Effects of Management Tactics on Meeting Conservation Objectives for Western North American Groundfish Fisheries

Melnychuk, Michael C.; Banobi, Jeannette A.; Hilborn, Ray
February 2013
PLoS ONE;Feb2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p1
Academic Journal
There is considerable variability in the status of fish populations around the world and a poor understanding of how specific management characteristics affect populations. Overfishing is a major problem in many fisheries, but in some regions the recent tendency has been to exploit stocks at levels below their maximum sustainable yield. In Western North American groundfish fisheries, the status of individual stocks and management systems among regions are highly variable. In this paper, we show the current status of groundfish stocks from Alaska, British Columbia, and the U.S. West Coast, and quantify the influence on stock status of six management tactics often hypothesized to affect groundfish. These tactics are: the use of harvest control rules with estimated biological reference points; seasonal closures; marine reserves; bycatch constraints; individual quotas (i.e., ‘catch shares’); and gear type. Despite the high commercial value of many groundfish and consequent incentives for maintaining stocks at their most productive levels, most stocks were managed extremely conservatively, with current exploitation rates at only 40% of management targets and biomass 33% above target biomass on average. Catches rarely exceeded TACs but on occasion were far below TACs (mean catch:TAC ratio of 57%); approximately $150 million of potential landed value was foregone annually by underutilizing TACs. The use of individual quotas, marine reserves, and harvest control rules with estimated limit reference points had little overall effect on stock status. More valuable fisheries were maintained closer to management targets and were less variable over time than stocks with lower catches or ex-vessel prices. Together these results suggest there is no single effective management measure for meeting conservation objectives; if scientifically established quotas are set and enforced, a variety of means can be used to ensure that exploitation rates and biomass levels are near to or more conservative than management targets.


Related Articles

  • Dreams as big as an ocean. Holmes, Bob // New Scientist;08/30/97, Vol. 155 Issue 2097, p20 

    Focuses on conservation biologists' warning that marine ecosystems and fish stocks may decline unless a fifth of the world's oceans are protected. Circulation of a statement on the Internet calling all nations to set aside 20 percent of the ocean's total area by 2020; Countries which have made...

  • Failure to eliminate overfishing and attain optimum yield in the New England groundfish fishery. Rothschild, Brian J.; Keiley, Emily F.; Jiao, Yue // ICES Journal of Marine Science / Journal du Conseil;Jan2014, Vol. 71 Issue 2, p226 

    Rothschild, B. J., Keiley, E. F., and Jiao, Y. 2014. Failure to eliminate overfishing and attain optimum yield in the New England groundfish fishery. – ICES Journal of Marine Science, 71: 226–233.Under US law, fishery management is required to eliminate overfishing and attain...

  • Seeing Is Believing. Helmuth, Laura // Smithsonian;Sep2008, Vol. 39 Issue 6, p56 

    This article discusses research conducted by Loren McClenachan, a graduate student studying historical marine ecology. It is stated that scientists in this field use resources like old photographs, newspapers, and ships' logs to determine how the number and variety of fish that inhabit the...

  • A Statistical Model for Estimation of Fish Density Including Correlation in Size, Space, Time and between Species from Research Survey Data. Nielsen, J. Rasmus; Kristensen, Kasper; Lewy, Peter; Bastardie, Francois // PLoS ONE;Jun2014, Vol. 9 Issue 6, p1 

    Trawl survey data with high spatial and seasonal coverage were analysed using a variant of the Log Gaussian Cox Process (LGCP) statistical model to estimate unbiased relative fish densities. The model estimates correlations between observations according to time, space, and fish size and...

  • Preventing overexploitation of migratory fish stocks: the efficacy of marine protected areas in a stochastic environment. West, Christopher D.; Dytham, Calvin; Righton, David; Pitchford, Jonathan W. // ICES Journal of Marine Science / Journal du Conseil;Oct2009, Vol. 66 Issue 9, p1919 

    West, C. D., Dytham, C., Righton, D., and Pitchford, J.W. 2009. Preventing overexploitation of migratory fish stocks: the efficacy of marine protected areas in a stochastic environment. – ICES Journal of Marine Science, 66: 1919–1930.Marine protected areas (MPAs) have been widely...

  • Privatize to Save the Fish. Kratz, Bridget; Block, Walter E. // World Future Review (Sage Publications Inc.);Sep2013, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p256 

    Fish stocks have been depleting, due to the reasonable desire of nations and individuals to maximize their self-interest, which brings about overfishing. This problem, popularly known as the “tragedy of the commons,” is described here in detail, and several solutions are offered,...

  • Scotland's sea lochs deserve special protection. Pearce, Fred // New Scientist;11/26/94, Vol. 144 Issue 1953, p8 

    Reports that sea lochs on the west coast of Scotland may contain Great Britain's richest marine ecosystems and should have top priority in conservation. Biotypes identified on Scottish sea lochs; Sites of richest sea lochs; Fishing nets scraping along the bottom as the biggest threat to life in...

  • Using vessel monitoring system (VMS) data to assess the impact of marine protection boundaries on blue ling fishing northwest of the British Isles. Posen, Paulette E.; Lee, Janette; Large, Philip A.; Kenny, Andrew J. // Aquatic Living Resources;Jan2014, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p17 

    In 2009, the European Commission set restricted fishing areas northwest of the British Isles to protect deep-sea vulnerable marine ecosystems and fish stocks. Two protection areas which, historically, have been targeted by fisheries directed at blue ling (Molva dypterygia), were defined. The...

  • A Global Estimate of the Number of Coral Reef Fishers. Teh, Louise S. L.; Teh, Lydia C. L.; Sumaila, U. Rashid // PLoS ONE;Jun2013, Vol. 8 Issue 6, p1 

    Overfishing threatens coral reefs worldwide, yet there is no reliable estimate on the number of reef fishers globally. We address this data gap by quantifying the number of reef fishers on a global scale, using two approaches - the first estimates reef fishers as a proportion of the total number...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics