Debating multiple positions in multi-party online deliberation: Sides, positions, and cases

Lewiński, Marcin
January 2013
Journal of Argumentation in Context;Jan2013, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p151
Academic Journal
Dialectical approaches traditionally conceptualize argumentation as a discussion in which two parties debate on 'two sides of an issue' (pro and con). However, many political issues engender multiple positions. This is clear in multi-party online deliberations in which often an array of competing positions is debated in one and the same discussion. A proponent of a given position thus addresses a number of possible opponents, who in turn may hold incompatible opinions. The goal of this paper is to shed extra light on such 'polylogical' clash of opinions in online deliberation, by examining the multi-layered participation in actual online debates. The examples are drawn from the readers' discussions on Osama bin Laden's killing in online versions of two British newspapers: The Guardian and The Telegraph. As a result of the analysis, a distinction between sides, positions, and cases in argumentative deliberation is proposed.


Related Articles

  • THE INFLUENCE OF THE OPPORTUNISTIC BEHAVIOR ON THE CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIP. Kundakchyan, Rezeda M.; Grigoryeva, Natalia S. // Journal of Economics & Economic Education Research;2016 Special Issue, Vol. 17, p68 

    The paper deals with the nature of influence of opportunistic behavior of economic agents on the implementation of contractual cooperation. Opportunism can apply to any form of interaction between economic subjects; it implies an increase of transactional costs including the costs of destructive...

  • ANCHORAGE IN ORGANIZATION: A DIALECTICAL THEORY. Grosof, Elliofl H.; Gross, Llewellyn Z.; Yeracaris, Constantine A.; Hobbs, Walter C. // Social Forces;Sep70, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p81 

    This paper presents a theory of participant behavior in (hospital) organizations which integrates internal and external cultural influences on such behavior. Emphasis is placed upon the relationship between extra-organizational variables (especially ascribed and achieved statuses) and model...

  • Network News Bible study. Arnold, Earl // Network News;Mar/Apr92, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p2 

    Focuses on the world in crisis. Apocalyptic proportions; Debates on the end of the world; Separation and marking-off of the faithful servants of God; Agenda of the church.

  • Reflections on the agenda for transformation. Erickson, Theodore // Network News;Mar/Apr92, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p3 

    Presents ideas on crisis theology. Persistence of slavery; Goal of a common humanity; Political, social and economic overtones; Danger and opportunity resulting from crisis; Calling to Christians.

  • Recuperar la política desde la deliberación. Brugué, Quim // International Journal of Organizations / Revista Internacional d;dic2011, Issue 7, p157 

    Politics is in difficulties. It is constantly blamed by people, who also require it to respond. The world is increasingly complex and diverse, and politics is needed to facilitate the continuity of a civilized community. The article defines the conceptual and operative bases of deliberative...

  • Teaching Corporate Finance Via Computer Conferencing: An Application for Executive Education. McCue, Michael J.; DeLellis, Anthony J. // Financial Practice & Education;Spring/Summer93, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p55 

    Describes the application of computer conferencing in the core Corporate Finance course for the Executive Program in Health Services Administration at Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) in Richmond, Virginia. Benefits of the use of computer conferencing; Basic mechanics; Course structure;...

  • Video conferencing: LV businesses are in the picture. Yakubik, Paula // Las Vegas Business Press;2/6/95, Vol. 12 Issue 5, p1 

    Reports on various Las Vegas, Nevada-based corporations' use of video conferencing facilities. Comments from Station Casinos Inc.'s vice president and chief operating officer Joseph Canfora; Danvers, Massachusetts-based Picture Tel's introduction of computer video conferencing system in the area.

  • Table for One. Ostendorf, Virginia A. // Satellite Communications;Sep98, Vol. 22 Issue 9, p100 

    Focuses on the development of technology for desktop video to compete with group video conference systems. Advantages of modern video conferencing; Information about desktop video systems; Common uses of desktop video.

  • Talk shows in cyberspace. Flynn, Mary Kathleen // U.S. News & World Report;7/4/94, Vol. 117 Issue 1, p70 

    Examines how live public conferences that link plain folks to big names, through computer online services like CompuServe, America Online and Prodigy, are giving new meaning to the televised `town meeting.' Similarity of online conferences to talk shows; Need to express oneself via the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics