Dropout among patients in qualified alcohol detoxification treatment: the effect of treatment motivation is moderated by Trauma Load

Odenwald, Michael; Semrau, Peter
June 2013
Substance Abuse Treatment, Prevention & Policy;2013, Vol. 8, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Motivation to change has been proposed as a prerequisite for behavioral change, although empirical results are contradictory. Traumatic experiences are frequently found amongst patients in alcohol treatment, but this has not been systematically studied in terms of effects on treatment outcomes. This study aimed to clarify whether individual Trauma Load explains some of the inconsistencies between motivation to change and behavioral change. Methods: Over the course of two months in 2009, 55 patients admitted to an alcohol detoxification unit of a psychiatric hospital were enrolled in this study. At treatment entry, we assessed lifetime Trauma Load and motivation to change. Mode of discharge was taken from patient files following therapy. We tested whether Trauma Load moderates the effect of motivation to change on dropout from alcohol detoxification using multivariate methods. Results: 55.4% dropped out of detoxification treatment, while 44.6% completed the treatment. Age, gender and days in treatment did not differ between completers and dropouts. Patients who dropped out reported more traumatic event types on average than completers. Treatment completers had higher scores in the URICA subscale Maintenance. Multivariate methods confirmed the moderator effect of Trauma Load: among participants with high Trauma Load, treatment completion was related to higher Maintenance scores at treatment entry; this was not true among patients with low Trauma Load. Conclusions: We found evidence that the effect of motivation to change on detoxification treatment completion is moderated by Trauma Load: among patients with low Trauma Load, motivation to change is not relevant for treatment completion; among highly burdened patients, however, who a priori have a greater risk of dropping out, a high motivation to change might make the difference. This finding justifies targeted and specific interventions for highly burdened alcohol patients to increase their motivation to change.


Related Articles

  • Clean and Sober. Keel, Beverly // People;5/3/2004, Vol. 61 Issue 17, p95 

    Jo Dee Messina's reputation as the hardest-working woman in country music is well-earned: The New England-born singer of the hits" I' m Alright" and" Bye, Bye" toured nonstop after her 1996 debut, while charting a dozen Top 10 singles and two platinum albums. Then, last summer, Messina broke...

  • TREATMENTS THAT WORK. Gonzalez, Theresa // Working Mother;Nov2010, Vol. 33 Issue 8, p42 

    The article focuses on the three treatment options for alcoholics. It states that addiction specialist Vincent Casolaro uses group sessions with family members to support recovery of patients. Meanwhile, the Closing the Addiction Treatment Gap at Open Society Foundations program by Victor...

  • Avoidance of Alcohol-Related Stimuli Increases During the Early Stage of Abstinence in Alcohol-Dependent Patients. Vollstädt-Klein, Sabine; Loeber, Sabine; Von der Goltz, Christoph; Mann, Karl; Kiefer, Falk // Alcohol & Alcoholism;Sep/Oct2009, Vol. 44 Issue 5, p458 

    Aims: The aim of this study was to analyse initial orienting processes as well as maintenance of attention towards alcohol cues in recently detoxified alcoholics and light social drinkers. Furthermore, we investigated the influence of pre-treatment alcohol consumption and abstinence duration...

  • The impact of detoxification on the coping strategies in a sample of inpatient alcoholics. Tzavellas, Elias; Paparrigopoulos, Thomas; Karaiskos, Dimitrios; Stefanis, Nikos; Komporozos, Agellos; Liappas, John // Annals of General Psychiatry;2008 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background In our study we investigate some aspects of the coping strategies and the impact of detoxification on these characteristics in a sample of inpatient alcohol dependent individuals. Materials and methods The sample of the study comprised 200 Caucasian, Greek nationality patients (147...


    It is a well-known fact that alcohol affects sex hormone levels in males. Even in the absence of liver dysfunction, there is still a direct toxic effect of ethanol on testosterone synthesis resulting in acutely decreased values. This study is based on 29 male alcoholics without severe signs of...

  • RECURRENT DETOXIFICATIONS ARE ASSOCIATED WITH CRAVING IN PATIENTS CLASSIFIED AS TYPE 1 ACCORDING TO LESCH'S TYPOLOGY. Hillemacher, Thomas; Bayerlein, Krishna; Wilhelm, Julia; Bönsch, Dominikus; Poleo, Daniela; Sperling, Wolfgang; Kornhuber, Johannes; Bleich, Stefan // Alcohol & Alcoholism;Jan/Feb2006, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p66 

    Aims: Recurrent detoxifications have been suggested to be associated with elevated alcohol craving. The aim of this investigation was to study the influence of preceding detoxifications on craving in patients with alcoholism classified according to Lesch's typology. Methods: We examined 192...

  • The Performance of Two Motivation Measures and Outcome after Alcohol Detoxification. Freyer-Adam, Jennis; Coder, Beate; Ottersbach, Caspar; Tonigan, J. Scott; Rumpf, Hans-Jürgen; John, Ulrich; Hapke, Ulfert // Alcohol & Alcoholism;Jan/Feb2009, Vol. 44 Issue 1, p77 

    Abstract Aims: The aims of this study were to investigate the performance of the treatment version of the Readiness to Change Questionnaire (RCQ[TV]) among individuals currently receiving alcohol detoxification and to develop a treatment version of the Treatment Readiness Tool (TReaT[TV])....

  • A structured programme for out-patient alcohol detoxification. Collins, Mark N.; Burns, Tom; Van den Berk, Peter A.H.; Tubman, Gary F.; Collins, M N; Burns, T; van den Berk, P A; Tubman, G F // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jun90, Vol. 156, p871 

    An out-patient alcohol detoxification service based in a psychiatric emergency clinic is described. Of 173 patients referred during the first year, 76 (44%) were accepted for the programme; 60 (79%) of these successfully completed detoxification with no medical complications. Compared with...

  • Longitudinal Models for Studying Multivariate Changes and Dynamics. Ferrer, Emilio; Gonzales, Joseph E. // Annals of Nutrition & Metabolism;Nov2014, Vol. 65 Issue 2/3, p184 

    In this paper, we describe a longitudinal modeling approach for examining multivariate changes and dynamics. This technique is based on latent change scores and is executed using a structural equation modeling framework. We provide an overview of the model, describing desirable features for...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics