctions in Great Britain. In the study, data from an electronic version of the List of Registered Medical Practitioners (LRMP) issued...

  • WORLD IN BRIEF.  // Nursing Standard;2/29/2012, Vol. 26 Issue 26, p9 

    The article presents information on several topics related to medicine, including information on Japan's annual nursing examination, an Internet employee recruitment advertisement for Stockholm South General Hospital and a petition which is being circulated in Australia by Australian nurses.

  • Demonstrating Construct Validity of the American Board of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Part I Examination: An Analysis of Dimensionality. Raddatz, Mikaela M.; Robinson, Lawrence R. // PM & R: Journal of Injury, Function & Rehabilitation;Oct2017, Vol. 9 Issue 10, p985 

    Background: Ideally, high-stakes examinations assess 1 dimension of medical knowledge to produce precise estimates of a candidate's performance. It has not been reported whether the American Board of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Part 1 Certification Examination (ABPMR-CE-1)...

  • BOOK REVIEWS. Best of Five MCQs for MRCPsych Paper 3. Turner, Trevor // British Journal of Hospital Medicine (17508460);Dec2010, Vol. 71 Issue 12, p716 

    The article reviews the book "Best of Five MCQs for MRCPsych Paper 3," by Lena Palaniyappan and Rajeev Krishnadas.

  • PROPUESTA DE EVALUACIÓN PARA LAS PRÁCTICAS FORMATIVAS EN ENFERMERIA. Gómez Díaz, Martha Patricia; Laguado Jaimes, Elveny // Revista Cuidarte;ene-dic2013, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p502 

    Introduction: The Nursing Program of the Cooperative University of Colombia in Bucaramanga, in their curriculum skills training competencies leads to modify the traditional evaluation of training practices, for an evaluation to acquire the skills for problem solving and applicability of concepts...

  • WORLD IN BRIEF.  // Nursing Standard;1/30/2013, Vol. 27 Issue 22, p10 

    The article presents information on several topics related to medicine, including information on a one year internship for nurses and midwives in Ghana who want to work with children and young people, support which the Fiji Nurses Association has voiced for a government initiative to recruit...

  • Educational Disaster In The Making. Jones, David R. // New York Amsterdam News;03/25/99, Vol. 90 Issue 13, p4 

    Focuses on the disadvantages of upgrading Regents English examinations for public high school students in the United States. Plan for the implementation of the examination as a requirement for graduation; Need for reform in the early childhood education system; Need for increased professional...

  • Correlations Between PANCE Performance, Physician Assistant Program Grade Point Average, and Selection Criteria. Brown, Gina; Imel, Brittany; Nelson, Alyssa; Hale, Ladonna S.; Jansen, Nick // Journal of Physician Assistant Education (Physician Assistant Ed;2013, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p42 

    Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine correlations between first-time Physician Assistant National Certifying Exam (PANCE) scores and pass/fail status, physician assistant (PA) program didactic grade point average (GPA), and specific selection criteria. Methods: This retrospective...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics