An economic model to evaluate cost-effectiveness of computer assisted knee replacement surgery in Norway

Gøthesen, Øystein; Slover, James; Havelin, Leif; Askildsen, Jan Erik; Malchau, Henrik; Furnes, Ove
August 2013
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders;2013, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: The use of Computer Assisted Surgery (CAS) for knee replacements is intended to improve the alignment of knee prostheses in order to reduce the number of revision operations. Is the cost effectiveness of computer assisted surgery influenced by patient volume and age? Methods: By employing a Markov model, we analysed the cost effectiveness of computer assisted surgery versus conventional arthroplasty with respect to implant survival and operation volume in two theoretical Norwegian age cohorts. We obtained mortality and hospital cost data over a 20-year period from Norwegian registers. We presumed that the cost of an intervention would need to be below NOK 500,000 per QALY (Quality Adjusted Life Year) gained, to be considered cost effective. Results: The added cost of computer assisted surgery, provided this has no impact on implant survival, is NOK 1037 and NOK 1414 respectively for 60 and 75-year-olds per quality-adjusted life year at a volume of 25 prostheses per year, and NOK 128 and NOK 175 respectively at a volume of 250 prostheses per year. Sensitivity analyses showed that the 10-year implant survival in cohort 1 needs to rise from 89.8% to 90.6% at 25 prostheses per year, and from 89.8 to 89.9% at 250 prostheses per year for computer assisted surgery to be considered cost effective. In cohort 2, the required improvement is a rise from 95.1% to 95.4% at 25 prostheses per year, and from 95.10% to 95.14% at 250 prostheses per year. Conclusions: The cost of using computer navigation for total knee replacements may be acceptable for 60-year-old as well as 75-year-old patients if the technique increases the implant survival rate just marginally, and the department has a high operation volume. A low volume department might not achieve cost-effectiveness unless computer navigation has a more significant impact on implant survival, thus may defer the investments until such data are available.


Related Articles

  • Two year follow-up comparing computer assisted versus freehand TKR on joint stability, muscular function and patients satisfaction. Lüring, C.; Oczipka, F.; Perlick, L.; Tingart, M.; Grifka, J.; Bäthis, H. // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Mar2009, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p228 

    Computer assisted (CAS) knee surgery has been established in clinical routine. There is still no study that investigates clinical outcome. Fifty patients who received a primary total knee replacement 2 years before were investigated. These patients were divided into two groups of matched-pairs;...

  • Cutting errors in total knee replacement: assessment by computer assisted surgery. Yau, W.; Chiu, K. // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Aug2008, Vol. 16 Issue 7, p670 

    The observed errors in the position of the implanted prosthesis can be due to a number of potential causes. One of these is the potential error during execution of the bone cuts. However, there is only minimal information on this in the current literature. The amount of cutting errors in 40...

  • Computer-assisted surgery for total knee arthroplasty: more than just "boy toys" for the passionate few. Point. Hofmann, Aaron A. // Orthopedics;Sep2005, Vol. 28 Issue 9, p940 

    Focuses on the introduction of computer-assisted surgery for total knee arthroplasty in the U.S. in 2001. Different types of computer-assisted systems; Navigation systems that have been developed by manufacturers working in conjunction with orthopedic implant companies; Uses of the universal...

  • Computer-Assisted Surgery: Still Just "Boy Toys" for the Passionate Few. Hungerford, David S. // Orthopedics;Sep2005, Vol. 28 Issue 9, p941 

    Focuses on the issue on whether surgeons who perform total knee replacements (TKR) are ready to incorporate computer-assisted surgery into their practices. Main determinant of success and longevity in TKR; Disadvantages of computer-assisted surgery; Factors that influence surgeons to use TKR...

  • Differences Between Extramedullary, Intramedullary, and Computer-Aided Surgery Tibial Alignment Techniques for Total Knee Arthroplasty. Mihalko, William M.; Krackow, Kenneth A. // Journal of Knee Surgery (SLACK Incorporated);Jan2006, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p33 

    Traditionally, intramedullary and extramedullary tibial alignment techniques are used to obtain neutral alignment during total knee arthroplasty. Computer-assisted techniques are available to aid in obtaining alignment intraoperatively. This study analyzed the difference in tibial alignment...

  • Fine Tuning Your Next Total Knee: Computer Assisted Surgery. Krackow, Kenneth A. // Orthopedics;Sep2003, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p971 

    The article discusses the development of computer-assisted surgery in orthopedics. It presents an overview of how these equipment play a vital role in total knee replacement and other surgeries. It details the advantages and limitations of computer-assisted surgery. It describes the development...

  • A five to seven year follow-up comparing computer-assisted vs freehand TKR with regard to clinical parameters. Lüring, C.; Kauper, M.; Bäthis, H.; Perlick, L.; Beckmann, J.; Grifka, J.; Tingart, M.; Rath, B. // International Orthopaedics;Mar2012, Vol. 36 Issue 3, p553 

    Purpose: Computer-assisted knee surgery has become established in routine clinical practice. Still, there is no study investigating midterm clinical outcome after five to seven years postoperatively. We aimed to test the hypothesis that there is no difference either for subjective [Western...

  • Process Optimization in Navigated Total Knee Arthroplasty. Walde, Tim Alexander; Burgdorf, Dirk; Walde, Hans-Joachim // Orthopedics;Oct2005 Supplement, Vol. 28, ps1255 

    Although navigation achieves better alignment results in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), it is generally assumed that navigation also needs more time and effort than conventional surgeries. After optimizing the treatment procedure of navigated TKA, the operation times needed for navigated...

  • COMPUTER-ASSISTED SURGERY VERSUS MANUAL TOTAL KNEE ARTHROPLASTY: A CASE-CONTROLLED STUDY. Stulberg, S. David; Yaffe, Mark A.; Koo, Samuel S. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Dec2006 Supplement 4, Vol. 88-A, p47 

    The article presents information on a study that determines the impact of experience with computer-assisted surgery on the manual technique of total knee arthroplasty. In the study, researchers compare the clinical, patient-perceived functional, and radio graphic results of manually performed...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics